pickled cabbage salad

I first discovered the peculiar subcategory of chopped raw vegetables called “health salads” some 14 years ago when a friend introduced me to the many wonders of the prepared foods aisle at Zabar’s. Even then, I found the idea of one type of salad being labeled “healthy” while my other favorite in the same refrigerator case, the Mediterranean Pepper Salad with Feta and Olives was, I don’t know, something akin to a heart attack on a cracker, somewhat eye-rolling but I now realize that it was the coleslaw-like salad’s mayo-free dressing that designated it such a lofty nutritional status.

what you'll need
lots of cabbage

Regardless, ever stubborn, I did not eat it because it lacked much-maligned mayo, because it was chock full of folate-rich cabbage or because it was branded wholesome, but because I liked it. Crunchy, bright, as good on day 2 as it is on day 7, it was the perfect light meal or side to a sandwich and even though I lived nowhere near the store and found shopping at Zabar’s, even on the slowest day, to be a shopping-cart-rammed-into-the-back-of-my-heels level of annoying (though, really, I should know better than to pause between locals and their smoked fish counter), I was a loyal customer for life so long as they could keep providing me my lightly pickled cabbage fix.

i like it colorful

shaving down the vegetables
adding the celery seed brine
soaked and ready to chill
pickled cabbage salad

Plus, this was in my ovens-are-for-sweater-storage phase of my New York life. Why would I try to make it for myself when someone else was perfectly willing to do it for me?

Flash forward seven years and a couple careers, I wrote an article for NPR in 2007 about coleslaw in which I reversed engineered my Zabar’s favorite. In the seven years since, I all but forgot about it until a cabbage salad from Russ & Daughter’s two weeks ago brought it all back. Because I’m obsessed with timing, part of me thinks this would be a better fit for January, when fat-free, vegetable-rich austerity measures are the order of the month. But the thing is, what with all of these vegetables still going strong at local Greenmarkets, it’s seasonal right now. Plus, do you know what’s coming in the next few weeks? Butter and cream-drenched vegetables. Stuffing. Gravy. Biscuits. Every pie, ever and if you’re lucky, a pumpkin cheesecake too. You’re going to need a lifeboat, something you can have on hand in your fridge to break up the calorie stampede. I vote for this.

pickled cabbage salad

Thanksgiving and beyond on Pinterest! Did you know that you can follow the Smitten Kitchen on Pinterest, and that I’ve been getting the page ready for holiday cooking with new boards with Everything Pumpkin (it’s the most wonderful tiiiiime of the year!), Thanksgiving: Savory (gobble, gobble), Thanksgiving: Sweet (mm, pie), Homemade Food Gifts, plus All The Cookies in the archives, because I promise, there’s nothing wrong with you that two cookies can’t fix. Hope that helps get your November kitchen engines going.

One year ago: Cranberry-Orange Breakfast Buns (please tell me you’ve made these, and if you haven’t, you’ll try soon? you will not regret it.)
Two years ago: Granola-Crusted Nuts
Three years ago: Baked Pumpkin and Sour Cream Puddings
Four years ago: Upside-Down Cranberry Cake
Five years ago: Raisin-Studded Apple Bread Pudding
Six years ago: Cottage Cheese Pancakes, How to Max Out Your Tiny Kitchen and Leite’s Consummate Chocolate Chip Cookies
Seven years ago: Roasted Stuffed Onions
Eight years ago: Not Your Mama’s Coleslaw, Indian-Spiced Vegetable Fritters, Dreamy Cream Scones, Shrimp Cocktail and an Artichoke-Potato Gratin

And for the other side of the world:
Six Months Ago: Five Egg Sandwiches
1.5 Years Ago: Japanese Vegetable Pancakes
2.5 Years Ago: Warm, Crisp and a Little Melty Salad Croutons
3.5 Years Ago: Leek Toasts with Blue Cheese

Pickled Cabbage Salad
Inspired by the health salad at Zabar’s

My primary change to this from my last version, and from the versions I’ve had from delis, was the addition of celery seed. I added it on a whim, and we cannot get enough of the flavor. Just a little permeates the pickle mixture with a hint of celery, without actually using celery, which can get a little beige after pickling. This is a flexible recipe, however. You could add actual celery slices if you wish, red onion or a little red cabbage to create the ink pinky tangled look of the Russ and Daughter’s version (which has only a pinch of carrot and pepper strips in it, and no cucumber). The carrots, cucumbers and peppers I use here are modeled after the Zabar’s version.

