Recipes

focaccia sandwiches for a crowd

Last year, Alexandra Stafford published a very good book about bread. It sprang from a recipe for the peasant bread her mother made often when she was growing up. When she shared it on her site, it went viral, which is no surprise given that it’s no-knead, comes together in under five minutes, rises in about an hour, and after a brief second rise, you bake it in buttered bowls that form it into a blond, buttery crusted bread that she boasts is “the antithesis of artisan.” Because there are no hidden tricks; no steam ovens, special flours, lames to score the crust, or bannetons to shape the loaves. Her central tenet is that “good bread can be made without a starter, without a slow or cold fermentation, without an understanding of bakers’ percentages, without being fluent in the baking vernacular: hydration, fermentation, biga, poolish, soaker, autolyse, barm.” (None of those words appear in the book.) She knows that there are a lot of no-knead breads out there, but this is the only one that can be started at 4pm and be on the dinner table at 7.


what you'll needwhisk flour, salt, and yeastadd waterlet it proof for an hour

I realize you’re thinking, as I briefly worried before I read it, how does one write an entire cookbook based on one recipe? But Stafford is a gifted recipe developer, and there isn’t a thing in this book — one part breads (with all types of flours, grains, and shapes, including pizzas, flatbreads, rolls and buns), one part toasts (including sandwiches, tartines, stratas, panzanellas, soups, summer puddings and so much more), and one part crumbs (a celebration of crunchy gratin toppings, stuffing, burgers, eggplant parmesan, fish sticks, meatballs, and brown bettys) — that I didn’t want to make. (I suspect that having four kids to feed ensures that these recipes were vetted by the most finicky of reviewer classes.) It’s also a gorgeous book, with a focus and format that my inner, long-surrendered organized person finds deeply pleasing.

deflate with forksdrop it onto oiled sheetstretch and dimple with your fingertipssplit the focaccia

My favorite thing in the book, and the one that I come back to again and again, is using the core bread recipe to make a focaccia that can be split and filled to make a sheet pan’s worth of sandwiches.* File this under things I never thought about pre-kids but obsess over now: Picking up sandwiches to go to the beach/park/pool/wherever your summer weekend takes you for a family or group of friends can be staggeringly expensive. I might even forgive the price if the sandwiches were usually better, but I’m sorry-not-sorry, they’re usually not. Either the bread is lousy and processed to the hilt, or they just don’t make them the way I want them, which is heavy on the vegetables and with a good mix of fresh, salty, crunchy, and pickle-like ingredients. Let’s fix this.

assembly timehummus-pickled carrot-cucumber and avocado-crispy kale

Below is the recipe for the simplest, quickest focaccia you’ll ever need to make and several sandwich filling suggestions (many vegan, too) I hope you’ll find good jumping off points.

focaccia sandwiches for a crowd

* If you have Smitten Kitchen Every Day at home (do you? I bet you’d love it, I’m just saying) you probably already know about my slab-sized sandwich fixation. In the book, I use roasted tomatoes and more to stuff a focaccia *before* it is baked, inspired by a foccia ripiena we ate in Rome several years ago. This is concept is similar, but there’s no need to pre-commit to fillings.

Previously

One year ago: Blackberry Blueberry Crumb Pie
Two years ago: Summer Squash Pizza and Peach Melba Popsicles
Three years ago: Raspberry Crushed Ice
Four years ago: Three-Ingredient Summertime Salsa and Blueberry Crumb Cake
Five years ago: Charred Corn Crepes and Burst Tomato Galette with Corn and Zucchini
Six years ago: Pink Lemonade Bars
Seven years ago: Tomato Salad with Crushed Croutons
Eight years ago: Nectarine Brown Butter Buckle and Sweet and Smoky Oven Spare Ribs
Nine years ago: Best Birthday Cake, Arugula Potato and Green Bean Salad and Peach and Creme Fraiche Pie
Ten years ago: Garlic Mustard Glazed Skewers and Huevos Rancheros
Eleven years ago: Quick Zucchini Saute

And for the other side of the world:
Six Months Ago: Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies and Slow-Roasted Sweet Potatoes
1.5 Years Ago: Broccoli Pizza
2.5 Years Ago: Spaghetti Pie with Pecorino and Black Pepper, Banana Puddings with Vanilla Bean Wafers, and Taco Torte
3.5 Years Ago: Caramelized Onion and Gruyere Biscuits and Charred Cauliflower Quesadillas
4.5 Years Ago: Garlicky Party Bread with Cheese and Herbs and Fennel and Blood Orange Salad

Focaccia Sandwiches for a Crowd

Servings will vary by how you cut the focaccia, of course. Here I show 12 small/medium sandwiches. Depending on how hearty your fillings are, each person may eat 1 to 2 sandwiches.

