“Twenty years of Thanksgivings on Smitten Kitchen!” I told Ed Levine yesterday, as we chatted for an upcoming podcast episode [I’ll link it here as soon as it’s live], a statistic that remains baffling to me. What should one even have to show for two decades of Thanksgiving recipes, ideas, and advice? A degree in dry brining? A medal in single-oven-side-dish-rewarming Jenga? A metamorphosis into my final form: a human-shaped holiday cooking questions hotline (it’s me, or at least the texts on my phone)? Aspirationally, all of the above?





The only pattern I can identify in my Thanksgiving cooking evolution over the years is this: The more I’ve hosted, the more time I’ve spent having Real Talks (with myself, in my head) about what is actually worth my time, energy, and limited stove and oven real estate, the simpler — and I’d argue better — my recipes have become. Turkey? Dry-brined, with a gorgeous burnished finish and the best onions you’ll eat in your lifetime, all from six ingredients. Stuffing? Store-bought challah, celery, leeks, herbs, and a nobody-needs-to-know amount of butter. A carrot side dish? Start with one bag of baby carrots. Yes, really.

My pecan pie has gone through a few iterations over the years: first, a classic pecan pie (still a knockout, but it serves only eight, a travesty); then a chocolate pecan slab pie in my second cookbook, Smitten Kitchen Every Day (party-sized, hooray, but a serious time commitment, with two homemade crusts, a lattice, and a chocolate layer). A few years ago, I streamlined and simplified that recipe into these bars, and I haven’t looked back. The crust is pressed in. The topping is made in one bowl. Yet I’ve packed as much flavor as I possibly can into every bite: The pecans are toasted, there’s honey and dark brown sugar, vanilla bean, dark chocolate chips, sea salt, and there’s brown butter, both in the crust and the pecan layer. The aroma of the tiniest square leaps off the plate, and I think we should be there to catch it.

Pecan Pie Bars
- 1 cup plus 5 tablespoons (10.5 ounces or 300 grams) unsalted butter (to be used for crust and pecan layer)
- 2 tablespoons (30 ml) water
- 2 cups plus 2 tablespoons (275 grams) all-purpose flour
- 1/2 cup (60 to 100 grams) granulated or powdered sugar
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt (Diamond brand; use half of others)
- 2/3 cups (140 grams) packed dark brown sugar
- 1/2 cup (170 grams) honey
- 1/4 cup (60 ml) heavy cream
- 1/2 teaspoon flaky or coarse sea salt, plus an extra pinch or two to finish
- 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste or vanilla extract
- 2 large eggs
- 3 1/4 cups (12 ounces or 340 grams) pecan halves, lightly toasted
- 1 cup (6 ounces or 170 grams) chocolate chips, semisweet or bittersweet are great here
Shortbread Crust
Pecan layer
[If your pecans aren’t already toasted, while the oven heats, place them on a sheet pan and bake them for 8 to 10 minutes, until fragrant. Set aside until needed.]
Brown the butter: In a medium-large saucepan (we’ll use this as the bowl to mix the pecan layer in a bit), melt butter over medium-high heat. It will melt, then foam, then begin to developed fragrant, toasted brown specks at the edges of the pan. Remove from heat when you see it starting to brown; the residual heat will be sufficient to toast the rest of the butter to a medium brown color. Carefully, so it doesn’t splatter, add 2 tablespoons of water.
Make the shortbread crust: In a large bowl, combine the flour, sugar, and salt. Measure 1 cup of the browned butter (leaving the rest in the saucepan) and add it to the flour mixture, stirring it until it’s mixed into a soft, crumbly dough. Scatter the dough over your prepared pan and press it evenly across the bottom and 1/4-inch further up at the edges. Transfer to the oven and bake for 15 to 17 minutes, until it smells fragrant and begins to get more golden at the edges.
Meanwhile, make the pecan layer: Add brown sugar, honey, heavy cream, flaky salt, cider vinegar, and vanilla to the remaining brown butter in your saucepan and whisk to combine. Add eggs, one at a time, whisking until fully mixed. Add your toasted pecan halves (still a little warm is fine) and stir to coat with honey mixture. Stir in chocolate chips last.
Assemble and bake: Pour the pecan mixture over the crust — it’s fine if it’s still hot from the oven — then sprinkle a few flakes of salt over the top. Bake for 25 to 30 minutes, or until the edges are set but the center is somewhat firm to the touch, but still has some jiggle to it.
