light brioche burger buns
In the six weeks since, I have waded through nearly 100 burger bun recipes, all submitted by you kind folks with promises that they’d be better. I saw white bread buns and challah buns and whole wheat sourdough buns and you-name-it buns and, gah, I barely knew where to begin. And then, just as I was halfway through the early steps of a totally different hamburger bun recipe that, if all goes well, will be a wonderful, unusual complement to these, I dropped that effort completely in the pursuit of the Light Brioche Buns run in the New York Times article this week on the elements of a perfect burger.
My hunch that they were onto something grand was duly rewarded. These buns are plush and mildly sweet and slightly buttery; think of them as halfway between a high-quality white bread and a decadent brioche. When you pick them up, they feel heavy for their size and when you lightly toast their edges — a must, says both the New York Times and yours truly — before building your perfect burger dreams upon it, they sing. You’ll sing. Seriously, I had a Moment with these yesterday, part relief that the recipe I’d been looking for was indeed out there and — bonus! — not laden with an excess of steps or labor and part a deep sigh, because they’re splendid, and I can’t wait to give them a proper spin on the grill tomorrow. If they make it that long.
Previously: I’ve been posting up a storm this week, but promise to stop now. Check out the Watermelon Lemonade I’m drinking right this very second or an avalanche of July 4th slaw and sides ideas if you’re just catching up now.
Light Brioche Burger Buns
Adapted from Comme Ça restaurant in Los Angeles, via the New York Times
Go! Make these! What are you waiting for?
Makes 8 4 to 5-inch burger buns
3 tablespoons warm milk
2 teaspoons active dry yeast
2 1/2 tablespoons sugar
2 large eggs
3 cups bread flour
1/3 cup all-purpose flour
1 1/2 teaspoons salt
2 1/2 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
Sesame seeds (optional)
1. In a glass measuring cup, combine one cup warm water, the milk, yeast and sugar. Let stand until foamy, about five minutes. Meanwhile, beat one egg.
2. In a large bowl, whisk flours with salt. Add butter and rub into flour between your fingers, making crumbs. Using a dough scraper, stir in yeast mixture and beaten egg until a dough forms. Scrape dough onto clean, well-floured counter and knead, scooping dough up, slapping it on counter and turning it, until smooth and elastic, 8 to 10 minutes. The dough will be on the sticky side so it can be a bit messy, but keep in mind that the more flour you knead in, the tougher the buns will get. Try to leave them tackier than you would a round loaf.
3. Shape dough into a ball and return it to bowl. Cover bowl with plastic wrap and let rise in a warm place until doubled in bulk, one to two hours. (In my freaky, warm apartment this only took an hour.)
4. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Using dough scraper, divide dough into 8 equal parts. Gently roll each into a ball and arrange two to three inches apart on baking sheet. Cover loosely with a piece of plastic wrap lightly coated in nonstick spray and let buns rise in a warm place for one to two hours. (Again, this only took one hour in my apartment and I suspect, you’ll also only need an hour for a second rise.)
5. Set a large shallow pan of water on oven floor. Preheat oven to 400 degrees with rack in center. Beat remaining egg with one tablespoon water and brush some on top of buns. Sprinkle with sesame seeds, if using. Bake, turning sheet halfway through baking, until tops are golden brown, about 15 minutes. Transfer to a rack to cool completely.














I really don’t think anyone minds you “posting up a storm.” I know I am delighted, despite a six week separation from my kitchen…
Mmm, looks good! I must say, Deb, I just made the black bean confetti salad and I cannot stop shoveling it into my mouth (on top of tortilla chips). My boyfriend and I (but mainly me – he’s busy washing dishes now, score!) have put a major dent into this dip already. I might just eat all of this and get rid of any ideas of making dinner tonight, hah.
Thanks for another wonderful recipe. I always come to you when I want to make something that I KNOW will be amazing. :-)
Oh my gosh! I’m so glad you found it, and I can’t wait to try it. Thanks for sharing in time for July 4th grilling!
Mmmm Comme Ca. Good place to eat. If someone pulls out a homemade burger bun for us tomorrow, we’ll be too through. No weenies for us, only burgers!
i’m with emma…post-away! we’re luckiest when you do ;o)
Just saw this recipe in the NYT the other day and was thinking of trying it for the Fourth…now I know it will be great! Yum and thanks for the suggestion. :)
Comme Ca is one of my favorite places in LA, I miss living right around the corner! Their burger is amazing and with your review this recipe has moved up on my list of thing to try!
Wow this looks like a fun one to try! My kids and I have been making your pizza dough every friday for a couple of weeks now and it has been really fun for them to knead the dough and watch it rise and then shape (and top) their own pizzas. But now I’v got the bread making bug so these will have to be on the menu next week for sure.
Hooray! I’ve been trying to find a great bun too! Though sadly, I won’t have time to whip these up before tomorrow…but soon, very soon!
