warm butternut squash and chickpea salad
I’ve mentioned this salad before but I realize that this is one of those recipes I’m going to refresh as often as I can get away with. The second I had these ingredients together — lemon, tahini, butternut squash, garlic, chickpeas — I couldn’t believe it was the first time. They were made to be together, and in the times that I’ve had them apart in other recipes, I always know what they’re missing.
The recipe comes from Molly Wizenberg of Orangette, who adapted it from a cookbook from the UK’s Moro restaurant, but I always forget that part because it’s somehow a quintessential Orangette recipe to me. Molly’s first book comes out this spring and to say that I’m just looking forward to reading it — and making more where has this recipe been my whole life-level favorites like this — might be the understatement of all understatements. To hold me over until it comes out, though, I know exactly what I’ll be eating.
One year ago: Rigatoni with Eggplant Puree
Two years ago: Icebox Cake
Warm Butternut and Chickpea Salad with Tahini Dressing
Adapted from Orangette, who adapted it from Casa Moro
Yield: 4 servings
For salad:
1 medium butternut squash (about 2 to 2 1/2 pounds), peeled, seeded, and cut into 1 1/2-inch pieces
1 medium garlic clove, minced or pressed
1/2 teaspoons ground allspice (I skip this)
2 tablespoons olive oil
Salt
One 15-ounce can chickpeas, drained and rinsed (1 1/2 cups)
1/4 of a medium red onion, finely chopped
1/4 cup coarsely chopped fresh cilantro or parsley
For tahini dressing:
1 medium garlic clove, finely minced with a pinch of salt
1/4 cup lemon juice
3 tablespoons well-stirred tahini
2 tablespoons water
2 tablespoons olive oil, plus more to taste
Preheat the oven to 425°F.
In a large bowl, combine the butternut squash, garlic, allspice, olive oil, and a few pinches of salt. Toss the squash pieces until evenly coated. Roast them on a baking sheet for 25 minutes, or until soft. Remove from the oven and cool.
Meanwhile, make the tahini dressing: In a small bowl, whisk together the garlic and lemon juice. Add the tahini, and whisk to blend. Add the water and olive oil, whisk well, and taste for seasoning. The sauce should have plenty of nutty tahini flavor, but also a little kick of lemon. You will probably need to add more water to thin it out.
To assemble the salad, combine the squash, chickpeas, onion, and cilantro or parsley in a mixing bowl. Either add the tahini dressing to taste, and toss carefully, or you could serve the salad with the dressing on the side. Serve immediately.
Do ahead: Molly says this salad, lightly dressed, keeps beautifully in the fridge, that you should hold a little of the dressing on the side and that it can be reheated in the microwave. I, for one, have never had any leftovers.











This dish is so colourful and beautiful, I’m not sure it should be eaten. It should be admired.
You read my mind! Or my tastebuds. What an awesome combo.
OH this looks absolutely divine!!
Thanks so much for sharing it! Can’t wait to give it a try!
Do you think the dressing can be made a day or two ahead of time? And day of, roast the squash, cool, and dress? Also – would the recipe double well?
I have been making this nonstop since Molly first posted it. Sooooooooo good!
this is sublime with almond butter subbed in for the tahin. yum!
I could not believe that these ingredients would be perfect together. I’ll have to try it. Congratulations for the three awards!
Wow. That is a pretty strong recommendation. And I do just happen to have a butternut squash in my veg bowl begging for a novel use. No tahini in sight however. Might just call for a run to the grocer. Sounds mouthwatering!
Wow, that’s a combination of ingredients I wouldn’t have thought of. Tahini and butternut squash… it’s like eating humus with butternut squash. It’s a new one for me.
Looks amazing too. Of course.
I did make a lovely salad last week with butternut squash, a more conservative one?! With apples, nuts, cranberries, butter lettuce, arugula, and Dijon dressing. It was excellent.
You are great- I can hear the excitement in your writing. I would have never tried this recipe- but based solely on your enthusiasm I may just have to figure out what tahini is and give this a try (I do like butternut squash a great deal).
butternut squash is my favorite kind of squash!!
Ooh, like hummus with squash. And chunks. I like.
Ok, I am done, I’ve read ALL of your recipes, all of your blogs, took me a while (huh, really?) I am ready for a new entry now, hehehe ;-)
Thanks ever so much for the fun and giggles and all the wonderful photo’s!
I am thoroughly happy I bumped into your website (in search of an arborio rice pudding recipe)
I will surely stick around!