Transfer pan to a cooling rack and let the bars cool completely. You can hurry this along in the fridge. Use the edges of the parchment paper to lift bars out and onto a cutting board. Cut into your desired size pieces.
Do ahead: These bars keep in the fridge for up to a week, but only if you hide them from family and, sometimes, yourself.
Previously
6 months ago: Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake Bars and Chicken Salad for Celery Enthusiasts
1 year ago: Brown Butter Snickerdoodles, Baked Potatoes with Crispy Broccoli and Bacon and Crunchy Brown Butter Baked Carrots
2 years ago: Skillet-Baked Macaroni and Cheese
3 years ago: Chicken Rice with Buttered Onions
4 year ago: Apple Dumplings
5 years ago: Big Apple Crumb Cake
6 years ago: Whole Wheat Chocolate Oat Cookies and Simple Cauliflower Tacos
7 years ago: Chickpea and Kale Shakshuka
8 years ago: Crispy Spinach Pizza
9 years ago: Pizza Beans and Chocolate Tahini Challah Buns
10 years ago: Homemade Merguez with Herby Yogurt and Magic Apple Plum Cobbler
11 years ago: The Perfect Manhattan, Broccoli Cheddar Soup and S’more Cupcakes
12 years ago: Latke Waffles and The Crispy Egg
13 years ago: Frico Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
14 years ago: Crackly Banana Bread and Spaghetti with Broccoli Cream Pesto
15 years ago: Apple Pie Cookies
16 years ago: Single-Crust Apple and Plum Pie
17 years ago: Date Spice Loaf and Lebanese-Style Stuffed Eggplant
18 years ago: Summer’s Last Hurrah Panzanella, Sweet and Sour Glazed Cippoline, Majestic and Moist Honey Cake, and Best Challah (Egg Bread)
19 years ago: Red Velvet Cake, Noodle Kugel, Spaghetti Fideos with Chorizo and Almonds and Couscous and Feta-Stuffed Peppers
20 years ago: Acorn Squash with Chile-Lime Vinaigrette
Happy almost Thanksgiving! I will be making my version of your kale salad with dried cranberries and Granny Smith apples.
I don’t love honey – do you think I could sub for maple syrup? Thanks!
Wondering the same about subbing maple syrup for honey!
Or subbing golden syrup and maybe using less salt?
I can assure you that using Golden Syrup in pecan pie is heavenly. That’s how my mother makes it and I am going to use it to make these bars.
Francesca, will you do a 1:1 sub with the golden syrup?
also wondering – may try these tomorrow with maple syrup (we have a sugar bush and make our own, so that’s easier than honey for me).
Help! I need an answer to the question: can you substitute maple syrup for the honey? I don’t want a thanksgiving disaster😅
I immediately thought of Lyle’s Golden Syrup to replace the honey! I think the challenge with maple syrup is the higher water content.
I did the maple syrup sub-equal volume of syrup for the honey. It turned out great! The slight maple flavor really compliments the pecans.
In my experience with pecan pie baking, the eggs do the heavy lifting in getting the filling to set. So there’s flexibility in the other ingredients. I bet a lot of other liquid sweeteners-golden syrup?-would work too; they would just change the flavors slightly
Thanks!
Can I freeze these?
I think definitely yes! I have frozen pecan pie and pecan tassies, and they freeze brilliantly.
THIS is what I’ve been looking for. Any idea which “fakes” to use to attempt a parev (dairy free) version? I appreciate that the brown butter element isn’t really reproducible
Wouldn’t be like brown butter, but I would use coconut oil instead of butter and coconut cream instead of heavy cream.
already scheming how I might be able to get away with using store-bought pie crust instead of the homemade shortbread 😁
Thank you for sharing! I was wondering if you have a suggested substitute for apple cider vinegar? Thank you!
It’s just a teaspoon. You can probably use pretty much any other vinegar except balsamic. I’d just use white or rice vinegar
Hi
These look great can I substitute golden syrup for the honey?
Can I use golden syrup?
These look AMAZING! I usually make @justataste’s recipe for pecan pie bars (which are incredible) but am absolutely going to switch them out to try these!
This recipe could not have come at a better time, I’ve been contemplating the pecan slab pie but also feeling like I just don’t have it in me to deal with the crust making this year and I take this as a sign from the universe that I needn’t. I may make this and the cranberry bars from the OG cookbook in and eschew pie crusts entirely!
How well do you think these might ship as a holiday gift?