You can choose your own schedule with this bread, by proving it for 1 to 1 1/2 hours at room temperature, overnight in fridge, or 10 hours at room temperature. For the last option, you want to make the bread with cold tap water.

To use active dry yeast instead of instant yeast, add it directly to the lukewarm water with a pinch of sugar to proof it for 10 minutes (it will get foamy) and then add it below where you will the water.

For more of a traditional focaccia flavor, you can sprinkle 1 tablespoon chopped or minced fresh rosemary over the top with the salt before baking it.

  • 4 cups (520 grams) all-purpose flour
  • 2 teaspoons kosher salt
  • 1 teaspoon instant yeast
  • 2 cups lukewarm water, made by mixing 1/2 cup boiling water with 1 1/2 cups cold water
  • 4 tablespoons olive oil
  • Flaky sea salt

    In a large bowl, whisk together the flour, salt, and instant yeast. Add the water. Using a rubber spatula, mix until the water is absorbed and the ingredients form a loose, sticky dough. Cover with a tea towel or plastic wrap and [choose your schedule]:
  • Quickest rise: Set aside in a warmish spot for 1 to 1 1/2 hours, until doubled.
  • Overnight in fridge: Set inside your refrigerator overnight, about 8 to 10 hours.
  • Overnight at room temperature: For this method, you will need to use only cold, no lukewarm, water. Leave the bowl on your counter at room temperature for 10 hours.
  • When you’re ready to make your focaccia: Pour 3 tablespoons oil onto a rimmed sheet pan (can use a 13×18, or half-sheet pan, but if you have something more 11×17-ish, as I use here, will make for slightly thicker loaf; you can line it first with parchment paper for maximum nonstick security).

    Heat oven to 425°F.

    Using two forks, deflate the dough by releasing it from the sides of the bowl and pulling it toward the center. Rotate the bowl in quarter turns as you deflate, turning the mass into a rough ball. Use the forks to lift the dough onto the prepared sheet pan. Roll the dough ball in the oil to coat it all over.

    Let dough rest for 20 minutes (for Quickest rise or Overnight at room temperature) or 1 hour (if you used the Overnight in the fridge rise, so it warms up) without touching it. Then, drizzle last 1 tablespoon of olive oil over and use your fingertips to stretch and press the dough to the edges, leaving it intentionally dimply. If your dough resists being stretched all the way, get it as stretched as you can, wait 5 minutes, and return to stretch it the rest of the way, repeating this rest if needed.

    Sprinkle with flaky sea salt all over and bake for 20 to 25 minutes, checking in on the earlier end, until lightly puffed on top and golden and crisp underneath. Remove from oven and let cool completely (this will go faster if you transfer the bread to a cooling rack) before assembling sandwiches.

    To make sandwiches: If you’d like, you can trim off the very outer edges — this exposes the crumb and makes it a little easier to halve. (I didn’t do this because I like to make things hard, also I like edges.) Stafford recommends you begin the halving process by cutting through each corner, then running the serrated knife through the short end until you get to the midway point, then starting from the other short end until I get to the midway point. A sharp, serrated knife is helpful. Try to keep your knife as parallel to the bread as possible. She says she finds if she hugs the top layer as opposed to aiming for the center, she gets a more even cut.