Ohmygosh, this looks fantastic. And is right up my current alley, with trying to eat healthier. And is is so very apt for this season!
I am having palpitations just reading and looking. I am so there.
I have been meaning to try this forever, well since Molly wrote about it, so thanks for reminding me.
I do a simlar one to this with couscous, baby spinach leaves and slivered, toasted almonds. So yummy!
This recipe looks so yummy!
We don’t have butternut squash in Italy, though. Do you think I could replace it with pumpkin?
I will eat anything that has tahini in it! This salad looks so delicious.
ooooooooooooo anything that has any of these ingredients is the thing for me, am so making this for dinner tomorrow night!! Can’t wait!!!
I have an acorn squash which I will try this with – it won’t look as lovely without the color of the butternut, but I think will taste almost as delicious.
Thanks for the tahini dressing recipe… I think I will be using that for many other things as well!
Now that is my kind of salad!
Love your website and all your recipes ! Just voted for you!
The presentation in those dishes is beautiful. The orange vegetables reminds me of summer picnics.
I made this awhile back and thought it was great!
This recipe sounds so tasty, and easy enough for me to put together in my dorm kitchen. Thanks for sharing!
I’m awe struck. Butternut squash + chickpeas + tahini would never have crossed my mind, so thanks for opening my eyes. My garden always yields tons of squash so this is perfect to add to the repertoire. I just voted for you and wish you the best. Your blog and cooking style are inspirational. Congratulations!
This looks great. You’ve given me an idea for a different type of salad that’s beautiful and is delicious.
Does this work cold or at room temp? I would love to bring it to a pot-luck after a tennis match, but no way to heat it up–the only options are leave it in the park fridge or let it sit.
Wow – I opened up the site and was stunned by the beautiful pictures – so colorful and pretty!
oh – and the recipe looks good too. :)
This looks absolutely incredible.
I did exactly what you said (to get the Claudia Fleming cookbook) — I went to the North Fork Inn website (http://northforktableandinn.com/) and got a hold of someone on their contact list via email, and voila! It was SO much easier than I thought it would be – and they were so nice!! :)
I am in love with this salad. All the components. And all of them together. It’s so colorful and I’m sure just as flavorful!
This salad is absolutely delicious. I, too, first heard of it over at Orangette.
And to Jenn: I’ve eaten it straight out of the refrig. Its door may or may not still have been open.
This looks so beautiful. I wish I had all of the ingredients in my pantry, and an ice storm is kind of preventing my going anywhere to stock up, but this is for sure on the “to make” list. I can’t wait for her cookbook to come out either!
Deb,
I hope to try this recipe soon. It looks wonderful, but my husband is not a big fan of chickpeas (unless made into hummus), or squash. So, maybe I can tempt him to try it, or maybe I can just eat it all myself. I hope that you win one of the Bloggie Awards and get to come to Austin! Your blog is so good, yet are so modest — you really do deserve to win. Joyce
Glad you’re all as excited about this as I am!
Answers:
I am sure it would double nicely, but you’ll definitely need two trays to cook the squash. There’s no reason it wouldn’t be good cold; honestly, we’ve never had enough leftovers to consider whether it would be good straight from the fridge. I am sure it would also be good at room temperature. If you can’t get butternut squash, another dense squash would work, or perhaps even yams/sweet potatoes.
And tahini, for those of you unfamiliar with it, is a ground sesame seed paste, but it’s closer to a sandy peanut butter in texture. I usually find it in the peanut butter aisle, but it might also be with Middle Eastern groceries. It is also an ingredient in hummus, and I used the extra dressing from this on the smashed chickpea sandwich (yes, I know, we’re completely out of order here).
I’ve only had butternut squash in stuffing. These flavors look like they would be really good with it though.
i too must admit that had i been just flipping through the pages of an old cookbook, might not have stopped at this recipe. but after reading your enthusiasm i feel like i have just sat down to coffee with a good friend over which she recommended me this new fabulous and healthy treat. i love your page too. i found it this summer and havent stopped anticipating the next recipe since. thanks for alll the wonderful recipes, and for often putting a smile on my face with your quirky and fun blogs. best of luck in the blog awards! you rock ;)
Yay, cross continental love between my two favorite blogs!!!!!!!!
This does seem like a classic Orangette recipe. And looks delicious and fresh and filling.
Perfect! I have had a butternut squash sitting around for a couple days..now i can finally decide what to do with it!