Yield: 9 to 10 cups, which shrinks to 7 to 8 cups after pickling

1 1/2 cups white vinegar
1 1/2 cups water
1/3 cup granulated sugar
1/2 teaspoon celery seed
1 tablespoon plus 2 teaspoons kosher salt* plus more to taste  

1 small head (2 pounds) green cabbage
1 red bell pepper
1 carrot (I used only 1/2 my very thick one)
1 kirby cucumber

Mix brine ingredients in the bottom of a medium bowl and set aside.

Prepare your vegetables: Trim and core cabbage and slice thinly with a knife, food processor slicing blade or adjustable-blade slicer. Place in a large bowl. Core, seed and thinly slice red pepper; peel and thinly slice or julienne carrot; thinly slice cucumber (I quartered mine first). Add vegetables to cabbage bowl.

By the time you’re done preparing your vegetables, the sugar and salt should in the pickling mixture should have dissolved. If not, whisk a few times until they do. Taste and adjust if you’d like it a little saltier — I added 1 more teaspoon of kosher salt in the end.

Pour pickling brine over vegetables and cover bowl with a lid or plastic wrap. Refrigerate for 1 hour or up to 1 week. Salad becomes more pickled as it rests. Eat with everything.

* Not all salts are weighted equally: Read more here. I used Morton brand, which for 1 tablespoon plus 2 teaspoons clocks in at 24 grams. If using table or fine sea salt, use only 4 teaspoons.

Leave a Reply to Amy @ What Jew Wanna Eat Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New here? You might want to check out the comment guidelines before chiming in.

155 comments on pickled cabbage salad

  1. Am I making up that they serve health salad when you sit down at the 2nd Avenue Deli? It’s been a million years — even longer than your 2007 article for NPR — but I feel like that was standard. I know they’re no longer on the LES, but maybe it’s still closer than Zabar’s on the UWS? Of course, if you’re already close to Russ and Daugther’s you might as well go there and pick up some candied pecans while you’re out.

  2. JP

    Looks so colorful and yummy. Doesn’t hurt to have something healthy at the beginning of the season of rich foods (Thanksgiving, et al.). Thanks for the great recipe!

  3. Suzanne F

    The Pennsylvania Dutch (where I was born & raised) have been making pickle cabbage for a long time. I agree, it’s a nice change from rich, creamy dressings. It’s a favorite side to ham, part of the 7 sweets & sours. I shred my cabbage a bit finer & use celery in place of the cucumber. It’s nice to see another version of it…can’t wait to try it!

  4. Lyn Never

    This is very close to the Curtido or Cortido I’ve started keeping in my fridge for 2-3 weeks at a time. It’s an absolutely vital addition to fish tacos, but yes – that vinegary cabbagey crunchy thing is so good for balancing anything rich or heavy.

  5. Deanna

    I was trying to remember what this recipe reminded me of, and I finally figured it out…it’s the vinegar slaw from your book with celery seeds instead of dill! (okay, and some additional vegetables).

    You can never have too many recipes for pickley cabbage salads.

  6. Karina

    What do you think about using different vinegar? I almost exclusively use unfiltered apple cider vinegar…I think the acidity is slightly lower. Would it still work?

  7. june

    I make a similar one called curtido. Sub the spices with oregano and a pinch of cumin. Replace cucumber with a whole jalepeno cut up in big chunks. After a week, its SPICY! Great with grilled chops or some salvadorian pupusa!

  8. deb

    SuzyG — It should last a week, if not more. I’ve kept them two weeks, even.

    Celery salt — Is usually just celery seed + salt. I’m not sure what the proportions are, but if they’re half-half, or look that way, I might use 1 teaspoon of it here and reduce the salt by 1/2 to 1 teaspoon (because celery salt is very fine, if I remember correctly), if you’re nervous about it throwing off the salt.

    Celery flakes — I’ve never bought or tried this before, but it sounds like it’s from dehydrated leaves and stalks. It should probably work, although I imagine the flavor would be a little different and they would ultimately get a little soft.

    Apple cider vinegar — Can be used. It is milder and a bit more sweet. It’s also a little beige, so the colors will be less crisp.

    Curtido — I had literally never heard of this before 15 minutes ago and I can’t get over how close it is! My photos look almost exactly the same. Obviously, I must seek some out and make it my new favorite thing, too. Thanks for the tip.

