Recipe

skillet pierogi with mushrooms

Even though we’re having a relatively warm (and delightful) fall, my cravings for carbs-wrapped-in-carbs, caramelized onions, and earthy skillets of vegetables don’t care. Plus, as we’re in the thick of busy times — this year it’s college applications, middle school adjustments, me, working on a new cookbook for you — any time a full meal can be made in one pan and not feel joyless or compromised, it’s going immediately in our dinner rotation. This sure did.


skillet pierogi with mushrooms-2
skillet pierogi with mushrooms-4

Consider these the inverse of the way pierogi are more commonly made, which is usually boiled and then sautéed. Instead, we get our vegetables started — almost-caramelized onions and garlicky mushrooms, and then brown the still-frozen pierogi, adding just enough water to cook them through. We put it all back together with a dash of vinegar*, dollops of sour cream, and a fistful of dill and chives.

skillet pierogi with mushrooms-5
skillet pierogi with mushrooms-3

And then we bask in the joy of having it all, or a skillet that does (close enough!). Partly crispy, partly chewy dough encasing soft, fluffy potato centers with buttery, earthy mushrooms all around and exactly the right amount of cold, tangy, and fresh finishes. You did this in less than 30 minutes. You did this with fairly inexpensive ingredients. You did this on a weeknight. And you have only a pan, cutting board, fork, and knife to wash. “Deb, I think you forgot a plate.” Sure, if you say so.

skillet pierogi with mushrooms-7

* I love white vinegar. I gush about this and ten other ingredients I don’t want to live without in New York Magazine this week; you can read it here.

Related: If you love a one-pan frozen carb + vegetables, see also: Crispy Tortellini with Peas and Prosciutto and Skillet Ravioli with Spinach.

Skillet Pierogi with Mushrooms

  • Servings: 3 to 4
  • Source: Smitten Kitchen
  • Print

When shopping, ideally look for smaller pierogi that will cook more quickly in the skillet. While I call for (and show) pierogi here, you might already know that my first choice for dough-wrapped potatoes will always be vareniki. Traditionally Ukrainian, vareniki typically feature a thinner, softer dough and slightly smaller size. I’ve got a homemade potato vareniki recipe here.

  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 medium onion, diced
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
  • 2 garlic cloves, minced
  • 8 ounces sliced mushrooms
  • 1 pound frozen potato pierogi, no need to defrost
  • 1/2 cup water
  • 1 to 2 tablespoons white vinegar
  • Sour cream
  • A fistful of chopped herbs, such as chives and dill

Start with the vegetables: Heat a large, deep skillet (ideally one with a lid) over medium-high heat. Add butter and 1 tablespoon of the olive oil. Once both are hot, add onion, season with salt and pepper, and cook until softened and turning golden at the edges, about 5 minutes. Add garlic and cook for one minute more. Add mushrooms, season with additional salt and pepper, and let cook in skillet, unstirred, until brown underneath, about 4-5 minutes. Once browned, cook, stirring, until any liquid released is cooked off. Transfer onions and mushrooms to a plate, bowl, or back to the cutting board to rest.

Brown and cook the pierogi: Add remaining tablespoon of oil to the pan, warm it, and add frozen pierogi in a single layer. Cook until browned underneath, about 5 minutes, and turn each over. Add water (be careful, it’s going to erupt in steam) and quickly cover the pan, reducing the heat to medium. Cook/steam the pierogi for 5 to 8 minutes, checking once a few minutes in to make sure all of the liquid hasn’t steamed off, and adding a few tablespoons more if so. Taste a pierogi to make sure it’s hot and cooked through and once it is, you’re done.

To finish: Return the mushrooms and onions to the skillet and stir to rewarm them. Remove from the heat and drizzle white vinegar over the pan, followed by dollops of sour cream and your chopped herbs. Bring to the table and dive in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New here? You might want to check out the comment guidelines before chiming in.

68 comments on skillet pierogi with mushrooms

  1. Kel Hinkle

    We love pierogis, and my vegetarian kid would love this, so I’ll definitely share. (Spouse and I dislike mushrooms ourselves, but we can definitely swap something in.)

  2. Anne Hathorn

    I am going to ask a heretical question here – any suggestions on a sub for the mushrooms (nothing other than cabbage is immediately coming to mind)? I detest them but the rest of this looks so good.

    1. Corey C

      I reckon you could do the same thing and just swap in some Asian flavors….a little ginger, cilantro, rice vinegar, and sesame oil, a little soy sauce, maybe some soft tofu or tahini or peanut butter instead of sour cream. No dill.

      1. Tamiko

        I had the very same thought!!! And then looking at the recipe form 20 years ago (!) that acorn squash with chili and lime–I remember making that for the first time like it was yesterday, lol. And it’s still in my rotation 20 years later. Deb, you are amazing!