And thanks for the pictures of the interior. The crumb looks lovely!
I saw the recipe this week and made them for my family. The consensus was they’re better than the one’s I’ve made in the past. So I guess I’ve found my holy grail.
HI. I love your beautiful yummy blog! I have been meaning to write and let you know I added you to my new food blog sidebar recently & enjoy going to your blog as a daily read. Just wanted to stop by and introduce myself! Have a great day.
These look beautiful! Definitely going to give them a try!!
Do you remember when you asked everyone what they were afraid of? I did not answer the poll. But the truth is… it’s yeast / bread baking. Like a lot of other people I think? Wish I wasn’t though… They look delicious!
Just made the confetti salad and it is yummy! This bread might just kill me, but oh, what a way to go. You got lovely buns.
wow! these look great i had a brioche bun with a burger in an american themed restaurant here in the uk and the slightly sweet bun with the burger was crazy good! ive been searching for something like this now its BBQ season here but you cant get them for love nor money in the UK they just dont get it! cant wait to get baking with this one my fiancee is going to love it!
P.S the more posting the better!
These look like the perfect buns. I will save them for when I have time ( and a grill in my future).
No complaints here about the frequent posting although I’m sure it will slow once you have a little one to take care of. Soon right? Can’t wait to see pics of the lil’ Smitten.
I like you when you’re pregnant Deb. Somehow all the recipes you’ve been posting lately have been extra, extra appealing to me. This makes me crave summer…which is weird because I usually love winter…damn you northern hemisphereans…
Oh this stinks–not the recipe, it sounds heavenly! I have been looking for an easy enough (because yeast doughs take a little bit of practice) and delicious hamburger bun. Mere minutes ago I got done mixing up a different (and not as yummy sounding as these) batch of hamburger buns and now I find your recipe!!! I wish I had sat down at the computer an hour ago…
So why did you not go with the whole-wheat sourdough ones?
Last thing the world needs is another vehicle for butter, Deb.
tsk tsk ;)
Do you think these would work for hotdog buns too?
Well, I thought I had found my “perfect bun” recipe a few years ago, to the point that I never even considered trying another one.
But I think I’ll give this one a try, sounds terrific!
:-)
these look really good, been a while since I baked bread this will be next on my list
This is a great, great find. I’ve seen a couple of mouthwatering burger recipes that all said would pair lovely with brioche buns and I had no idea where I would get those in my disjointed metro area. Alas, I can make them!
Happy 4th! I hope the almost- baby likes fireworks
What amazing timing — these buns are doing their second rise on my counter right now! My dough was really, really sticky though…maybe it needed more flour? I haven’t perfected bread making yet, so if anyone knows what I did wrong, do tell!
I just recently got my Hot Shoppes cookbook in the mail (I’m orig from DC area) and need the high rise bun that I can take a center slice out of for a double decker Mighty Mo burger. This looks like it! The book says they had their buns made for them and they were a little on the sweet side. You, my dear, are right on time with this recipe! Thanks!
I have also bookmarked that recipe and am planning to make these along with that tomato compote to serve at my daughter’s birthday party next week (slider sized, so I’m a a little nervous, but will leave time for my back up recipe if these are a no-go). Love that interior shot! Mouthwatering.
Oh, lovely buns. Bring bread on anyway it comes. Happy 4th and if you have more stuff to post we really don’t mind.
Nicole — Definitely on the sticky side. I had a good amount of flour on the counter, and sprinkled more on as needed. I tried to resist adding a ton more, when I formed them into rolls they were still quite sticky. I should point you (and others) to my bread tips post — the less flour you can get away with, the more moist bread ends up. If you get frustrated, let it rest a few minutes on the counter so whatever flour you’ve added insofar absorbs a bit.
Interesting recipe. I made one from Epicurious a few weeks ago and when I compare the ingredient lists, they are very different.
I thought the Epicurious ones were pretty good but I’m going to give your recipe a try soon.
I rolled my dough and cut it out using a cutter and that helped the final buns to be very uniform. You can check out my other tips and a link to the Epicurious recipe on my blog if you’re curious.
Love any kind of homemade bread! These look delicious.
Thanks! This is JUST what I needed right now! I needed to get off the computer and go make some hamburger buns, and this is PERFECT!! :-)
Glad to see you found a recipe and the results look delish! This looks easy to make if I can get past the sticky dough. Thanks for sharing!
Looks good. I’m going to bookmark this for later this summer.
BTW, I made a rendition of your Med. Pepper salad the other day and it was simply divine. Loving it!
LadyC
This looks really good. I’d eat it with butter if i don’t have burgers..heehee
These will be great with the Turkey Burger recipe on my blog! I can’t wait to make them.