    Some ideas for sandwich fillings:

  • Avocado + Crispy Kale [Shown]: First, crisp your kale. I used a 5-ounce clamshell of curly kale leaves, tearing out and discarding any thick ribs. Rub/toss them with 1 tablespoon olive oil, spread them on a large baking sheet in one layer, seasoned them with salt and pepper, and baked them at 375&#176F for 10 to 15 minutes, until crispy and just barely brown at the edges (keep an eye on it). Then, scoop out and slice 4 avocados, fan the slices across the bread and mash/spread them smooth. Coat with olive oil, lemon juice, flaky salt, and red pepper flakes (like we do here). Spread crispy kale over avocado.
  • Hummus + Cucumber + Pickled Carrots [Shown]: First, coarsely grate 1 pound of carrots. Pour 1/2 cup apple cider vinegar, 1/2 cup cold water, 1 teaspoon kosher salt, and 1 to 2 teaspoons (to taste) of granulated sugar over it and stir to combine. (You could also add mustard or dill seeds or fresh chile peppers here.) Chill in the fridge for as long as you have — 30 minutes, an hour, and up to a few days. Carrots will get more pickled the longer it soaks. To make your sandwiches, schmear the bottom half of the bread with about 1 1/2 cups hummus (storebought or homemade). Squeeze out little handfuls of pickled carrot and sprinkle this on as your next layer. For you final layer, use a y-peeler to shave long ribbons off 1 large (1/2 to 3/4 pound) seedless cucumber. Tousel these on top; season them with salt and pepper.
  • Walnut pesto + grilled zucchini ribbons (skip the parmesan in the pesto to make it vegan)
  • This grilled pepper and torn mozzarella panzanella, minus the croutons
  • This crunchy asparagus and egg salad
  • Pickled vegetable sandwich slaw + anything else you love on sandwiches
  • This salsa verde + any grilled or roasted vegetables
  • This zucchini carpaccio salad, as a sandwich filling
  • Any of the sandwiches from the archives
  • Many of the salads from the archives, such as this egg salad, this chicken salad (not vegetarian, of course), that chicken salad, or even (I love this as a sandwich) this chicken caesar, with the dressing spread on both sides of the bread, the chicken thinly sliced, and the romaine cut into thin ribbons. I wouldn’t be sad to have a broccoli or cauliflower slaw between bread, either.
  • Or, of course, endless slices of peak-season tomatoes + mayo + salt, or the same plus sliced mozzarella + basil pesto

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New here? You might want to check out the comment guidelines before chiming in.

106 comments on focaccia sandwiches for a crowd

  1. SallyT

    I’m SO EXCITED by this b/c I just love BTC, and Alexandra as well. I highly recommend using 1/2 AP flour and 1/2 bread flour. She has a foccacia on her website that uses 00 flour, and I loved that too.

    (note: In the head note, I think that you meant “proofing it” rather than “proving it”!

        1. I always do it baked as you can cut it into more manageable slices or 1/4. A whole full sheet pan is a lot of bread. Great for a party but a little much for my breakfast!

    1. Focaccia is definitely best fresh day of but I make it a lot (the recipe from Saltie’s cookbook but I will be trying this one ; )) ) and frozen wrapped tightly in foil it is wonderful if you reheat nicely in the oven or toasted it is perfect. I love a herbed focaccia with jam on it…so delicious.

  2. Emily

    I have an oven that doesn’t go above 350F, and it always makes me hesitate to try bread recipes. Any ideas on what would happen if I bake this at 350? Should I just bake it longer?

    1. Candice

      I bake an extremely similar recipe at 350 as Sicilian pizza and it works fine. I even do the same stretching method with olive oil, funny enough. It should brown for you too.

      Also! Sandwich breads usually bake at 350, if you are feeling brave.

      1. Sara

        My non-pro go-to tip for these are elastic bowl covers from the grocery store. Yes they are plastic but I’ve re-used mine for years and they are awesome for bread. I use them over the bowl *and* over the rising loaves as they will slip over a loaf pan or banneton, keep the dough nice and moist, and still allow room for expansion. I even found a large sized one that fits over an entire small sheet pan for things like focaccia and rolls. Not as cute are yours but super handy!

        1. Deanna

          I use hotel shower caps I’ve taken to cover bowls while proofing. They last for ages, and I travel enough to easily replace them as needed.

            1. Mimi

              I would guess, as long as it doesn’t touch the food, it’s okay. Probably not worse than all the plastic-wrapped stuff we sometimes buy…
              The sandwich fillimgs sound delicious! Must pickle carrots at once :-D

    1. Kim

      My friend made me beeswax food wraps, and I find they are perfect for this. They are expensive commercially, but if you’re so inclined, are very easily made. Just google.