    ZK — That sounds amazing too. I will take down my Hungarian cookbook and learn more shortly.

    holly — The salad’s pickle brine has sugar in it, so it wouldn’t taste the way I was aiming for without it. You’d also want to cut back the salt if cutting back the sugar, perhaps even completely since there’s more sugar than salt.

    Molly — I think they might. I’ve, actually, shh, never been to the new one and it’s been so many years since I went to the old one (which I live a sneeze from). Will fix that this winter.

  9. Matilda

    Fun fact: In Sweden, this is known as a “pizza salad”, and you’ll generally get one in a little plastic tub when you order a pizza! I’ve never seen it done with cucumber here, but it seems like a nice addition – I’ll have to try it :)

  10. Ruthan

    I make something like this with rice wine vinegar and a chunk of konbu. And by “make”, I mean “used to make all the time and will probably go home and make tonight”.

  11. Lia

    My Cambodian mother made a very similar pickle to this all the time when growing up. We usually at it with bbq’ed meat and rice; it helped cut the greasy rich flavor of the meat. Now, I always feel like something is missing if it’s not included in a bbq.

  12. Saya

    I love that you’re doing “on the other side of the world”! I’ve gotten well out of the food blogging world and shut down Sasasunakku completely (busy with writing a thesis and back among my peeps I feel less of an urge to be online) but I always read your posts and it’s nice to know I don’t have to bookmark everything for six months in advance! Thank you.

  13. Randi

    Looks delish. We are pickle fiends in this house. We literally have an entire pickle shelf in our fridge. Also cranberry orange buns are the bomb and they ended up being Christmas morning breakfast! Can’t wait for them again this year!

  14. Bridget G

    This has been the only way I’ve made slaw for the last 10 years…. I think it’s so much yummier than the traditional method with mayo, probably because I’m a huge fan of vinegar.

  15. Jillian F

    This looks great!! Have you tried cutting back the salt in any of your brines? Normally I don’t want to mess with your recipes, but I really, really like pickled veggies so I’m a bit worried I’m eating too much salt. Would I cut back on the sugar/salt evenly? Any thoughts?

  16. Ruthan

    Sarah is probably looking for something like strawberry pretzel salad. (If you’re somewhere that it’s likely to be served, it totally counts as salad.)

  17. Peg

    I have always loved this and I have to add paper thin Vidalia onions. The flavor is fabulous and I always serve with pulled pork or smoked ham. Yum! (Thanks for reminding me to get it in the brine before Thanksgiving)

  18. Margie

    The cranberry orange breakfast buns are the best ever! There are a ton of cinnamon bun recipes out there – strange doughs and even stranger fillings – but your cranberry orange buns are just about perfect. They are a new fall tradition.

  19. Katie G

    My family makes a slaw similar to this, and although it sounds strange, it is delicious with broken up ramen noodles on top (uncooked and unflavored).

  20. Yes! This salad sounds so good. I do a similar thing and make Salvadorean curtido de repollo — basically spicy pickled cabbage that you then put on tacos and chili and burritos forever. It lasts months in the fridge! I am super excited to try out this variation. :)

    1. deb

      Cammie — I have never tried to pickle kale but I imagine it might wilt instead of crisp up, at least the flat kale. Do let me know how it goes if you try it; I’m curious!

  21. I come from a Dutch background and pickled cabbage is a staple. The brine is heated and poured on the veggies hot, and then the mixture is chillled for a couple of days. I like all the ideas for serving (pizza, fish tacos, burritos, etc.)

  22. I love this recipe because I happen to live in an area (Buffalo, NY) where cabbage is a big, big deal. Everyone eats cabbage here! The famous food trucks use it in lieu of salad on their taco’s. And like you said, so healthy, love that too. Great recipe.

  23. Yum.. nostalgic for the old take away spots Zabars and so many lovely delis.

    Have to make everything from scratch (kind of lying) up here in the woods
    Thank you for this update

  24. june2

    Love all the cross-cultural recipe notes flying through the comments! I like to add juniper berries…they’ve become my favorite addition.

  25. Emily

    Thank you, thank you, thank you for adding the .5 for the antipodes! I always save recipes for when it comes around to Summer and we can gorge on summer fruit but never go back to them. You’re a wonderful person!

  26. J’Marinde Shephard

    Don’t we have to boil the brine first?
    Can one add shaved Brussels sprouts to this mix too?
    What about some garlic and dill? Some tall romaine leaves? And maybe some walnuts?