I made these buns earlier today from the nyt artickle and they were delicious. As for the dough, it was very very sticky but I didn’t add any extra flour as I was afraid to deviate from the recipe. Also, our apartment is cool so I put the dough in my bottom oven with a pan of hot water on the bottom to creat the warmth. (stole this trick from the joy of cooking cookbook) I also made the burger and sides that were in the article as well…the tomato compote, tarrago pickles and slaw were great on the burger. It really was delicious…we had burger juice running down our elbow…sign of a good burger! spent all day in the kitchen but had a blast! Also, I froze the extra buns for my inlaws who are visiting in a few weeks by wrapping each bun in foil and then putting in a ziplock bag. will let you know if they taste fresh when I thaw and toast.
What a great idea! I never thought of using brioche for burgers!
Oh gosh, these seem perfect!! I’m afraid if I eat one I’ll never want a store-bought one again!
I can’t wait to try this. One of the most maddening food conundrums is how difficult it is to find good hamburger buns. Sometimes we just eat the meat because I don’t have the bandwidth to devote to The Hunt. And you’re right–these look easy. I’m all over it.
Lovely buns! I never thought of using brioche for burgers, definitely going to give them a try!
These buns look simply divine, and I bet they’re healthier than the store bought ones as well.
These buns look perfect!! I wish I could make such good-looking buns too!!
This recipie looks so yummy.. Can’t wait to try it any sugesstions on how to adapt this for a bread machine using the dough cycle?
Hmmmmm- these are begging for a spicy black bean burger….. Thanks so much! -e
I don’t mind you posting up a storm at all – I love the posts! What gorgeous sounding buns :D
Can I make this dough in a bread machine? I have a very active two year old and I need my eyes on her all the time. Deb, you will understand this in about 2 years :)
I’m so glad you did all the work for me. I’ve been struggling with an average bun recipe for the last few months and just gave up. Now I’m back on my game. And speaking of game, I’m really impressed at your ability to steadily eat food and post about it even though you’re pregnant. I’m 21 weeks, and a tree stump is more useful than I am. I’m pretty sure if I eat another container of takeout, my kid is going to come out made of styrofoam. Major props to you.
I made these tonight. Almost disaster, my yeast didn’t yeast itself up, but I fixed the error before all was lost and the buns came out beautifully!
Thanks especially for the “don’t add flour to the sloppy dough” tip. I kneaded the gloppiness into submission and it really paid off.
In the end the buns were a big hit at a birthday BBQ here in Australia.
Don’t apologize for posting up a storm! Love your recipes!
for Emily…can you give us the recipe for the black bean burger…I’ve been wanting to make vegetarian burgers…or Deb, maybe you have one…I’ll check
My 11-year-old son stumbled upon your site in a search for black and white cookies. I am totally in love – it is FABULOUS! I worked on putting together a cookbook a couple of years ago for a woman’s club and know how hard it is to get the right photo. Your photos are incredible and your recipes mouth-watering! Shamefully, I’ve been on somewhat of a cookie hiatus after all the testing for the cookbook — it looks like I’m going to have to start cooking again to try your recipes!
I have a favorite bun recipe that’s very similar. Although I use buttermilk in mine and I always substitute a cup of freshly ground wheat flour to give them that nice wheaty bite a little texture and that lovely wheat flecked appearance. We made mini pub burgers last night for our get-together.
We had a guinness themed party featuring your Irish Car Bomb cupcakes (although I think the original half ganache recepe would suffice, a little too rich with so much ganach). Everything in the menu contained Guinness, including the homemade chocolate ice cream to top it all off. MMMM, nothing like an Irish 4th of July celebration!
Thank you for your due diligence on finding the perfect recipe. Now the rest of us get to benefit from your hard work and angst. These look light, flavorful, and simply delicious!
Who said you’re posting up a strom? I’m enjoying every bit of it! As soon as I saw the buns I knew that you’d finally overcome the sad buns you ended up with a while ago. These look great, Deb.
oh these look so good. They re perfect. Anyways your bakes are always spectacular :)
Ooh, thanks for posting this! I’ve really been wanting a recipe for burger (and hot dog) buns since I live in a part of the world where they aren’t sold, but I have been too busy (or lazy, if you like) to hunt through all the possibilities. I can’t wait to try this!
I am definitely going to make these! they look scrumptious. but I’m worried, what’s the difference between all-purpose flour and bread flour? can i use AP flour instead and get the same results?
Do you think they would freeze well? Or that the recipe would half well? With only two of us in the house, we probably wouldn’t be able to go through all 8 buns! This recipe sounds perfect though- I love brioche-like buns!
Yay! I was hoping you would find the perfect burger bun. I made some a while back that I wasn’t entirely pleased with (they weren’t thick enough). I’m going to pick up an order of Texas Longhorn beef today that includes 25 lbs of burger meat. I can’t wait to try these!
I’m giving these a shot before I run out of time and have to go to the store for buns! First rise is looking good but my dough wasn’t all that sticky (at least not compared to some doughs I make) so I hope they turn out. Humidity is very low in Seattle right now; no rain for a couple of months… Any chance of providing the weight you use for one cup of each flour type? It might make the recipes more repeatable.