    2. Check out a brand called earth bunny on Amazon. Really cute, cotton, stripy elastic bowl covers. I have no affiliation but I believe this is what you are looking for! Good luck

    3. Kathy

      The bowl covers are edged with elastic. Alexandra provides the source on her website (AlexandraCooks.com), along with the bread recipe, which is fantastic!

  3. Meleyna

    Yes! I figured this out a while back, but my go-to focaccia recipe… is not a quick one. I end up reaching for Acme’s herb slab (which is not a bad option), but I am excited to have a quick bread that is actually a bread and not cake option.

    1. Nirinjan

      I’m not Deb and I don’t play her on TV but I live/cook/bake at 7000 feet here in Santa Fe. I haven’t found yeasted doughs to need that much adjusting for my altitude but often they will rise faster than specified in the recipe. To counteract this, I will sometimes decrease the amount of yeast by about 1/3rd or let the dough rise once, punch it down and then go for a second rise. Sometimes cooking times are shorter too so keep an eye on things toward the end of the specified cooking time. Cakes/quick breads/and especially brownies need a bit more adjusting.

    2. Kelsey

      I agree with Nirinjan – I used to live at 5,000ft, and for yeasted breads I would usually decrease the yeast a bit, and do an additional rise. That will give the gluten enough time to actually develop so you don’t end up with crumby (literally) bread.

  4. Kawa

    “by proving it for 1 to 1 1/2 hours at room temperature, overnight in fridge, or 10 hours at room temperature. ” One of those “room temperature”s is probably not meant to be so…

    But wow! I’m excited to see this and hope to try it soon.

  5. Charlotte

    Longtime reader, rare commentor, but I just have to say that I am SO EXCITED to make this! I am also in the “young kid” part of my life, and find myself steering toward kid-friendly recipes. Ones that include vegetables AND quick, homemade bread? Sign. Me. Up.

  6. Jessica

    Any idea the temperature of your “lukewarm” water? I’d love to just set my electric kettle to that temperature for all of the water, as it would be less fussy. :-) Thanks!

    1. SallyT

      It should be about 110 degrees .I like Alexandra’s recommendation of 1/2 cup boiling water with 1 1/2 cups of room temperature water. If you’re using instant yeast, it won’t really matter though.

      1. deb

        110 degree water is necessary for activating active dry yeast, not strictly necessary here for instant yeast, however, I, too, find that instant yeast gets moving faster when lukewarm water is used.

  7. Heck yes! You have perfect timing! I’m hosting a bridal shower next month and was thinking about serving something homemade, but not too intensive, because I will be very pregnant. I hadn’t even started looking up recipes, but this, cut into smaller portions, will be perfect! Thank you :)

  8. Rebecca

    Hi Deb,
    I used Alexandra’s focaccia recipe and the frittata for a crowd recipe from your most recent book for a teacher appreciation lunch this year and felt like a hero! Both in 9×11 pans, you can cut the bread, place the sheet of frittata in the middle, and cut into the most lovely, tidy squares. It feeds 24 with sides or 12 on its own. Thanks for making me look so good!

  9. Rosa

    Looks amazing! I have a weird kid who doesn’t like cheese or lunch meats so even though we aren’t vegan it’s refreshing to see a vegan sandwich presented as a kid-friendly option

  10. Wendy

    I have made Alexandra’s bread recipes (including this focaccia) many times. I use her hack for creating the “warmish spot”–preheat the oven at 350 for 1 full minute. Turn off the heat. Put the covered bowl of dough in warm oven and check after 1.5 hours. Turns out great every time. Looking forward to trying your combinations!

  11. Robin

    I just previewed Alexandra’s book on Amazon and noticed that most of her recipes use 2 teaspoons of sugar. She also notes possible variations that omit the sweetener. Do you ever reduce the sugar, and if so, what are your results? I notice you only use a pinch for this recipe.

  12. Jeanne

    Yum, always looking for this kind of crowd stuff!
    Former deli worker hint: cut the top and bottom parts of the sandwich separately, to avoid filling squishing out. It’s true, the top and bottom may not match up PERFECTLY when you put the individual top back on the bottom, but close enough. Worth it for cleaner edges. 😉

  13. Layne

    I made this with a rosemary, garlic and salt top last night. Delicious, oh so simply and pairs with SO MUCH. I made them into fried egg sandwiches that we dipped in marinara. Delicious.