Hi Allison, not Deb here (we’re a nut supplier), but one thing to keep in mind: the pecan layer has eggs and cream, and the recipe says these keep in the fridge, so they aren’t ideal for a multi-day trip at room temperature. If you do ship them, chill or freeze the bars fully, cut them, wrap each one individually, pack them snugly in a tin with a cold pack and send them overnight, and ask the recipient to refrigerate them on arrival. If you want something that travels well by ordinary mail, toasted spiced or candied pecans, or a pecan shortbread, hold up much better.
– Zarchin Saffron & Nuts
Oooh good points for both these replies! I would be shipping from western CO to Chicago, so I’m not sure they would safely hold up, which is sad bc my father would love these. Thank you!!
I ship pecan tassies as part of my cookie box every year, and they do well! I agree that it works best if you freeze the cookies first, and I use shipping that will get them to their destinations within a few days, for freshness. Having said that – I live in NY, and am generally shipping to other places that are pretty cool in December – I might not attempt it if it’s quite warm where you live.
Hi, I assume if you try to freeze it. You would freeze it after it’s baked and cooled. Then you would defrost it by letting it sit in the refrigerator overnight?
Wondering the same thing! I’d like to make one dessert to freeze to make day of prep easier!
Thanks for a great recipe. Do you know the weight in grams of the browned butter (rather than pour into a measuring cup)? And what’s the flavor or texture difference in using granulated vs powdered sugar? Which do you prefer? Thank you!
This is my question, too. What would 1 cup of the browned butter weigh in grams or which kind of US standard measuring cup (should be liquid, right, so 8 oz)?
What’s the percentage of milk fat in your heavy cream? We don’t have “heavy cream” in Canada, but we have “whipping cream” with 35%mf. Thank you!
I’m Canadian and have used whipping cream in all recipes that call for heavy cream (or double cream, for recipes from the UK), and it works fine!
In the US heavy whipping cream contains at least 36% milkfat (and is often labeled simply as “heavy cream”), while standard whipping cream (sometimes called “light whipping cream”) contains between 30% and 35% milkfat.
Oh yes! This is dessert! Looking forward to making and tasting. I was conflicted about which pecan pie to make this year but no more worries. Pecan bars for the win.
The curly haired rogue baker!
Would a gluten free flour work here, ya think?
Hi…I was just wondering the same thing about GF flour! Would love to know as these look yummy……OR I can tolerate 00 Italian Flour if that works?
I plan to make these using KA 1-to1 flour. When using this flour, I let the dough sit for 20-30 min before baking
*UPDATE* Don’t use KA 1:1 flour! I tried and it was way too wet and wouldn’t bind at all. Baked it for over 45 minutes and it’s basically a big wet pancake. I’m on my second attempt with a combo of half almond and half oat flour. Not out of the oven yet, but much more promising!
How did the half almond and half oat flour turn out? I am wanting to make these but need a gluten free flour option
Has anyone tried this with a little bourbon yet?
No but that sounds amazing and I want to try!!
Just made these for the first time. I used homemade bourbon vanilla (has a strong bourbon flavor). Received raving reviews at my dinner party! Definitely on my “keep” list.
Practically ran to make this morning. Used walnuts, of course, because they’re far superior to pecans, but otherwise made as written. Great crust, and the whole thing came together easily. I’m still on the fence regarding the inclusion of chocolate chips – it’s an already intensely sweet dessert, and they sort of take over.
I better go have a few more pieces, so I can make an educated decision.
I used a dark chocolate chunk—the bitterness was excellent against the sweetness. The addition of chocolate is a wonderful combination!
Deb, is it possible to just make half this recipe in an 8 or 9 in. Square pan? We have a tiny family.
The volume of an 8in square pan should be about half the volume of a 9×13 pan, so yes, that should work. I also plan to halve it and make an 8in pan.
I’m excited to try these. These are similar in concept to the Honey Walnut Bars that I have been making since Tim recommended them in his Christmas cookie roundup a few years ago https://www.lottieanddoof.com/2020/12/what-we-talk-about-when-we-talk-about-cookies/ but I’m wondering what the eggs in pecan layer do compared to the butter in the walnut layer there. I would love to understand the logic if anyone’s good at deducing it.
https://www.blossomtostem.net/honey-walnut-bars-and-a-review-of-cookie-love/
My FIL cannot have dairy. I think DF butter would work in the crust—any suggestions for a swap for the cream in the filling?
I haven’t tried it in this recipe, but, in similar ones, I’ve used coconut cream (not coconut milk or lite coconut milk–you want the fat).