Laila — Bread flour has more gluten in it than all-purpose. You can use AP instead, but breads generally work best with bread flour.
Elizabeth — There’s no reason you cannot halve, double, freeze, etc. anything you need to with this recipe.
I can’t wait to try these! I like a little whole wheat, so I think I’ll sub in a bit. Do you think I should use some in place of the AP, or use less bread flour? I’m thinking 1/2-3/4 of a cup.
Sharon commented on adding whole wheat–have you tried that and what do you recommend? I’ve been on a fresh bread making kick for a while and these look wonderful!
My rule for substituting whole wheat flour in a recipe where I have not done it before is to start with a 1/3 swap. It’s a pretty safe level to get you that whole wheat heft without throwing off the softness of what you’re baking too much. The next time, if you feel you’d wanted it heartier, you can move up to the 50/50 level.
I was wondering if this would work well in a bread machine, as well…any thoughts?
Thanks
I have never used a bread machine before. I suspect you can use it for the mixing/kneading/dough prep part (though you’ll still need to proof the yeast outside the machine because it’s active dry and not instant or bread machine yeast, which does not need pre-proofing, hm, yes, I believe this is why I never use bread machines: by the time you’ve done all that, you could have had two doughs made and kneaded!).
I’m so glad you tried this recipe out–I was pretty excited when I saw it too but haven’t had a chance to make them. Did you cook the burgers the way the NYT suggested too?
Cindy, I’ve used a bread machine to make dough the same way I use my stand mixer now. I’ve never liked to actually bake in a bread machine, but for kneading it can be handy sometimes. Proof the yeast in the machine, then dump everything else in and let it mix. I guess you could even let it do the first rise in there, too.
I’m thinking the next time I’m feeling bake-y I’ll make a whole bunch of these and freeze them. I hate last-minute crappy fluffy bun purchases. I always feel like a dope when I end up with buns like that because I didn’t plan ahead (like this afternoon, for example).
I dreamt about these last night. seriously. all night long….the perfect bun! weeee!!!!
These look amazing and wish we were having them with out turkey burgers tonight instead of english muffins :-). Just a note – the word you want is “eke” not “eek”. Sorry, I am a word nerd.
and i have a typo, too! our turkey burgers
Oh my goodness…I was just leafing through magazines while waiting for the teenager to finish with his haircut. There was a great little recipe for mini veggie burgers in a brioche burger bun….but no recipe for the buns. See?! Now I have it…ooops and a torn out recipe from a magazine from a salon that shall remain nameless…grin
so cute. Looks a bit like a baked pork bun…
Just made the buns for an awesome turkey burger 4th of July supper. Wow! Those buns are keepers! Just the right hint of everything that’s lovely. I didn’t use sesame seeds on the top and I don’t think I missed them.
Yea for brioche buns!
Just made these, and they are AMAZING! Using a bench scraper saved my life, and this recipe is definitely a keeper for any type of sandwich needing a bun. I look forward to more excessive posting!
Oh I am so thankful to spot this recipe today! I was searching online for a brioche recipe and yours came up (funny enough, I read your blog daily, except for the past 2 days!). I am hoping to make my son a huge cheeseburger for his birthday dinner, I am assuming this can be baked as one large bun as well?
These are fabulous looking…I can’t wait to give them a try. I think anything made from brioche would be incredible.
These look excellent! Too bad I’m lazy and bought the pre-made buns for my grilling party today… :D Oh well. I made lemon bars. That should be good enough.
As a substitute for bread flour I add gluten flour to regular flour, subbing in 1 teaspoon per cup of all purpose or whole wheat flour. Gluten flour is available at natural foods stores, and also many supermarkets, usually in the natural foods section. Keeps a long time (perhaps forever, I have not had any go bad, ever) and makes that nice, stretchy, elastic dough needed for great bread, even 100% whole grain breads. (If you use too much, though, you’ll end up with dough that kneads like a rubber ball!)
I made these last night and they were fantastic (If I do say so myself).
Being the rather lazy type I am, and given the comments that it was a wet dough, I used the technique that Dan Lepard often describes in his recipes – e.g. no 8-10 minute knead, instead, rest for 10 mins, then knead for 10 secs (I do it in the bowl) – repeat 2 more times (10 mins and quick knead), then rest for 30 mins and knead for 10 secs – repeating a couple of times. Then I shaped, left for an hour and into the oven they went… I didn’t egg glaze them – they went into the oven naked, but I still got a great colour on them after 15 mins.
Thanks for the recipe!
I made these, along with your ‘dead simple slaw’, yesterday for our 4th of July dinner and they were spectacular! I was a little nervous, because I had never made my own buns before, but it was actually quite simple. And not having any bread flour on hand, I used all all-purpose and they still turned out great, not tough at all. No more store-bought buns for us!
I woke up yesterday and checked your blog- and I’m so glad I did. Saw this recipe and had enough time to make the buns for our 4th party last night. They turned out well- although I would’ve divided them up into 12. I got many compliments on the buns, so thank you!