    Thanks for sharing this MOST delightful and delicious-looking recipe. I cannot wait to try this.

  27. Lovely and fresh!

    My husband often craves crunch- being a vegetarian he doesn’t have crackling, the caught edge of a lamb chop, ribbons of salty bacon……to chaw down on.

    So I have to find other ways, ways other than a handful of crisps on his plate- this will do nicely for those days when I cannot be arsed to roast potatoes or cauliflowers to a crisp.

  28. Helen

    This looks and sounds exactly like a recipe my Mom makes, but we all call it cole slaw. I love it and it keeps in the fridge for weeks, too. Thanks for your riff on the this “slaw”!

  29. dc

    Yum!! I grew up with vinegar and oil coleslaw with paprika so this is right up my alley!! Well, and pickled anything works pretty well too!

  30. Pburger

    This is very similar to my German/Hungarian grandmother’s “Freezer Spiced Cabbage”. There is a teaspoon of dry mustard in it as well. The dressing is boiled, and cooled before mixing into the veg. Then chill in the refrigerator and freeze it. It keeps a long time. And the cabbage is crunchy even after thawing.

  31. deb

    J’Marinde — No need to boil the brine. Brussels sprouts might pickle well, but I’ve never tried to pickle romaine leaves or walnuts. Garlic and dill could be added if you wish.

    Elizabeth — I’ve never tried to pickle savoy. I suspect it would be softer but it should probably still work? I honestly cannot guess in this case. :(

  32. stephanie

    “would love to see what the category of “non-health salads” looks like.”
    @sarah taco salad. it looks like taco salad. (i also would wager southerners might have some great answers to this as well :))

    and deb, i’ve said this before (and i’ll keep saying it!) the mediterranean pepper salad is one of my most favorite things, certainly my most favorite salad. always get a little fangirl “ooh, they mentioned The Salad!” …i mean, what is wrong with me? anyway, cole slaw, yes. will add to my list. i love making slaws, and every time i make them the boyfriend says the same thing. “i can’t tell if i love this or hate this.” and then he pushes it around his plate even though i know he likes it but the man won’t eat a vegetable outside of corn or iceberg lettuce. it’s terrible. and forget about fruits all together. i really don’t know how he’s alive, to be honest. oh well, more for me.

  33. stephanie

    also, to be ~that person~, this sentence could use a little, erm…help. (not that we don’t all know what it’s supposed to say, of course.) “the sugar and salt should in the pickling mixture should dissolved.”

  34. Mona

    This was made by my German grandparents with the addition of mustard seed. They used a lot more sugar, but I have scaled down the sugar quite a bit. Yummy!

  35. melissa

    Thanks so much for updating your pickled slaw! It is my favorite slaw recipe and an absolutely required when making any sort of pulled pork. Just a couple of hints for those who haven’t made it and have missing out on the best slaw in the world: Using all purple cabbage makes everything this odd bright purple, so stick to green (I’ve made that mistake); adding a bit of onion makes it divine (and very similar in taste to KFC only with vinegar instead of mayo–a plus); and substituting a regular garden cucumber means mush on day 7–use a kirby like Deb suggests. Thank you as always, Deb!

  36. Liz

    This would be a nice side for a turkey sandwich. Especially healthy after the richness of Thanksgiving food.

    I’ve pickled Brussels sprouts and also made sauerkraut with them. I was pleased with them both. A mixture of freshly roasted Brussels sprouts and chopped sauerkraut ones was an interesting side.

  37. Mino

    can this “pickled cabbage salad” be made without salt?
    I love pickled foods but need to stay away from salt… you have a solution for us?

  38. Deanna

    I was just over on Food52 and they mentioned your brought “Pizza Beans” to a potluck with Dana Cowin. It sounds perfect for winter! Any chance it’s up next or is it being saved for the new book?

  39. Bobbie Kramer

    Pickling and Kosher salt have no added ingredients like anti-caking or iodine, which might produce off-colors or flavors in your pickle. The main difference between the two is the size of the crystals. Kosher salt has bigger, flaky crystals, and weighs less per volume than the smaller crystals in pickling salt. Sea salt and flavored salt crystals can also vary in size, and have additional ingredients that could change the flavor or color of your pickles. Best salt to use for consistency: Pickling salt.