Oh this looks perfect for cooking in a rented kitchen! Nothing too terribly complicated or gear-heavy – AND it looks delish. Thanks for what is likely to be yet another winner.
Is there anyway to make these without eggs? They look divine!
These are 10/10 incredible!!! I always make your black bottom oat pie for Thanksgiving but I’m considering switching to these because they were so easy!
My crust is more like batter. Was i supposed to let the butter cool more?
Which type of sugar did you use?
I had the same issue. Used granulated sugar and weighed all ingredients except melted butter. I feel like one of the measurements must be off. I ended up adding flour, a handful at a time until I got a better consistency. Curious to see Deb’s response.
I had the same problem. First crust attempt was as written and I used 100 g of granulated sugar and it was a portable batter.
Second attempt I mixed the 275 of flour, salt, and 60 g of granulated sugar (I measured 0.5 c and weighed it as i poured it in). I melted 1 c of butter, and poured it in a little at a time until I had the consistency I wanted, which ended up being about half a cup of butter.
I also had this issue. I added more flour and sugar to get it to something thicker (still not crumbly), and it baked up fine! They are delicious!
I am also wondering if it has to do with my melted butter being so hot-I went immediately from browning the butter to making the crust
And I started with granulated sugar (measured by volume) and flour (measured by weight)
For the chocolate pecan bars, I’m trying to make sense of 3 1/4 cups of pecans = 12 ounces. Should I prioritize weight? Thanks.
I made them tonight with a 12-ounce package of pecans (label says it’s 2 3/4 cups) and I feel like they have plenty of pecans, so I’d definitely prioritize weight.
I was an adult when I found out that derby pie wasn’t traditional for most people at Thanksgiving, especially people from New England or New Jersey (a Southern aunt brought it with her when she married into the family before I was born), so this seems like the perfect holiday dessert to me!
Sooo did anyone try it with golden syrup and would it be 1:1?
I’m having a heck of a time with this. My dough was more of a batter and I’m not sure if it was the sugar. I did 100g of granulated (was using a scale and did a quick google). Please update the recipe to be more precise on the sugar amount.
I messed up my brown butter because I needed to strain out the milk solids, so I only have a cup. How much should go into the filling? I have to do a second batch of brown butter to have some for the filling. Sigh
Why did you strain out the milk solids? I think they’d be great wherever they end up.
Simple and tasty! I halved the recipe to make in an 8×8 pan. Next time I might make a bit more of the shortbread mixture as I prefer a slightly thicker crust. I used the volume measurement for the granulated sugar. Even a small piece scratches that dessert itch.
Twenty years of Thanksgiving recipes is an incredible milestone, and “single-oven-side-dish-rewarming Jenga” describes our holiday kitchen far too accurately. Turning pecan pie into bars is honestly the smartest move for a crowded table since they travel easily and slice cleanly ahead of time. Definitely adding these to our baking list this week.
Twenty years of Thanksgiving recipes is an incredible milestone, and “single-oven-side-dish-rewarming Jenga” might be the most accurate description of holiday cooking I have ever read. Turning pecan pie into chocolate-layered bars is such a smart move for a big crowd since they slice cleanly and travel way better than a traditional pie. Definitely bookmarking these for next week’s dessert table.
Awesomely delicious! However,I found them hard to cut cleanly. Perhaps I baked too long? Anyway these will be enjoyed no matter what ‼️
Can I substitute bourbon for the cider vinegar?
I had a terrible time with the shortbread. I measured everything carefully, by weight, and ended up with a batter, not a dough. I made a second batch of shortbread, thinking maybe I erred, but alas, another batter. I’m not really sure what went wrong, but I am probably short a dessert for Thanksgiving, barring a miracle. Your recipes are usually foolproof. I guess not this time for this fool.
If I want to do a chocolate layer vs mixing in the chips like in your pecan pie recipe: (1) how should I adjust the chocolate chip measurement and (2) should I prepare it the same way as in your pie recipe?
I made these this morning. They are SWEET. I weighed the flour and granulated sugar (only used 60g) and measured out the browned butter at 8 oz/1 cup using a liquid measuring cup. It made a soft greasy dough—definitely thicker than a batter and very oily when patting into the pan. I used Guittard extra dark chocolate chips. I went toward the longer end for all the bake times but within the parameters Deb provided. I agree that a little more crust would’ve been ideal for a taller edge to contain the filling better. I’d be curious if reducing the honey or brown sugar by 1/4 cup would still work. These were good but I have a different recipe from Food & Wine that I think I’ll stick with next year.