Wow. These stand up really well to a juicy, drippy, burger. I was worried that they’d be too crusty, like little hard shells–especially after I made 16 slider-sized buns–but they were fantastic. Cheeseburgers (with guacamole) from the oven have never tasted better. These are not the inedible hockey pucks of meat on crummy bread I ate growing up.
Hi!I’m an italian girl my boyfriend loves burgers so I thought that the healthyest way of eating then was to prepare the myself!Your recipe is very good and i will use it!!!Thanks!!!
I tried to adapt these into hot dog buns. They turned out really ugly, but tasted fantastic. The dough spread out too much. I probably just let it rise too long.
I did all the kneading in my Kitchen-aid and it was much easier than messing with sticky dough on the counter.
Oh, good, I’m glad you tried them. I’ve been looking for a bun worthy of several other recipes I wanted to try. I pulled the Food section this week specifically to try that recipe, but it’s always nice when someone else does first…and posts pictures.
Thanks for doing all the research for us. I tried making hamburger buns once but gave up after they didn’t work out. I’ll have to print this recipe and try it out after all the rave reviews.
I made this today…just my hubby and myself, and it was well worth it. Delicious. Don’t know how I will ever eat a packaged bun again. I’m looking forward to spliting and toasting one in the morning! Thanks, it made for a stupendous burger!
try these with the coffee rubbed cheeseburgers from Bon Appetit and you will not be disappointed.
Oh my! These look amazing, I can’t wait to give them a try!
Sarah, I too, tried to shape them for Brats and they were too big and flat, but like you said, they were good.
I made them in the bread machine where you don’t have to prep the yeast and I would say a success.
Thanks, Deb!
I am blown away by how light, flaky, and positively delicious these look :) great job! (an understatement)
I have been searching for the perfect burger bun for years, so will definitely be giving this a try. But why no weights????
mmmm! I have just sent this to my good friend who was blathering on about brioche for ages on saturday, naming any meal it can be used with…so this will delight him! and i will have to make them – yum and thanks!
I have been on a similar quest. I read your post last night. The flour is already in a bowl and I am about to mix. How excited am I? YAH!
Seriously the best looking buns I’ve ever seen! Yum!
lovely receipt!
Oh my goodness…the one with the little bubble toward the top is calling to me. It really does look like these are “it”. Awesome.
These look really delicious. I just got a stand mixer from my friends last month, and I can’t beleive that I haven’t made a yeast bread yet. This might not need to be done in a stand mixer, but as soon as I can clear off my counters these will be mine!
The look great! I can only imagine how fantastic they taste:)
Hi Deb.
your recipe looks a lot like mine. I like milk and butter in my rolls cuz they make bread soft and flavorful. Mine used all milk instead of water+milk. We made them 1.25 inches in diameter for little appetizer lamb burger sliders. I highly recommend doing these next time you have an event. buns, garlic aioli/mayo, thin slice of roasted beet, olive tapenade, 2 or 3 arugula leaves. pretty! and the guys love it.
I recently did an interview with a chef for my site and he used the Barefoot Cantessa brioche bun recipe for his to die for pulled pork sandwiches… but I just had a baby, I had to turn to the store. However, I did do the 9 hour smoked shoulder and felt victorious!
This is similar to a recipe I have for my bread machine that turns out fine buns. Although I should probably invest in the bread flour – been too lazy to buy it. Will try – thanks for sharing! I love your blog.
Love you! on a bad day I read you recipes and always, always get a good laugh and a great recipe! Keep up the good work! Light brioche burger buns….permenant eats at the homefront now. (always make me look good at the holidays or a picnic)
Wow those look great! Your blog is amazing. Your photos are just top notch, and such a great variety of recipes! You are an inspiration to other food bloggers like me. Keep it up!
Mazel tov upon this yummy milestone! :)
Made them yesterday with Vietnamese pork burgers and they came out beautifully. Thanks for this recipe – it goes in the permanent file!
Will try some whole wheat flour next time – should I sub some for the AP flour or for some of the bread flour?
Ah! Not that I wouldn’t be reading every day anyway, but I have been diligently checking every day since the “Incident” for your perfect burger bun recipe. Thank you, thank you!!
I needed to make these for my La Bella Burger (Italian) I made on the 4th… also made an Irish Burger and a Japanese Burger. Next step is to make buns for each of them. Thanks for the recipe!
I was just saying the other day how much I would love to make the perfect hamburger bun…then I found your blog. I’m so grateful to you for your efforts and good taste.
Can you substitute instant yeast here? How much? Or do you find it’s best to keep two types of yeast – instant and active dry in your pantry?
I have been waiting for this! Will try soon… thanks!
I made these today, and they turned out fantastic. I had made my favorite curried chicken salad this morning and it was divine served on these! I’m thinking of a hundred excuses to make some more in the very near future.
