44-clove garlic soup
Reminding myself that complaining about the weather makes for about as interesting conversation as “wow, I thought it was 4:15 but it’s only 3:45,” I decided to roll with it, as well as with The Coolest Anniversary Present Ever from my husband: an eggplant-colored, 7.25 quart oval Cocotte and a soup I’ve had bookmarked since last winter.
Let’s just cut to the chase already: the soup has 44 cloves of garlic in it. 28 are roasted and then peeled, 18 peeled and then simmered, and somehow the outcome is subtle, but not boring. My 11-clove serving was heavenly, and with a glass of wine we fell back into that haze of garlic Ruth Reichl so aptly describes in Comfort Me With Apples after feasting on duck with garlic mosaics, fish wrapped in puffs of garlic pastry, lamb surrounded by garlic puree, arugula salad with garlic-rubbed croutons and poached figs in red wine with garlic meringues at Chez Panisse.
“If everyone ate more garlic, the world would be a happier place,” she says, and if this soup is any indication, I wholeheartedly agree.
44-Clove Garlic Soup with Parmesan Cheese
Adapted from Bon Appetit, February 1999
Serves 4
26 garlic cloves (unpeeled)
2 tablespoons olive oil
2 tablespoons (1/4 stick) butter
2 1/4 cups sliced onions
1 1/2 teaspoons chopped fresh thyme
18 garlic cloves, peeled
3 1/2 cups chicken stock or canned low-salt chicken broth
1/2 cup whipping cream
1/2 cup finely grated Parmesan cheese (about 2 ounces)
4 lemon wedges
Preheat oven to 350°F. Place 26 garlic cloves in small glass baking dish. Add 2 tablespoons olive oil and sprinkle with salt and pepper; toss to coat. Cover baking dish tightly with foil and bake until garlic is golden brown and tender, about 45 minutes. Cool. Squeeze garlic between fingertips to release cloves. Transfer cloves to small bowl.
Melt butter in heavy large saucepan over medium-high heat. Add onions and thyme and cook until onions are translucent, about 6 minutes. Add roasted garlic and 18 raw garlic cloves and cook 3 minutes. Add chicken stock; cover and simmer until garlic is very tender, about 20 minutes. Working in batches, puree soup in blender until smooth. Return soup to saucepan; add cream and bring to simmer. Season with salt and pepper.
Divide grated cheese among 4 bowls and ladle soup over. Squeeze juice of 1 lemon wedge into each bowl and serve.
Do ahead: Can be prepared 1 day ahead. Cover and refrigerate. Rewarm over medium heat, stirring occasionally.











Okay, that’s it. Next time we’re in New York, we’re eating at your place. All kidding aside, I would love to see fall in August. Today was the first day since, oh I don’t know, MAY that it hasn’t been 100+ degrees. I’ll hold on to this lovely recipe until November or so.
Hi,
Just thought I’d let you know I’ll be spotlighting your blog tomorrow for Blog Day 2006. Hopefully quite a few of my readers will come and visit you.
I found your site via your comment on The Wednesday Chef.
This soup sounds perfect for a rainy fall day and your photograhy and writing is wonderful.
So glad Kalyn found you. Your blogs looks fab. and I have to try this soup but like Jennifer, It’s got to be under 100°. November would look good.
I love your site and will be back often. Thanks to Kalyn for recommending you. We have had a warm summer for Denver but it’s been cooler this week so maybe before long I can make the soup.
Jennifer – I’m probably jumping the gun *a little* with this declaration of fall. When it actually arrives, I will mock my current sandal-and-t-shirt-wearing self for thinking that 71 and damp was cold. That said, I hope you get to make the soup soon, just not too soon!
Kalyn, Julie, Tanna and Judy – Welcome and thank you!
Deb – I know just how you feel. And by the way, that cocotte looks drop dead gorgeous. If a piece of kitchen equipment could be called glamorous, that would be it. Hope to see more of it!