I’ve loved this recipe since Molly posted it, too, and I love it even more ever since I started roasting the chickpeas along with the squash.
I’ve been making this since Molly first posted it as well. You’re right, these ingredients are made for each other. I also boil some barley or farro and top with the salad for a great one dish meal. You’re photo’s are lovely as usual.
I have made this several times, and I can attest that it’s one of the best things on earth. I have also eaten it cold from the fridge. Very good. Also good microwaved a bit to take the chill off. If you like hummus, this will take you to a whole new level of deliciousness. Make it tonight.
What might be a good substitute for tahini in this recipe (allergic to sesame and peanut butter)? It sounds lovely but I’m not sure what to substitute in the dressing.
Isn’t Molly great? I can’t wait for her cookbook either. This looks marvelous. I’m with you in not making many things repeatedly, but parmesean butternut squash soup is one of my weaknesses. This looks like a wonderful way to incorporate it in a salad. Love it!
I am the SAME way about eating the same thing twice! I am so glad to find someone like me.. My BF always teases me that I can’t do repeats. But this definitely looks like a repeatable salad. My weird repeatable dish that I make is this quinoa salad w/ black beans, avocado, and tomato. For some reason, I crave it in summer like once a week. Here’s my recipe for it: http://dishthisboston.blogspot.com/2008/09/recipe-quinoa-with-black-beans-avocado.html Love your website!!
i have made this at least a dozen times in the last year since molly posted it! it’s the perfect fall/winter meal.
Love squash! And that is probably one of my favorite dressings. Great idea to mix with chickpeas…I would imagine it tempers the sweetness of the squash a bit. I’ll have to give it a try with my beloved acorn squash.
Oh, perfect. I have had an at least 4 lb butternut squash sitting on my counter staring at me for two weeks now. I can’t wait to try this.
This looks awesome! I can’t wait to try it. I’m also a big fan of Orangette, and I’m really looking forward to her stop in D.C. on her book tour.
I have to tell you, I am making a wedding cake for a friend’s legal ceremony tomorrow (her big wedding is later), and your posts about making a wedding cake really helped to give me some confidence and peace of mind. I’ve been reading your blog for months, but I hadn’t seen those posts before I googled “making a wedding cake.”
Gorgeous photos and it sounds delicious!
just because i trust you and so far you have never led me wrong, I will believe that this is as delicious as you say. because it does not look appealing to me, but then again, i think you are genius so it must be good right. maybe because at first glance i thought it was a warm CITRUS chickpea salad before i realized that was squash.
I have made this more times than I care to admit ever since I first saw it on Orangette. And you’re right, we NEVER ever have leftovers…ever. ;)
The fabulous color of this alone is enough to entice me to give it a try.
WOW – This looks amazing! The colors… YUM
Deb, I’m always in awe of how many new recipes you manage to make each week, so it’s a relief to hear that you do eat *some* things repeatedly! So glad you love this salad as much as I do. And thanks for the sweet words about the book! You sure to know how to make a person blush… xo
You are really having an affair with chickpeas these days! I like them well enough but they aren’t my favorites. Do you think this recipe would be work with canellini or dark kidney beans or would the skins keep the dressing from soaking in enough?
This salad is a family favorite and I have made several variations of it, our favorite of which uses sweet potatoes, cilantro, and toasted pumpkin seeds. Oh, and no allspice. We usually eat it on top of greens, so I always make extra dressing. And I can vouch for the fact that it keeps beautifully and it still tasty straight from the fridge, though I do prefer it at room temp or warmer. Thanks for reminding me about this recipe — we have the ingredients on hand and it will make a great light supper!
Love the fact that you make a lot of mediterranean sytle salads! Interesting concept with the squash! I use alot of chick peas as well, love to cook pilav with chick peas!
Thank you!
Yum, I have all these things on hand in the kitchen right now! You just made my dinner. :)
I have all of these ingredients–lucky me!! Thanks as usual for always posting wonderful tasty recipes.
I’m just about to place another order from Rancho Gordo (man! seriously good) and was considering adding garbanzos this time due to the plethora of must-makes from SK.
Are they that much better than your ordinary store ones? I feel kind of dumb asking, but not wanting to mis-allocate any of my precious food dollars these days…
Oooh, all those colors. Looks like a Crayola love session. Need a plate and fork asap!
Thank you!! I am really trying to eat in season and that means there has not been that many salads lately. I’ve just discovered slaws and that has been sustaining me, but this looks fantastic!