  14. Carla

    This is amazing bread..cooked in the little bowls, which I found for 10 cents each at Goodwill…or as focaccia or any other variation!!!! I actually own Bread Toast Crumbs…as well as both of your cookbooks. I’m totally enjoying cooking my way through all three…not one dud in the bunch.
    BTW, those trimmed edges make fabulous croutons…..if you don’t eat them as the chef’s treat first!!

  15. Patty

    I love this bread idea! I have her book but have not tried this yet. I love her book! Oh…I have your book, too! And I love it, too!

  16. tigerlille

    I have been contemplating Alexandra Stafford’s mother’s peasant bread recipe for awhile, and here is my concern: With such a short raising time, how can any flavor develop? I don’t like bland, no-flavor bread. Any feedback? Thanks.

  17. Sarah

    The love this! I just made it, subbing spelt flour for wheat and it turned out lovely. Or rather, it actually didn’t ‘turn out’ at all as I neglected the layer of baking paper in the base of my usually unproblematic and very well oiled pan. The base was basically welded to the pan so I had to decapitate it to get it out and the pan is now soaking in the sink. Ahem. But apart from that faux pas, it was easy and tasted lovely!

  18. Hatuly

    Side bar question regarding your sandwich filling options. Saw mint leaves as one of the ingredients in the asparagus & egg salad and the salsa verde. Is that true mint or spearmint ? Baked the focaccia, but hungry family ate it before I could stop them. Good reason to bake a second time.

    1. Cary

      I’ve tried to research this a bit, and find they are fairly interchangeable but spearmint is often sold as garden mint and might lean a little more savory than sweet. YMMV

  19. Jessica

    Your list of suggested sandwich fillings reminds me of a series of lists Mark Bittman did in the NY Times a bunch of years ago…

  20. I’m attempting this with whatever flour I could find (new baby = haven’t baked in a while). I’ve used 3.5 C AP, 1 C WW, 0.5C buckwheat. AND my yeast was expired lol. Only by a month but it foamed up ok in warm water and a little sugar. FIngers crossed it turns out fine! Love your recipes and your cookbook. SK is my FAVORITE!!!

  21. Liz

    You lost me at ” no hidden tricks; no steam ovens, special flours, lames to score the crust, or bannetons to shape the loaves. Her central tenet is that “good bread can be made without a starter, without a slow or cold fermentation, without an understanding of bakers’ percentages, without being fluent in the baking vernacular: hydration, fermentation, biga, poolish, soaker, autolyse, barm.” (None of those words appear in the book.) ”

    Can good bread be made without a starter? All depends on your definition of good bread.

    As a sourdough aficionado for taste as well as health … AND as a natural “yeast” aka starter person … go fer it but I like the process, the taste and the benefits of a more natural method.

  22. Susan in GA

    Just made the focaccia with my 15 year old son thinking we’d use it to make his school lunch for the next couple of days. Instead the family pretty much devoured the whole thing while warm and dipped in olive oil and herbs. Scrumptious!

  23. Lizzie

    Oh my!!!! This is amazing!!! So easy, and absolutely delicious! I followed someone’s advice and used half bread flour, half AP…gave it a perfect texture. It is golden and dimply on the outside, and has the perfect chew on the inside. We keep cutting strips off to eat…made it originally to make some pressed sandwiches, but will need to make another batch for that. Tonight it will be an accompaniment to a large dinner salad, along with some wine. Doesn’t get much better than that! (This afternoon my daughter on the opposite coast and I spent some time sending each other pictures of various SK recipes we have made in the past week or two. She introduced me to SK…and meals have never been the same!)

  24. Jessica

    In this recipe you use 1 teaspoon instant yeast, but in the original recipe have from Alexandra’s kitchen, she uses 2 teaspoons. This seems a fairly significant difference, no? I would have thought that doing the quick rise version might require the 2 teaspoons.

  25. Lydia

    Can you substitute sour dough starter for the yeast, as I recently started using sour dough starter for no knead, baguettes and tartin breads. If so, any idea on the adjustment to the recipe?

    Thanks in advance, a devoted fan.

  26. Jessie

    I just pulled this out of the oven – so good for a quick yeast bread. I halved the recipe and ended up baking in an 8 in cast iron and it was perfect! Crispy bottom, fluffy inside, and the right hint of salt.