  40. Sue from Pleasanton

    Sarah, and others wanting to know what an “unhealthy” salad is: my mom would put a leaf of iceberg lettuce on each plate. Whip about 3-4 tablespoons of heavy cream, stir in a spoon of peanut butter, and spoon atop the lettuce. Then add a few slices of banana to decorate. I liked it as it was almost dessert. And we ALWAYS had dessert.

  41. Laurie

    Just had a version of this at Fuego (DC suburb) that included jalapeños and cauliflower – addictive but VERY spicy, as the restaurant name might imply … highly recommend!

  42. juliana

    Just made this for a potluck on Friday! It’ll sit and get yummier and I don’t have to worry about day before preparation! YeaHoo!

  43. Mary

    Hi Deb, long time reader of your blog and cookbook and recipe-trier, first time poster. I just was over on Food52 and they mentioned you were at a potluck party for Dana Cowin’s new book (how cool) and brought something awesome called “pizza beans” Can you share it? Can you tell us how fun the party was?


  44. Wife To An Amazing Cook

    This recipe reminds me of your pickled vegetable sandwich slaw – which we LOVE. Can’t wait to try this version… looks even quicker/easier since there’s no boiling/cooling of the brine required. And I’m drooling over some of the variations in the comments; I’m adding Brussels sprouts and cauliflower to the list right now!

  45. Kim

    I just tried the pickled vegetable slaw over the weekend which I loved! Is this one similar at all? Just curious as I will be making more in the days to come. Now wondering which to make. All the best

    1. deb

      Kim — It is. That one is a little bit saltier (these cabbage salads are usually more sweet) and it uses mustard seeds and different flavors… but very similar.

      About those “pizza beans” — So, I never meant to be a tease, and I didn’t know they’d be mentioned (though of course I’m glad everyone loved them) but they are something I’m working on for the next book. I’d never have teased you over here. And my son called them pizza beans; I thought I’d made something grown-up. ;)

      Mino — If you’re skipping the salt, I might skip all or most of the sugar too. It will taste different, of course…

      stephanie — Thanks, now fixed.

  46. Trisha

    I do love curtido, so I’ll have to try this. I am intrigued by the idea of adding cauliflower, which some other commenters mentioned.

  47. Sandra

    Something very like this has been around for literally hundreds of years. In medieval times, however, it often made in layers (adding more vegetables to the crock as they were picked) and was called (at least in some places) compost. This was, of course, long before “compost” came to mean layered no-longer-edible vegetables.

  48. Patience

    Hi Deb, unrelated to these delicious looking pickles, I want to also give a big Southern Hemisphere HOORAY for your ‘other side of the world’ recipe histories. Love reading your blog anyway, but it can sometimes seem incongruous salivating over midwinter fare when we’re living on mangoes, peaches, cherries, bbqs and salads. We have eaten some strange things when I can’t resist cooking your latest recipe, despite being completely out of season. Thank you for thinking of us down here :-)

  49. vanessa mcnelly

    my mother made this many years ago. she called it “forever cole slaw And like you she put hers in a nice clear glass dish. we always made it at Thanksgiving and then served it again at Christmas when the flavors had had a chance to blend. one year my son was tasked with getting it from the fridge to the table.. thereafter we refer to the incident as the year KEVIN DROPPED THE COLE SLAW. I know you will understand that my eyes did shed a tear or ten when I saw all that yumminess hit the ground.

  50. Phin

    Mmm, celery seed. That’s the semi-secret ingredient to my mom’s cole slaw. Celery seed and a mayonnaise dressing. I’ll have to try this to see how it’s different.

  51. Ken

    As mentioned by someone, this is very similar to Haitian “pikliz”. While traditional pikliz has an alarmingly number of Scotch Bonnet/habanero peppers per jar, you can start with this recipe and add just a hint of heat by slicing a jalapeno pepper in half and incorporating it. I always try to invert the jar holding this once or twice a day to get the pepper flavor to blend throughout. Adjust the number of peppers to suit your taste, if you like the heat but it’s too much, try half a pepper; or add more if it’s not enough.

  52. Liz

    This is pretty similar to a side dish called achar in Peranakan (Straits Chinese) cuisine! Apart from cucumbers and carrots, we also use pineapple chunks, and long beans and pickle them in a spicy pickle that consists of shallots, red chillies, candlenuts, tumeric powder and some water all blended together and fried before adding the vinegar. Then we add some chopped roasted peanuts and sesame seeds for crunch and keep it in the fridge to have with all the meals we can have it with.