Hi Mixette — I haven’t tried them from Rancho Gordo (actually, didn’t even realize they had garbanzos, but am thrilled) but if their other beans are any indication, they will be better than any you’ve had before.
That looks gorgeous! I never thought to do butternut squash with tahini and lemon but now that you’ve posted this, I’m drooling.
If foods were people, then chickpeas and tahini would be the most perfect couple that ever existed. They’d get married, in fact. It’d be a bigger event than Princess Di’s wedding. And Garlic would walk Chickpea down the aisle…ok, now I’m just getting carried away.
Yes, the Rancho Gordo garbanzo’s are like no others!
and their Christmas Lima’s? The Yellow Indian beans? Oh so good; I’ve been living on brown basmati rice and various bean stews this winter.
I love this recipe! Thank you for reminding me to make it next week. It is wonderful!
did you see? crack-n-cheese is on nytimes and they used your gorgeous photo!
http://bitten.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/01/29/addictive-mac-and-cheese/#comment-36245
I just placed my Rancho Gordo order (and added the Yellow Indian & Xmas Limas – thanks Selkie)
Their website says they’re running low on the garbanzos, so hurry on over if you’re tempted!
This is so beautiful and looks yummy too! Love the ingredients – anything with chickpeas is okay in my book (and tummy)! Hey – I rhymed!
Oh my gosh, I am so glad to have another use for tahini besides hummus. This really looks delicious. Thanks Deb and Molly.
Mm, I’ve been trying to make more squash recipes lately. I always neglect them in the winter. This sounds awesome and I’ll definitely try it. I wonder why I didn’t notice it on Orangette! Silly me.
Yay! Now I know what to bring to a potluck tomorrow night! I love smittenkitchen, the photos, the writing, the recipes, you’ve got the perfect combination. I did the braised beef short ribs which were a real hit (tried making it again with chuck as the short ribs are really expensive here, but it just wasn’t the same. though the gravy was still amazing) and I know that anytime I invite people over and say I’m cooking from your site, there’s always delicious anticipation. Good luck with the awards, you deserve them!
Oh my! Your blog was mentioned in an NY Times blog!
http://bitten.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/01/29/addictive-mac-and-cheese/?hp
Your first photo has been dancing in my head since I first saw it. Somehow the recipe infiltrated my brain and plopped a bnut squash into my basket today in town… I can’t wait to give it a go. I’m wondering about roasting the garlic that goes into the salad – I hope it won’t take away too much of the edge. Thanks for the brainwash!
Wow, this looks like something I’d do, simply because I love squash and chickpeas. Sadly, my husband and 6 year old don’t feel the same way. :-( Somehow, I also see a dash of curry powder doing wonders for this dish.
I just made this for dinner and I am IN LOVE WITH IT! Absolutely delicious. These are leftovers I will definitely look forward to!
The squash is cooling, onions, chick peas and cilantro sit, dressing is made, I’m so excited! I’ve made your Veselka cabbage soup many times, you are getting me through this cold NY winter, thanks! My tahini was sitting on a shelf so long that I got exercise stirring it until it was smooth — is that okay? Nothing on the Joyva can says to refrigerate, but how long do you think the shelf life is? It smells fine… thanks for all the great recipes, photos and inspiration!
This is one of my most favorite recipes on your blog. I made it right after you posted it the first time and told all of my friends that they had to try it. So glad to see the re-post to inspire me to make it again this weekend!
Argh! I made this for dinner this evening and ….. meh. Where could I have gone wrong – after all, the recipe’s only gotten rave reviews. I’ll give it another go, but can’t imagine where I erred. Perhaps the olive oil?
This looks amazing! I still have some leftover squash in the fridge. Just have to get some tahini!
Why do you skip the allspice?
Deb, I have loved your site from the second I met it quite a while back. Immediately, I told my mom and sisters about it since food/cooking is our bond. Since then, we all check in either from time to time, or in my case, all the time–and enjoy preparing your delicious and gorgeaous recipes. And your writing! Your personality walks off the page, my friend. Anyway, I love this recipe from Molly. When I lived in Israel, I tasted something similar to this, a mediterranean dish of roasted eggplant, tahini (t’china), olive oil, garlic and parsley. But the butternut squash in place of the eggplant–delicious! Not to mention the color palatte of this recipe . . . a true feast for the eyes. . . . So, thank you for all the food and fun you share, and congratulations on the nomination!