I just discovered your site through Kalyn – I love the presentation. I have dropped you in my rss reader and cant wait to read more and see more of those beautiful pictures.
I just discovered your blog (thanks to Sweetnicks) and love it! I’ve added you to my list of links. Happy blogging!
That soup looks like the perfect thing to make while waiting for Ernesto to clear out and give me blue skies again. I love your blog :)
Hey Deb, I can help you install the live comment preview plugin. I have it on both of my blogs.
Just found you (thanks, Sweetnicks!). Love your blog!
I, too, discovered your blog via your comment on Wednesday Chef; the “Foodie Jeopardy” line really made me laugh. Great writing and photos, and that cocotte is a beauty!
Deb, I followed you from ivillage. I too am a newlywed and a little obsessed with food, and reading about food, and talking about food (and perusing recipes online, and thinking about food shopping) . However, I have a 5 month old, and his level of patience does not allow me to spend the time in the kitchen as I would like to. So I will continue to visit your site often. PS– its a little pedestrian, but I feel about my crockpot the way you feel about your Cocotte!
oh, the leaf is lovely! it made me happy from just looking at it. Can I use it as my desktop wallpaper?
Oh my. I’ve never made soup before, but I came across this recipe today and had to try it. I always thought I didn’t really like soup, but turns out I just never had anything so absolutely fantastic. It was fairly simple to make, and nothing short of delicious. I plan on using the leftovers as a sauce on some type of fish tomorrow, if I have the willpower not to eat it before then.
This was a total Thanksgiving hit. Despite the fact that it was a little futsy, I would make it again. Using an immersion blender made life lots easier.
wow what an awesome way to OD on garlic! great blog and great soup!
we made it last Tuesday and OH how yummy it was!!
thanks so much!
A friend and I made this for a family dinner a couple weeks ago and it was a huge hit at our gathering! This is a delicious dish that everyone should definitely try. It would be especially wonderful on a chilly Fall day.
This soup is exquisite. I’ve had the recipe saved in my bookmarks for a month or more but the temperature only recently dropped below 90, so I made it for the first time tonight. I can’t believe how subtle and rich this is. It’s amazing.
YUM – reduced the broth to make the soup super thick. Again, YUM!
This was FABULOUS. We loved it!!!
absolutely fantastic! LOVE IT. we will make it often, especially when we need to fix the sniffles. thank you so much, you’re a genius. ps, love your cocette too;)
would vegetable stock work as a replacement for the chicken stock? do you have any flavoring suggestions for this substitution? :)
Any vegetable stock would work, whatever you would like with garlic.
Actually, we made this for the two of us as we were watching the Super Bowl (I know, it’s not very Super Bowl-y, but we were out of beans). We used Imagine low-sodium vegetarian broth. In this particular recipe, I think low sodium broth is essential because I didn’t add any salt and it was perfect. With a regular broth, I think it would have been too salty. Oh and it was yummy!
First, I envy your cocotte. Second, the soup was incredible. It was smooth and rich. In fact, I’m jonesing for some right now. Lastly, I appreciate how well you write.
I made this last night for my husband and myself and used vegetable broth and half and half instead of chicken broth and whipping cream. It came out wonderfully, and there was enough left over for us to have it for lunch sometime during the work week!
Wow. I am convinced that the cafe I once went to in search of this soup in a little town on the central coast of California actually stole this recipe. I am completely sure.
Thank you for posting this so I can recreate it. I was shocked how much the lemon did for it, shocked. That, and my heavy hand with the salt.
This is such a healthy recipe. Did you know that garlic is one of the best foods to use to help the body ward off bacteria, virus and helps boost the immune system. I think I will put this recipe in with my herbal remedy stuff.
Greetings from sunny Singapore!