You should defintely do more self kneading bread recipies!
breads so fun to make and you feel so accoplished when it comes out tasting great, and the best part is you can say you made it yourself without a bread machine!
OH MY WORD!!!! These buns were AWESOME!!! Thank you so much for the recipe! We absolutely loved them and they were super easy to make!! The next morning my 4 yr old son asked for one for breakfast! I will definitely make them again and might even make them on vacation next week (though everyone thinks I’m nuts for making homemade bread while on vacation!) they were so good!
I made these buns a couple nights ago – absolutely fantastic. They were delicious with burgers and on their own. They are so easy to make that I don’t understand why anyone would ever buy that wonder bread crap after trying these!
i can already taste the meaty juices running into the bun.. i’ve gotta try this, thanks!
they really are perfect. and very easy.
made these tonight for burger night (happens at our house on most fridays) and holy-bleepity-bleep I’m so happy. once again, THANK YOU for the glorious recipe. it WILL be hard to buy the store-bought version from here on out. love that this recipe is super easy too–especially for a nervous bread maker like myself.
eh, skip the bread making….use a baguette, make a misformed shape burger to fit, add Dijon mustard and Roquefort/Bleu cheese ….happy Bastille Day!
Made these this afternoon and they are wonderful. My son ate a whole one plain. Honey is cleaning the kitchen as a thank you. I also cheated and put it in my bread machine on dough cycle while I did other things. Next time I’ll get my son to do the work, on a double batch. And yes it took under an hour for the buns to rise-beautifully.
echoing you and everyone else — why on earth would we buy the store-made nonsense when these are so simple and delicious? thanks for such a great recipe, along with those for light wheat bread, mediterranean pepper salad, and black bean confetti salad, all of which i’ve made in the last two weeks and can’t get enough of. :)
I’ve just made these, I forgot to add the butter and they’re still AMAZING.
First time poster here, congrats on the baby, I read you religiously ;) When my boyfriend notices I’m reading this site he always goes “Mmmmm great! What’s for dinner?!” hehehe
Regards from Spain!
Just baked my second batch of these fabulous buns. After reading about the stickiness, I did mine in the bread machine through the first rise. I have the full size Zojirushi breadmaker. Put salt and flours in with softened butter and crumbed by hand. Then the yeast mixture. Kneaded for 9 minutes in the machine, then let it rise. No stick, no mess. Then I made into rolls, let rise again and baked. Deliciousness!! Thanks for passing this recipe along.
I made Jim Lahey’s no-knead bread the other day with self-rising flour instead of the bread flour that I normally used, it came out pretty well, could I do the same with these guys?
I tried the self-rising, it worked well for sammies, but fell apart under the turkey burger, maybe that will be where the gluten from the bread flour comes in. Next time… They are delicious though, thanks for sharing, I never thought that it would be possible for me to make bread!
Yeast and self-rising flour are wildly different ingredients. Yeast is a living plant microorganism; self-rising flour has a chemical leavener, baking powder, in it which is a quick-rise element for cakes and cookies. I don’t know how self-rising flour managed to make bread rise, unless you used the yeast as well, in which case the baking powder 24+ hours later probably had no effect left in it and it was only the yeast doing the work. It is not the right flour to make bread.
Stumbled upon your website and have to say how excited I am to find another Foodie who really puts a lot of time and effort into cooking and discovering the best recipe and truly having fun doing it. Tried your Brioche buns out and had to tell you what a huge hit they were in my family – you made me look good. Can’t wait to make them again – and of course eat them.
Looking forward to trying a lot more of your ideas/recipes out. Thanks!
Made these today. Oh my goodness….you are simply amazing!
Thank you so much for the inspiration. I love that I made hamburger buns!
These are amazing! I replaced the half cup of AP flour with whole wheat, might go for a whole cup next time. Also, they are big…My next batch I will shape into 12 rolls instead of 8. The dough was wet and a bit tricky to work with. I kneaded them in the KA. Mine rose fast too – an hour for the first rise, and less than that for the second.
I made these buns for the fourth of July and forgot to comment here!! They were so good! I made burger and hot dog buns with them, and my guests didn’t say “Oh, what a great burger!”; instead, they said, “Wow! the bread tastes amazing!” It was soo good that you forgot all about the innards of the burger and the hot dogs haha. This recipe is definitely a keeper.
Thanks so much Deb. I made these today, on a crazy baking tear at 8 a.m. this morning, and they are FABULOUS. We’re making hamburgers this afternoon on our new grill — the first burgers I’ve had since we moved to Mexico six months ago. Suffice to say, a burger on this bun will be the best damn American hamburger ever.
OK Deb,
I made these last night- went real easy on any extra flour and had great rising deliciousdough BUT they were like pancakes expanding out not up! What did I do wrong? how to fix it? the only other thing I can say is I only had about 2 1/3 cup bread flour so a bit of extra plain flour to compensate.. would this make them so floppy though?