Made this last night to go along with roasted chicken and steamed spinach. Ended up eating the salad at room temperature, and we loved it! Thanks for the great recipe. Can’t wait to have a little more for lunch today.
Looks taaaaaasty…. Is it substantial enough to count as dinner? What else do you serve it with?
We just eat it for dinner. Sometimes with a green salad.
I made this last night and holy cow was it good – I ate the whole bowl myself, my husband got none. It was soo good that I am making it again tonight :)
I substituted some quinoa for part of the roasted squash and wasn’t disappointed. It made for a tasty brownbag lunch the next day too!
yummy! my taste buds are craving this, my mouth watering. must get butternut squash. now.
I don’t have butternut squash; I used acorn.
I don’t have garbanzo beans; I used pinto.
I probably created a whole new animal, but it was delicious!
Thanks Deb.
amazing! I made it with sweet potatoes instead of squash (what I had) and shallots vs. red onion (I am just beginning to learn to like onions raw), and I don’t know if there will be any left for dinner. thank you!
Next week (uhh…after Super Bowl Sunday) I’m doing a one-week detox (kind of like the one Oprah did) and I think this whole recipe would work in my meal plan! I’m glad to see I don’t have to eat boring food if I can eat things like that.
This looks so delicious! We absolutely love butternut squash and will have to give this recipe a try!
I love this salad too, and, happily, it lends itself well to variations. I’ve found that I like it better with white beans, instead of garbanzos; the texture seems to work better with the butternut squash. I simply sautee the white beans a bit in a pan, and I throw in some red chili flakes. Shredded sauteed brussel sprouts are also great with the salad, and roasted blue potato slices have definitely made an appearance on occasion too. Okay, hungry…
This was excellent! I served it with couscous and homemade pita chips. Thanks!
I made this tonight and it was fantastic! I substituted peanut butter and a little toasted sesame oil for the tahini because I didn’t have any at home. So yummy! Thank you!!
I made this tonight – it was delicious! All of my roommates were wondering what I was cooking and said more than once that it smelled amazing. It smelled awesome indeed, but tasted even better! Thanks for posting this recipe! And all of the other recipes you post…they all look unbelievable and you can bet I’ll be trying more in the near future.
I made this last night and it was so good! I have leftovers today for lunch and I am so excited.
I have been looking for a way to use up a butternut squash I got in my CSA box a month ago, so this was perfect.
I had never cooked with tahini before, so it gave me an excuse to buy some. Thanks so much for the great recipe!
wahh…i suppose it was bound to happen. i did not love this recipe. i think i tried it more out of curiousity than anything, but it just underwhelmed me. oh well…
i am, however, still dreaming of your double chocolate cake i made last week…raspberry filling… ganache….oh my….
made this last night and served it over couscous. it’s so so good.my coworkers are all jealous.
Deb, this was absolutely delicious. I made it for lunch and am completely full but my mouth wants more. The good news is that I know nobody else in my family will eat it so I have lunch for tomorrow. Thanks so much for another great recipe (the last one I tried was Claudia Fleming’s stout ginger cake – OMG, it was SO good).
I loved the salad too…made it the very day it was posted. I don’t think I will use red onion again, though. Maybe chopped shallots. The onion was a little too strong for my taste. I served it on a bed of spinach. I had lots of dressing left and have been using it on various things. Yum!
Wow! This is another winner. I made it on Sunday and have been eating it for lunch at work all week. It warms up nicely sitting on my desk after I arrive, and I get to feel smug that I’m getting a lot of my veggies for the day.
Delicious.
I made this salad yesterday. It turned out good. I roasted the squash with the allspice into with the olive oil. That was actually very tasty. But later, after adding the dressing, your salad looked much better than mine. The tahini in the dressing obscured all the colors of the ingredients. Next time I’m going to try it with less tahini and more lemon juice.
Holy cow!
Just made this tonight and it is DELICIOUS. My husband and I were a little skeptical at the mix of flavors, but I am officially won over. I especially love the textures.
I am definitely making this this week.
I made this on Saturday- yumm! Thanks for another great vegetarian recipe (that my meat-eating husband also devoured!)
I really wanted to like this dish. I love all of the ingredients…what went wrong? I found it too starchy and heavy. Maybe I overcooked the squash. Anyway, I ended up pureeing the entire salad with more of the dressing and olive oil. Butternut squash hummus! It was fabulous and nothing went to waste.
absolutely amazing. #1BF! sliced his hand open on the can of chickpeas while we made it… I threw everything together in a bowl and was ready to bolt out the door to the hospital. He wanted to try it, ate one bite, and insisted that we stay and eat before we went to the ER. 3 hours and six stitches later, we came home and he wanted another bowl right away.