  53. I make a Pennsylvania Dutch salad called pepper cabbage that is similar to this – although it’s less of a brine and more of dressing with some oil in it. It can be frozen with great success – SO CONVENIENT when cabbages are enormous right now and dirt cheap. I serve it as a salad, sandwich additive, or side dish to anything.

  54. MaryTinsa

    We used savoy and also added a yellow wax pepper. Excellent side with noodle beef stir-fry and I can’t wait to toss it on a sandwich. I used a inexpensive Oxy mandolin for the carrot and kirby cucumber’s I found at our weekly farmer’s market.

  55. Erika

    This was amazing (I’m not crazy about bell peppers usually, so I left them out–still good!). I may find myself making it weekly. Husband loved it, daughter loved it and even ate it when I put it in her lunch–all-around win. We’re having it tonight with hot dogs & leftover crash hot potatoes.

  56. LH

    Yes, as ZK says this is a very popular salad in Hungary known as csalamade salata. In my child’s level Hungarian I have always interpreted this as “family salad” (csalad) because there’s a specialize version depending on which restaurant or family you visit.

  57. Barbara

    Not for those on a low sodium diet, I’m sure, but do you know the approximate amount of sodium that lives on in the salad after pickling?

    1. deb

      Barbara — No, I would not be able to find out without a chemistry lab, I fear. However, if you’re looking to reduce the salt, do it proportionally with the sugar, so if less salt, less sugar too.

  58. Trystate

    I’m distantly related to Tracey Zabar thru marriage. We’ve been thrown together at a number of family events – Summer BBQs, bar mitzvahs, weddings. She’s a pip, a genuine UWS artifact, and an obsessive baker. If the opportunity to meet her ever presents itself, Deb, make it happen. I think you two might really hit it off. Imagine – unlimited access to ‘health salad’!

  59. Mary

    This. Was. Awesome. Every member of my family liked this (and this is saying a LOT). We had it with some beans cooked with Indian spices, and it was a really tasty counterpoint. Can’t believe I’ve gone so long in my life without this dish. Thank you!

  60. Helen

    Just made this last night, and I’m counting the hours to lunch so I can eat it again. We did it as a side to the always delicious, totally crowd-pleasing baked pasta with sausage and broccoli rabe. I’m thinking we should start a hashtag #dinnerbydeb

  61. MomsintheGarden

    Thank you for this simple, fabulous recipe! We harvested a lot of cabbages from our garden, and I was looking for a non-mayonnaisey salad for them. This fits the bill perfectly! Everyone likes it.

  62. Anon321

    Yum – thank you! Found this when looking for a pickled cabbage recipe to go with the no-rotisserie-needed chicken shawarma recipe just published on nytimes. My favorite London shawarma shop was unique in offering pickled cabbage as well as the lettuce/tomato/onion that usually counts as “salad” for British sandwiches. Have been back home in the US for 2 years, and so happy that I will be making shawarma this weekend!

  63. Sal


    I am posting here for the first time. I followed your directions (my cabbage may have been too big) but the brine didnt cover the veggies in my big bowl. Should it be covering them all the time when storing it in the fridge?

    I did have the glass containers like you show in your pics but the liquid is not all the way up.

    Would appreciate your help. I think I’ll love this since my Jamaican Jerk chicken shop sells a kind of picked cabbage but this looks close to it.

    Thank You.

    1. deb

      Sal — Yes, I think it was the same for me. I just shook it up/tossed it around whenever I saw it for the first couple days, then it had collapsed enough that it wasn’t an issue.

  64. Michelle

    Hi Deb – I’m a HUGE fan of your site. I just recently found it and have been working my way through your archives. Quick question about the brine – do you know if you can sub out the sugar for splenda? I’d like to make this for a brunch coming up but mom can’t have sugar.


  65. MadeleineC

    I made this with yellow peppers instead of red and sliced radishes instead of cucumber because they were what I had on hand, and it was delicious. But the best part was the colors after it sat in the fridge overnight. The radishes brightened and bled a lovely pale pink into the brine , making the prettiest yellow, orange, pink and white salad ever!

  66. Sarah V.

    Any idea if it’s okay to make/store this in a metal bowl? I don’t have a glass one large enough and I’m worried about ruining the salad with a metallic aftertaste.