I made them again, and made 10 not 8, it was just the right amount for us! I would like to try these for another party but will be short on time. Do you think I’m better off if I make the dough the night before, to do the first rise in the fridge, or shape them the night before and do the second rise in the fridge?
I just pulled out my batch of these buns, and they are fantastic! I can’t believe how light and soft they are. And so easy! Thanks Deb for another great recipe :)
These are truly amazing. I’ve been baking bread for 20+ years and these are some of the best rolls I’ve ever made. My hubby actually said these will take the place of his homemade cinnamon roll requests. My KIDS even love them. I mix mine in the Kitchenaid so it’s easy to knead w/o adding any more flour. To shape I sprinkle a small handfull of flour over the top and grab balls out of the dough, rolling in theh flour. So insanely good. We use them for pulled pork sandwiches, hamburgers, turkey sandwiches, breakfast sandwiches…you name it. Yum.
Did the first rise overnight in the fridge and they came out great!
I had never made bread before or even baked much at all, but I braved it and made these and they were so good I couldn’t believe that I had made them! Try them toasted with butter and honey mmm :)
I don’t know what I’m waiting for!!! I must make these!
I made these this weekend. And oooh, Smitten Kitchen, I am so grateful for you. :) But I suffered from a stupidhood: I turned the oven on to 200 degrees to get it warm so the buns would rise the second time… and then I forgot to turn it off. TRAGIC. So even though they’re not as fluffy as they would’ve been, they’re still delicious and I can’t wait to make them again (you know, the right way).
Seriously, reading/viewing your cooking experiences has led me to make all kinds of foods that I would never have bothered trying before. I LOVE cooking, and this site has made me love it even more. So thank you!
I’ve been on the same quest- making my own burger/hot dog/sausage buns- and many recipes/methods have been disappointing. But this recipe came out of the oven about 20 minutes ago and they are beautiful- I’m sold. My daughter and I already ate one with butter an honey b/c they smelled way too good to wait for the sloppy joes we’re eating for dinner. I love being able to make breads that I would other wise have to buy; its the control really but also it just tastes better. Your description- the picking up and slapping it down- really helped. Also your pie crust directions- pie crust has been my nemesis for years- and I feel like I can bake- but no longer! Thanks!
Thanks so much for this recipe! I ordered some Wagyu beef burgers for my brother’s birthday, and decided to make these. (Of course I bought a back-up bag of Sara Lee buns in case I screwed it up! LOL) They turned out BEAUTIFULLY! Your recipe is great, especially the emphasis on leaving the dough a little tacky. They elevated the already great burgers to a new level. This is a definitely a new standard recipe for me. Thanks again for this excellent recipe.
What am I doing wrong? I followed the recipe to the letter and have crumbs, not dough!
Maggie — You’ll have to give me more information about what happened, if you’d like feedback.
Oh, Deb! I have literally drooled over these since you posted and finally got around to making them this week. I sprinkled Eden Shake all over them (two kinds of sesame seed, nori chunks, and sea salt).
Made a luxury vehicle for the best sandwich fillings I could possibly muster.
Thank you!!!
VERY sticky. So very sticky that I figured out what I did wrong- bummer. I put both eggs in at the beginning, I didn’t see that you save 1 for brushing on top. See what happens when you try to bake with two little peanuts racing around under your feet! They are on their final rise, cross your fingers for me.
Stupid question, but where does one place the pan of water on the oven floor – on top of the element? My oven has heating coils on the bottom, held up by little legs to elevate it from the floor. Do I put the pan underneat the legs? It’s such a silly question but I’m totally stumped!?
Introducing steam in the first few minutes of baking bread is a classic technique to help bread crust formation. If you can’t put it on the oven floor, just put it on a low rack. You can also skip the step, but as I said, it does make for nicer bread.
Thanks Deb! I’m doing my second rise right now!
Made these last night for burgers and they are fantastic! I did make them with 1/2 whole wheat bread flour and they turned out delicious. Thanks Deb for this great recipe!
There’s just two of us so I would like to make a batch and freeze what we don’t eat. (We don’t eat burgers too often). Question: Do I freeze the dough, thaw, then bake as usual or do I bake as usual, thaw, and then warm in the oven before serving? I have frozen pizzza and bread dough before, but they didn’t contain milk or eggs so I’m wondering how this dough will hold up.
Excellent post! I made these over the weekend, and posted about them on my site, A Bread A Day [dot] com. Really, really fantastic bread.
Breanne — You can freeze a bread dough at any point in the process. You simply need to let it fully defrost and get back to room temperature and pick up the recipe where you left off.
Deb -
Not enough moisture, very dry dough. Added another 1/2 water and 2 eggs to get a moister dough. OK, but not the raving results or other commenters.
Made this using only all purpose flour, and I thought they turned out great!!! Great texture, perfect! Next try I used half, or was it a third? whole wheat flour, and they were denser, didn’t like them as much.