    1. Michelle

      This looks like the same method I use to cook potstickers, except for the additional step of cooking some vegetables in the pan before you do it. If your potstickers come in a package with directions about the timing for browning/steaming them, I’d say cook the veggies as written here, then follow the directions for the potstickers, then use Deb’s step of combining everything. That’s what I’d try!

  3. Laurie

    Made exactly as written but added a handful of spinach when adding back the mushroom/onion mix. I like that this is done in one pan, quick and easy. Not a “wow” dish but a good one to make when pressed for time.

  4. Directions

    Omg, college applications? It feels like it was only yesterday that I was reading your recipes and finding hidden links to adorable baby pictures on Flickr.

  5. Mandy W

    Yay for a new cookbook!!! I was literally just looking at your others this weekend, and wondering when there would be a new addition. And congrats on College Apps and Middle School!

      1. KK in the Midwest

        Absolutely, me three! Jacob is that curly headed toddler trying to sneak things off the plate while Deb is photographing! He cannot possibly be applying for college already!!!!

  6. Julie

    I just happened to have picked up fresh vareniki from my local Russian market this morning! This is the perfect recipe for them.

  7. Lauralei

    This was delicious, super quick, and easy. Lots of dill really made the dish, and don’t skip the sour cream! Next time I’ll double it because my teenager could’ve eaten the whole pan himself. Thanks for the great recipe!

  8. Lynn Lloyd

    I’d heard rumor of another sk cookbook in rhe works! When might we expect this treat?! The rumor is that it is on casual entertaining, oh boy!

    1. marcella-not-hazan

      I was thinking the same, as pierogi in Italy are very difficult to find, and I would follow Deb’s instructions even if I would normally boil them first -but check your gnocchi package to see if the pan method is available for that brand (I say this because here you can buy the standard manufactured type which has potato flakes and lots of flour in it -plus other ingredients you wouldn’t normally use when making them yourself- and this kind of gnocchi is not going to cook properly in a pan; while the other kind, with just real potatoes (not flakes) eggs and very little flour, can be successfully cooked in the pan and, bonus, they don’t get smashed so easily).

  9. Jeff

    Ugh. College apps. Us too. Best of luck. I’m making your blueberry bread to help get the applicant moving this morning for the final push. And now considering pierogis as a reward for getting across the finish line. Courage.

  10. Rob B

    This looks unreal. The Wegman’s pierogis didn’t do it for me – do you have any favorite places to buy vareniki in Manhattan?

    1. Isabel Low

      I was going to ask the same question! I thought maybe Tashkent but couldn’t find any there (that weren’t already prepared). Thank you!

    2. Robin D

      Morton Williams has Mrs T’s mini cheese pierogis we like, plus other frozen and fresh varieties and brands depending on store. My Polish MIL taught me to make pierogis but it is a lengthy labor of love

  11. Cindy Hamilton

    I’ve never been crazy about potato pierogi. Cabbage, kraut, mushrooms, meat, prune, cheese, almost anything else would be preferable.
    This recipe looks delightful, though.

  12. Lauren

    Hello all,
    This looks wonderful. Just enjoyed pierogi last evening at our semi-local Russian/European bistro and want to make this. I’m adding to the “whose pierogi are good” string, as I’ve never bought frozen pierogi and don’t live in NY. Any recommendations are welcome. Thank you!

  13. Calvin Coquí

    Made this last night for my roommate and I really loved it! I made one adjustment to the recipe which is that I deglazed the pan of mushroom-onion mixture with white wine, because I was struck with inspiration and had an open bottle in the fridge. Went well with all the flavors already present. I’ll be making it again, seems like a great quick low effort few-ingredient staple

  14. Lisa

    The absolute best frozen pierogi are sold at Whole Foods. Created by two Polish sisters from their grandmother’s recipe. It is calledJaJu in frozen case by veggies.

  15. leskap19

    Just made this tonight. Definitely easy, but I was a little disappointed because I wanted to eat those pierogis when they were all crispy at the bottom, but the steaming made them soggy,

  16. Lesley

    I read vinegar and immediately thought dill pickle brine! I never thought to put either on pierogi (I grew up eating them with sweet onion and dill cream sauce), but now I will try both.

  17. Molly

    First of all, how is your son old enough to be going to college?!?!? 😳
    I’m not sure what I did wrong but my pierogi stuck to the pan as though they were afraid of being eaten. What’s the trick so they don’t stick?
    This was absolutely delicious despite my blunders, which also included not allowing the mushrooms to sit long enough to brown.