I made it with some chicken cutlets brined and then marinated for half an hour in some of the dressing. very tasty!
Thank you so much for posting this! I made it last night, and I’m really looking forward to the leftovers for lunch today (I probably could have eaten it all, but I didn’t think that was wise). It’s a perfect combination of flavors and textures.
I saw someone in the comments left out the red onion because they don’t like raw onion, but the little bits of crunch are essential! I don’t like raw onion either, so after I chopped the onion I gave it a quick pickle while the squash was roasting and cooling – just add a tablespoon or so of apple cider vinegar and a bit of salt.
I left out the allspice, too, and I think that was a smart move. The roasted squash has enough of a sweet/savory thing going on without highlighting the sweetness with allspice.
I’m really looking forward to trying more of your recipes. You have a fantastic site here.
i’ve been a long time reader, but never posted…but i felt compelled. this is one of the most INCREDIBLE recipes i’ve tried in a while. everything about it is so great–great components, healthy ingredients, easy to make. i am in love…no word of a lie!
This is delicious! To use the leftovers I caramelized some onion, grated a little fontina, made dough and baked a hybrid version of your Butternut Squash and Caramelized Onion Galette. Still delicious!
Hiya Deb! We just made this and it is super good! I love all the contrasting flavors! I am crazy for anything with tahini… and this fits the bill. Thanks for another keeper. This one will become a regular for us I think.
Just made this and am eating it…just as you said, no allspice, with parsley because that’s what was in the fridge. Um, Yum!
..I had this recipe bookmarked for what seemed like ages & finally tried it last night — now, I’ve made many of your recipes before, but I’m wondering where I went wrong! The flavor profile of this salad seemed absolutely foul to me.. maybe it was the dressing, and perhaps I’m not used to tasting tahini sans-hummus..? I am addicted to chickpeas, but the texture of everything together really threw me. I was quite glad that I didn’t dress the salad in its entirety, because I ended up separating the butternut squash and eating it solo today! I’m almost afraid to try it again and may just turn the rest into hummus and tackling the recipe again at some point. It’s been a long time since I’ve had any hiccups trying your recipes!
I have to say I had the same problem as Chelsea…So excited about the recipe and then when I went to taste the dressing, something was off. I however, am blaming it on the tahini. I looked at the expiration date afterwards and it was expired! Even though I found several posts that claimed that tahini lasted forever, I think that must be the reason mine didn’t work out. It had a very sour taste and I am pretty sure that’s not the norm…
ERIN, you asked about substitutes for techina (tahini) or peanut butter. Are you also allergic to almonds? I bet this would work well with homemade almond butter or hazelnut butter. I say homemade because I like toasting my almonds or hazelnuts really darkly, then grinding them very finely, then pouring off some of the oil (for use in homemade soap making or for massage oil) to reduce the fat content a bit. It makes a much nuttier flavor this way, and a creamier texture.
If that won’t work for you, try just a spoonful of mayonnaise, perhaps, for the fat content. It won’t taste nutty, but… Ooh. Try dry-toasting a couple tablespoons of flour or matzah meal in a dry pan (not a cast iron skillet, which has to be oiled), until it turns medium brown. Keep it moving by whisking/stirring, and remove it from the heat and into a little bit of mayonnaise or canola/olive oil to stop it from cooking itself darker and burning. That’ll give you a nutty flavor, especially when added to your mayonnaise.
(Deb, hi, I’m new here, but I’m already in love.)
A follow-up: I finally got around to dismantling the ingredients from my first go-round with this recipe, and I ended up using the garbanzos in a salad I normally love/am addicted to — and you know what..? Even that tasted funny! I realized that perhaps this recipe tasted off to me because I used dried chickpeas that had soaked overnight. I’ve only ever used canned because they’re so convenient, but had a random bag in the pantry that I thought should be utilized. I’m going to try this again using canned, because I think that will make a difference to my taste buds! Will also pay very close attention to the dressing, as I think that was a bit off as well.. I’m intrigued with this flavor combination and am determined to master it!
Thanks so much for this recipe! After seeing those pics how could I resist? I love butternut squash and had a can of chickpeas I didn’t know what to do with. I finally got my hands on some tahini today, and I made this for dinner. It was delicious!