    1. deb

      Sarah — Only reactive metals (aluminum, copper) will be an issue. Most metal mixing bowls these days are stainless steel, which shouldn’t be an issue.

  67. Sarah V.

    Fantastic – thank you so much Deb! Also, anyone have experience doubling (or tripling) the recipe? I’m bringing it to a food swap!! :)

  68. Do you think this could be canned in a hot water bath and kept in the pantry until opened? We have an abundance of cabbage this year and I would like to make a dozen quart jars for use through-out the winter.

  69. Steph

    Love that this is an “instant” pickle, and can be kept fresh for use, but do you think it would bottle OK too? As with Dori S I’ve a glut of these and am looking to make the most of them (tooooo good to be pig food!) Thanks :)

  70. deb

    Dori, Steph — I don’t consider myself a canning expert although I cannot find any reason here it wouldn’t be okay to can this, it might be best to cross-check in on a canning forum just to be safe.

  71. I love your blog and this “surprise me!” feature is fantastic!! Anyway, I’m living in Haiti for 2016 and this recipe looks a lot like Pikliz, except we add spice to it (in Port-au-Prince, we normally use scotch bonnet peppers). Thanks for sharing this with the world!

  72. Karen I

    OMG…will be putting in the garbage…1 Tablespoon of salt and 2 teaspoons…its horrible and I love salt!

  73. Margaret

    I originally found this recipe on NPR’s website and just came across this post here (a blog I’m already well-acquainted with). So happy to learn that the cooking step is not necessary! I have been making this for years. I top each serving with crumbled (deli) feta. Great combination.

  74. Sandy

    Have been following you for years and have loved everything I made from SK recipes. I just made this salad, and, wow!! Majorly delicious. Thanks for another great recipe!

  75. Terri

    I didn’t have white vinegar (living abroad and haven’t tracked down where to find it yet), so used a mishmash of white and red wine vinegars and apple cider vinegar. If I had it all to do again, I would cut back on the sugar. I suspect that the varieties of vinegar I used made for a sweeter finished product. But it was still good. Someone asked me where I got the recipe, and thought it must be an old family recipe.

  76. svetlanafaulkner

    The cabbage is best fermented i.e. without any vinegar or water in a natural way. That’s the Russian way of making and storing it.
    Simply the best

  77. Kris

    Perfect! This is very similar to the slaw at Pickle Barrel in the Toronto area. I’ve been trying to replicate it for years. The celery seed is key. I also used the brine in a jar of thinly sliced red onions. Mmmmm!

  78. Emily

    I made this and the pickled sandwich slaw last weekend – both are good but this is my favorite! I used coleslaw mix (preshredded cabbage with a little carrot) and Persian cucumbers – very easy. Just made a second batch!

  79. Annette

    I would like to try this pickled cabbage salad but I do not use sugar can I add pureed or minced dates to the brine?
    Thank you

  80. Teresa

    Hi Deb (and anyone else who hasade this recipe) I’m planning to make pickles for gifts this Christmas. I’m looking for a recipe I can make say a week before visiting, and then they still have a couple of weeks to eat them (we all know they won’t last that long, but it’s the thought) Could this recipe be it?

    Thanks so much 😊

  81. Kathy

    Hi Deb, this has turned out to be a perfect salad for these days of self-isolation. Cheap, adaptable and long lasting, with readily available ingredients. I didn’t have celery seeds in the pantry so I added a generous pinch of red pepper flakes to the dressing. A welcome bit of freshness and crunch to add to the day. I constantly have a jar in the fridge now. Thank you for this.

  82. Nancy Wright

    Can this brine be re-used? There is a ton of liquid left and I’m wondering if I can keep adding more sliced vegetables?

  83. Sarah Casseday

    I’m going to try this Cole slaw since it does sound delish! So far the very BEST I’ve ever had (and I’m a Southerner so I’ve eaten lots) was at Steamers in Kitty Hawk NC. The chef told me the recipe came from his Grandmother’s church cookbook, but he didn’t share it.

  84. Kristin

    I make this on the regular. It works with all cabbage types or even a sad bad of Cole slaw mix. It is my go to vegetable when I need to have dinner ready within 2 minutes of stepping in the door because this is a salad that is made the night before. Add a crock pot soup and dinner is done before I leave for work. With a little that has a 7 pm bedtime, that is magic.

  85. Karen

    Dear Deb- I have found the taste of white vinegar a little overwhelming when pickling veges. Can I substitute rice vinegar? Thank you!