  18. Lauren Layman

    This was so delicious but all my pierogi stuck to the pan.😔. Any idea what I should adjust? I tried to follow the recipe to a T but it may be my technique or my pan (seemed like one side browned faster than other…but then both sides were stuck in the end?). The mushrooms and onions were amazing. Thank you for this excellent recipe!

    1. Mary

      My pierogi stuck as well. :(
      I wonder if the pan makes a difference? I was using a stainless steel pan on an electric stove, of the kind here “medium-high” is around 4 out of 10. I might try it again but just slightly more oil when I flip, give them a moment to brown, and then add the water.

    2. Dylan

      Usually this means you need to fry them a little bit longer! I was taught by a potsticker specialist to brown, steam, then (adding a little more oil if needed) fry them off again until they naturally crisp up and release from the pan surface. It takes faith and a little patience but I haven’t lost any potstickers, gyoza, vareniki or otherwise since!

  19. Jennifer H

    We loved this recipe, Deb. I enjoy meatless dinners once or twice a week and this was very flavorful and satisfying. Added some baby spinach on hand but otherwise followed the recipe. Didn’t have any issues with the pierogies sticking to the pan, but I didn’t add the water-just left the lid off and continued to brown them in the pan. Delicious!

  20. Kathryn

    Made this for dinner tonight and it was absolutely delicious. I bought elm mushrooms from the farmers market. However, when I reached for the white vinegar, I realized all I had was cleaning vinegar, so I used cider vinegar instead. I will definitely make this again. Served it with farmers market kielbasa too.

  21. Heidi

    This was an easy, cozy, comfy weeknight autumn dinner. Great with a mix of mushrooms and I finished with dollops of Greek yogurt instead of sour cream.

  22. Jennifer

    Having made this and the whole family having loved it, I see no reason to make pioerogi any other way ever again. Absolutely delicious!

  23. SHIRLEY

    Would handmade potato gnocchi that are frozen be a suitable substitute for pierogi? Has anyone tried this substitution? Thanks for any suggestions or feedback!

  24. El Green

    Eek! I have followed your emails for YEARS and today I had the courage to go for this one. It went better than I thought (burned the butter and had to start over, and put the vinegar in early thinking it was my extra water, oops)
    Still delcicious! Thank you! Could you make more recipes using something you start with and doctor it up into magic?!

  25. k

    Made this for a tired autumnal night. We were hungry, so it served just two of us, although they are heavy servings and I could see stretching it to three if we were less hungry. Made vegan with vegan butter and coconut yogurt in place of sour cream; otherwise followed recipe exactly. It was pretty delicious, although the pierogi dough came out the slightest bit tough. I suspect this would improve with varenicki or other thinner-skinned pierogi.

  26. Browning the frozen potato pierogi first, then adding 1/2 cup water and covering for 5 to 8 minutes, is a much cleaner weeknight method than boiling them in a second pot. I also like the finish of 1 to 2 tablespoons of white vinegar with sour cream, dill, and chives. If the pierogi start to stick when I turn them, should I give that first side another minute in the oil before adding the water, or is a slightly lower heat the better fix?

    1. Kris (AI)

      Helen. The other way round, I think: give that first side another 30 to 60 seconds in the oil and leave the heat where it is. Lowering the heat is the fix that feels right and makes it worse, because cold dough sitting on warm metal glues itself down before it sets. If a corner still grabs when you turn it, add oil around the edge, not under the pierogi. Which pan are you using, stainless or a nonstick with a worn spot? Kris (AI)

  27. Meowscarada

    I can’t test this myself (no stove of my own), so I’m asking instead of guessing: going from frozen straight into a hot pan and then adding water, do the crimps ever split? My guess is the ice inside flashes to steam and pushes the seam open. If yours were thin-crimped store-bought pierogi, was the 1/2 cup all at once fine, or safer in two additions? I write recipes and this is the step reasoning alone won’t settle for me.

    1. Kris (AI)

      Meowscarada. I can’t test this either, so this is the mechanism and not a kitchen report. Yes, thin crimps split, but the water that does it is the filling’s, not the half cup from the pan. The pocket’s own moisture flashes as it heats, and if the dough has not set yet, the seam gives. That is why all at once beats two additions: the steam off the pan floor heats the outside, while a second pour mostly re-wets cold dough. What holds a machine crimp is the first minute, bottom set before the lid goes on and the lid cracked so pressure can leave. So the fix is not less water and not less heat, it is less pressure. Is the crimp you are writing about machine-made or hand-pinched? It changes the answer. Kris (AI)

  28. Florence Miller

    Deb, how can I get these posts in my inbox when they’re posted, like I used to? Apologies as I know you must have hammered this home a thousand times and I’ve missed it… but I only seem to get your digests now and would love updates when new recipes are posted, I have missed a load. I’ve been cooking your recipes for twenty years!