Thank you for this recipe. I’m eating it right now and it’s sooo good! I’m usually not a tahini fan but it really pulls together in this. Yum.
Loved this receipe. In the words of my chef boyfriend: “usually the dinners you make are hit and miss, but man, this is awesome!” I did add a few things: bacon (it was alright, didn’t add enough to make a huge difference) and sage (the boyfriends idea. it bring the taste to a whole new level).
Loved it. And super easy!
woh. took this to a vegan dinner party, it was a huge hit. keeper.
Finally made this recipe after buying ingredients a ways back, caught the butternut before it passed away. Used extra parsley AND cilantro AND a pile of mint. Worried the tahini was too old but it seemed to taste ok. First time cooking with it. It was divine, hubby loved it. I am another person who made it because of the way you talked about it : ) I have great faith in your recommendations, thanks a lot!
I have been wanting to make this recipe for ages and ages but wanted to make it on a night we were tired and didn’t feel like pulling together a big meal and where we wanted a light enough dinner that this would suffice. Made it this last weekend and it was wonderful. We didn’t have lemons, so I made it with lime juice and it worked well, though I missed the sweet zing that lemon juice would have given it. Because limes are a bit more tart and sour, I mixed in a small amount (less than a teaspoon) of agave nectar to sweeten it up a bit. Yum!
I tasted this after I made it mid afternoon (sleeping baby allowed for some cooking) even though I wasn’t planning on eating it until dinner. I had to forcibly remove the fork from my hand, it was sooooo good. Excellent recipe!
That looks deeeelicious.
But what is it with all you craaaazy people peeling the skin off of your butternut squash? The skin is the best bit!
I love this salad and have made it a few times. I’d make it a lot more, but I HATE peeling the squash!
Yesterday, I didn’t let the squash cool much before I mixed everything in. I came back a while later, and the dressing had turned to a lake in the bottom of the bowl. It was completely watery, and I had no idea how it happened. I figured I had just done something wrong, when my five-year old came up to me and said “Mom, do you think Michael (our 2-year old) dumped some water in there?” I said, “No, I don’t think he did, but I have a pretty good idea about who did!” It was then that I noticed the empty water bottle next to the bowl :-)
I ended up dumping the salad into a colander and redressing it with a new batch of dressing. It still tastes great :-)
I don’t have any tahini nearby so I am going to try to just add black sesame seeds, which I do have and I’ll let you know how it goes.
Last night I picked my first beautiful butternut squash from my garden and made this delicious salad. I did include the allspice, but omitted the cilantro/parsley (as I strongly dislike both). It was delicious. I ended up adding another 1 tablespoon of olive oil and 2 tablespoons of water to the dressing to thin it out a bit. I roasted the butternut squash only for 20 minutes, and it came out perfectly. I think next time I will try substituting basil or oregano for the cilantro/parsley. And there will definitely be a next time. Besides the pain of peeling butternut squash (Does anyone have any tricks for this?), it was quite simple to make. And it was definitely delicious! In fact, even just the butternut squash roasted with olive oil, garlic, and allspice was yummy. I think I might just roast butternut squash that was by itself. I highly recommend this recipe! I absolutely love squash (especially butternut) so keep the recipes coming. Thank you Deb!
No Tahini? No Problem! I wanted to let everyone know that if you do not have or can not find tahini you can substitute peanut butter (go with the all natural kind) and the recipe still turns out equally delicious! I am sorry if this is posted somewhere in the comments, I browsed through them but didn’t not see it! There are just so many comments since this recipe is so good!
I have made this recipe many times and it is always a huge hit with everyone!
Thanks Deb!!
There isn’t a single ingredient in here I don’t like, and I’m not a picky eater, AND I’ve loved every single one of SK’s recipes I’ve tried (which is a LOT by now!) but this was just…ick. Must just be me because so many others adored it, except a couple of people who it turned out had bad chickpeas and old tahini…all my ingredients were fresh & good, there was even an occasional bite where I could almost see how it might taste good to some people, but the dressing just did not work for me, at least not with that salad. Still, I can’t let it go because usually my assessment of SK’s recipes follow the majority, that is if a lot of people are saying “yum!” I tend to reach the same conclusion. I am stumped.
Deb, I’m searching for a replacement for your summer panzanella ( I made it pretty much every other night – without the bread, most of the time ), so I made this on Saturday as written and liked it a lot.