  27. Diane

    Should this be baked and eaten on the same day? I assume so but I wanted to double check. I’m planning to double or triple the recipe and use to it make little sandwiches for a late afternoon baby shower.

  28. Cheryl

    Deb, I made this tonight using 100g of wholemeal flour cos I didn’t have enough plain. It was absolutely stunning in every way! Thank you x

  29. Wife To An Amazing Cook

    This was a huge hit in our family – we did a make-your-own-sandwich dinner that included the focaccia and all sorts of filling options (cheeses, fresh vegetables, pickled vegetables, pesto, tapenade, hummus, etc.). My little people hadn’t even finished their meal and were asking for it again soon. Win-win as far as I’m concerned! Next time I might let the dough relax in the pan a bit longer as my corners were thinner than the middle (not that anyone noticed or complained – just thinking ahead for next time).

  30. Just out of curiosity… have you come across and tried a focaccia recipe that is gluten free? I would love to try baking these if you know of a gluten free version. If not, I will just try tinkering with different flour blends. Thanks so much!

  31. bent el deera

    i made this yesterday with mix of whole wheat and all purpose 50:50 and bake it in 9×13 pan because I like it more thick
    and I was really really good thanks Deb 🌷🌷🌷

  32. Pickled carrots with hummus? That is such a great idea! I love the hummus + veggies combo but I do get sick of it sometimes after my five millionth hummus sandwich (especially since all the sandwich places around here seem to think vegans only want hummus, and nothing more exciting). Hummus and carrots are one of my favourite combinations but I never thought of pickled carrots. Definitely going to try this combo soon (whether I find the time to bake my own focaccia or buy some good bread from the bakery!).

  33. Marnie

    I’m amazed at how easy this bread was – and it was still tasty the next day! I did find it was too much oil – it pooled in the pan – so I poured some off but then the top didn’t brown as much as I’d hoped — should I have left it?

    Served it with your eggplant caviar dish and obsessively good cucumber salad for a smitten kitchen trio of deliciousness!

  34. Kelly

    This was super super delicious, everything I hoped it would be! Totally in character with every single time I try to make bread, it didn’t quite rise as much as I would have hoped and was a little tough, but was still very tasty and workable to turn into sandwiches. I didn’t have an rosemary, but had some fresh thyme lying around, so tossed that on there and it was great.

    For fillings, I used the crunchy kale and avocado, and did the egg salad with pickled celery. Both were delicious, but I think that I liked the crunchy kale a little bit more.

    This was just so satisfying, one of my favorites I think! Going to keep my battle with yeast as well, one day I will win.

  35. Sally

    I made focaccia once about 10 years ago from a KAF recipe called “blitz bread.” The recipe is very similar to this one and I’m not sure why I never made it again — it was good and simple.

    I started making her bread before the book, which I have, was published. The ingredients and amounts are identical to that in the recipe I’ve been for 10+ years. The difference is in the technique. The one I’ve used to years calls for a few minutes of kneading (5 or less) after the first rise. The technique I use depends on the result I want.

  36. Adriana

    What happens if you plan for the 1-1.5 hour rise but your 3 year old and 8 month old have other plans and it turns into 2 or 3 hours?

    1. deb

      At 2 hours, it’s almost definitely forgiving. At 3, not sure. Give it a poke, if it deflates to something very flat, it might be problematic but it can’t hurt to bake it and find out. Pretty impressed you’re making bread with two littles underfoot, just the same!

  37. janine02

    Love this recipe! I have your book and Bread Toast Crumbs… Make peasant bread 2-3 times a week! Add all kinds of wonderful things and it comes out perfect every time! Focaccia for a crowd is amazing!

  38. Bonny

    Delicious ,but like one other comment, mine was cemented to the pan. I will try it again on parchment. I Sprinkled the top with sesame seeds.

  39. Heather

    This was bread was even better than i hoped! It turned out so well i couldn’t resist baking another the very next day. This time studded with Greek olives. Another winner. Thanks deb!

  40. Jane M

    Welp I’m hosting a crowd in 2 weeks — so I tried the focaccia last night – and WOW WEE it’s terrific. So vegetarian sandwiches along with other foods are on my menu now! I had to give the L.O.’s away to neighbors yesterday just so I wouldn’t eat it all up! I made them happy!