Hmmm…I think I’ll try these next week..shape them in oblongs and serve them with your lobster salad!
instead of rolls, i made this in a rustic loaf shape. took about 6 more minutes to bake; turned out just as delicious.
I’ve made this recipe three times now with stellar results each time. I have found that rising them in the refrigerator overnight up to 24 hours yields the best, easiest results–I can mix the dough up the night before and the next day cook them up and look like a star. The recipe is also great for hot dog buns, by the way.
These were exactly what i have been searching for, and was about to give up. This is the best bun recipe I have ever made. All others pale in comparison. These were nice and soft, not dense. I made 6 instead of eight and they were perfect for big burgers. I have been tuning in here for a while and have tried several other recipes. I havent been dissapointed yet. Keep up the good work :)
Just tried this recipe for buns for my beer brats, they turned out perfect despite me not having any parchment paper, only having all-purpose flour, and not having a dough scraper. Thanks for the recipe!
Hi Deb,
I tried these today to have with some turkey burgers and they were fantastic (like everything else I have made of yours!). I should be posting the buns on Saturday so feel free to stop by. :D
I can’t even remember how I found your site but I bookmarked this page because I can’t find any hamburger buns on the market without High Fructose Corn Syrup. So I’ve been eating hamburgers without the buns for over a year. I finally got up the courage to work with yeast, it’s never been successful in the past. But this time…everything worked out perfect. My husband nearly choked on his own spit when he asked where I was going with the digital camera and I told him, “to take a picture of my buns”…hamburger buns of course. Thanks for the recipe. I’m making another batch today.
Mine came out perfect, the dough was so wet they seemed to spread outwards rather than rise upwards. They are the perfect golden and rustic looking buns ever. Toasted they were crisp, yet fluffy. But they were a bit off in taste – I found them FAR too sweet. I’m a bit nervous about touching sugar quantities in a bread recipe, so I probably wouldn’t make these again. Such a shame – other than being too sweet, they were perfect!
Becks — There’s no reason you cannot dial back the sugar. It is not like a cookie or cake, where it could adversely affect the structure.
This is IT. Delish. I was so proud of them I was worried whatever I cooked up to put on them wouldn’t live up to the buns.
I make all breads with my stand mixer. For now I can’t imagine kneading by hand. It allows me to keep the dough wetter than I would like if it was sticking all over my fingers and counter. And this is working well for me for now. I have been telling all my friends, if you have a stand mixer there is no need to be scared of yeast. Baking a good cake seems just as challenging…and then you need to decorate it.
I made these today, and they were awesome! One problem I did have is they stuck to the parchment paper after I baked them. I used honey instead of sugar because we were out. Could that be the problem? They tasted great though!
Hi Anna — I wouldn’t think it’s the honey. Actually, I’ve never heard of things sticking to parchment — you don’t perhaps have the Whole Foods brand of “natural” parchment, do you? It is my nemesis, as it is parchment-like but without the high-heat nonstick properties of real parchment paper. (Can you tell it has burned me before?)
::light bulb:: I bet it IS my parchment paper! It’s not the Whole Foods brand though. It’s pre-cut sheets of sandwich wrapping paper. I thought it would work the same, but apparently I was wrong. I’ll be sure to steer clear of the Whole foods brand as well! Thanks =)
dear deb,
first of all, thank you. i have been inspired by your words and fulfilled as i make your recipes. again, thank you.
secondly, i made these buns for dinner this evening and they turned out beautifully. the only think i did differently was i baked the buns on my baking stone. delicious!
sincerely,
jani
Respectfully,
This recipe is simply a common white bread recipe, nothing special about the recipe.
The word Brioche in the title is a misnomer.
Brioche is characterized by a high butter content, the brioche lite recipes containing 20 percent butter, with the rich brioches going up to 100 percent at the highest.
This recipe contains 7.5 percent butter. Most enriched white bread recipes call for the same amount of butter. No one ever considered them to be a brioche.
Lightness and soft texture texture in a hamburger bun is more about technique, proofing method and the brand of flour being used.
The best bun I ever ate was made with common grocery store RobinHood bleached and bromated AP flour, the worst was made with King Arthur unbleached unbromated bread flour.
Thank you! See I know if you have posted a recipe then it is trustworthy. I am still learning to cook, and even more learning to bake. But I am making pulled pork sandwiches for the Lost Premiere and thought how cool would it be if I could successfully make the buns to go with it. I am currently eating one all on its own and am now thinking that’s how they all should be eaten. No butter, no nothing. So even if it is a common white bread recipe with nothing special about it… Its fantastic. My only problem tonight will be convincing people to eat the pulled pork with the bread!
I planned on making burgers today and decided to skip the store bought buns and make them myself. I remembered seeing this recipe and decided to try it out. It was one of the easiest breads I’ve made so far and I feel well worth the effort. The buns came out light and beautiful. I cannot wait for my delicious burger later!
Blogs like yours make cooking for people like me so much easier. :) You searched out the best recipe with your time and effort and I believe you’ve found a winner!