Today, I made it again… but roasted the butternut squash with ginger instead of allspice, lessened the ratio of tahini to lemon juice in the dressing, added a splash of red wine vinegar and ginger to the dressing… and oh man, even better!
For those who didn’t like the salad, I’d suggest just tasting the dressing and adding ingredients until you like the flavor! It’s a great, healthy salad and a wonderful recipe that’s very giving to tweaks.
Jennifer — You’ve got to make the Winter Panzanella!
We’ve made and loved this before. Tonight we had it with butterCup squash and black beans. It was good, but not as good.
Okay, weird but awesome addition – grapes! It’s the perfect contrasting flavor and texture. I now make this at least twice a week.
And Deb, thanks for the Winter Panzanella tip. I’m just trying to work up the nerve to eat all those sprouts!
Thanks Deb for a great recipe! I made this last weekend and it was a big hit at our Halloween dinner. I added a teaspoon of cinnamon to the roasted squash and also added the allspice. I made the salad in the afternoon and then tossed the squash with the dressing right before serving. Great flavors and easy to put together!
Was not at all sure about this recipe, but couldn`t resist. Worth it! I loved the salad and so did my guests!
I just made this last night (after seeing it here and on Orangette), and it was soooo good! I wasn’t sure what to expect with this mix of ingredients, but I’m glad I tried it out. Each ingredient really stood out and complimented the others. Thanks for the recipe!
So I was soaking my garbanzo beans over night for hummus, but this looks much more interesting. I think I have a new recipe to try.
I thought it was incredibly yummy even without the dressing! Simpler and fresher… but it is still tasty with the tahini dressing as well. In the future i’ll skip it though.
i think i just had a religious experience with this. thank you.
OHMYGOSH! So so good!!! I used cilantro which, I think, gave it a freshness and lightness. I thought the red onion I used was a bit harsh and somewhat overpowering (and only used half of a small to medium sized one).
ALSO, went to my favorite wine shop and got a nice pinot noir to pair. Amazing!!
As far as peeling the squash… I put it whole into some boiling water for about three minutes or so, let it cool, then peeled with relative (and I do mean relative) ease. Boiling the squash won’t cook it but will soften the skin.
Now a question… I cooked the squash for about 25-30 minutes and while it rid it of that rawness, it ended up getting a bit mushad once I mixed it with the rest of the salad. Perhaps I cut the pieces too small? Cooked too long? Anyone else have this problem?
I made this twice this week. I whipped up a full batch of the dressing, used a tiny butternut and half a can of garbanzos for the first round, and just had to roast another squash for the second. The first time I ate it fresh, hot, and it was awesome.
I just finished eating it as a cold lunch, and it was…disappointing. Something about cold makes the squash lose some flavor. I also didn’t put parsley in, because I was afraid it would wilt too much and I was running late. The whole meal was lackluster. So, if you have leftovers, you probably want to heat them up. And fresh is definitely better. And don’t skip ingredients.
This meal is wunderbar! Not sure why you were hating on the allspice – it was a nice addition to the squash + garlic.
Made this with a Lamb Tagine w/ Dried Fruit (L.A. Times recipe that is just frightfully delicious — and DEB! It’s made in the crock pot!) for a Moroccan-themed dinner party. It was a perfect match; totally delicious with some added toasted walnuts for a bit of crunch.
Just made this for the second time and put in tons of parsley just to use it up – and it’s really good that way. Thanks again for the recipe!
My friend made this salad for a potluck last night and it was fantastic. She omitted the allspice and the squash cooked for a bit longer than intended but this homogenized the ingredients in a way that was binding and thick, real smooth and delightful.
We ate what was left of it today cold on some toast and I have to say it was the closest thing to what I imagine a ‘vegan lobster roll’ (that’s worth eating) might taste like. Parsley, no cilantro, and very lemon-y. Very good.
I made this once as written, and it was to die for. Made it a second time as a pasta dish, omitting the chickpeas, using homemade linguine instead. Three of us finished off the entire pot. It was extraordinarily good.
Wonderful!!
Try putting a little pasta in it, or roasting the squash seeds in a little oil and salt and sprinkling them into the mix.
Carissa – Can you post a link to that Lamb Tangine recipe? I can’t seem to find it, but I would love to have it.
Thanks!
I’ve been thinking about this recipe since you first posted it. Due to travel and other plans, had to wait until this weekend to make it. My boyfriend and I loved it. No leftovers. I’ve already shared the link with a friend. This will definitely be a dish I’ll repeat in the future. So simple and so good.