The recipe sounds absolutely deleactable! Thanks for sharing…
Just bought a container of garlic cloves at the farmers market to try this over the weekend. Will let you know what I think…
I had to combine two of your recipes into one. http://pseudicide.livejournal.com/917455.html I just couldn’t decide which to make!
Made this the other night and still can’t get over how amazing it was. Thank you so much for this fantastic soup that I know I will be making for years to come. :)
I made this tonight and I kept making little yummy noises the whole time I ate it. Cold begone!
One of my favorite quotes: “It is not really an exaggeration to say that peace and happiness begin, geographically, where garlic is used in cooking.” X. Marcel Boulestin (1878-1943)
I made this soup last night only by recommendation of a friend. I normally would never pause on something like this and I am very pleasantly surprised and loving this soup! I omitted the cheese but the lemon is a must. Thank you for the recipe and though this is my first time visiting this website, it will certainly not be my last. I enjoy the simple layout, directions, and beautiful pictures.
I made this last night as well; I’ve been pining over it since I’ve seen it – garlic was on sale for 25 cents each and I had to try this finally. And boy, was I ever glad…this one’s a keeper! Thanks!
I made this last night and can’t wait to serve it tonight. I’m always amazed at how sweet and mellow garlic becomes when cooked for long periods of time. (Perhaps someone should cook ME for long periods of time?) Thanks, Susan, for the comment about the lemon juice. I might have skipped that step, but will be sure not to now.
I LOVE your blog, everything about it!! I discovered it recently when I was googling for an apple cake recipe. I love the cake…we love it….already baked it twice. Now, the soup…. simply love it!!… and your bundle of joy is sooooooo CUTE and ADORABLE!! Thank you for the recipes!
This soup is so good! I made it yesterday while also making your mini soft pretzels (yum!). I don’t have a blender so I decided to puree the ingredients in my food processor before adding the chicken broth. I ended up with a few small garlicky bits, but overall, the soup was still very smooth. Just thought I’d share in case anyone else had a similar equipment problem!
Made it, love it, soooo easy! Gonna share it with some Hungarian cooking community, if you don’t mind :)
Two thoughts. 1) This recipe’s name needs to be officially changed from 44 clove garlic soup, to 52 clove garlic soup. Two roasted garlic cloves should be used as a garnish on each bowl. 2) Swine flu, be damned! Talk about a great soup to make right as early cold/flu symptoms arise.
Made this soup last night for thanksgiving, LOVE IT!
Thanks.
Lord lord lord, i just made this for dinner for me and a friend and it was honestly the most delicious thing i have made in a long time. So easy and so very tasty, it came out even better than i had hoped, even though i substituted mixed dried herbs for thyme and cheddar for Parmesan. Thank you so much for this recipe!
Just made this for dinner, and we had it with crusty sourdough bread, salad greens, and a good bottle of wine. AMAZING!
I just made this soup and it was delicious! I also added in potatoes and white beans. So tasty! A perfect soup for this horrible weather we have been having.
Wow. This was exactly as described, subtle but not boring. I was surprised that the soup wasn’t MORE garlicky! Overall an excellent meal! Can I suggest a pairing with a grilled gouda sandwich on sourdough?
mmmmmmm this is my faaavorite… i’m a garlic addict. i made this for myself and my mother once… i used a few extra cloves of garlic, of course… and once it was ready, mmm boy! we ate 25 cloves of garlic each, at once. we couldn’t stop. if there had been more, we would have eaten as much more as there was. since then, every time i mention it, she says “not if we’re going to have to go out in public the next day!” because as it turns out, eating 25 cloves of garlic for dinner has some.. interesting (ready: gassy) effects on the body. …but damn is it worth it.
today, i woke up feeling a lot more like death than a few beers last night can explain, knew i was sick, and started formulating a plan: tea, tea, garlic, more tea, kombucha, GARLIC SOUP. (and cake, i must have cake.) sometimes i think getting sick is just an excuse to eat garlic soup. i’ve got the house to myself tonight and i intend to have a moderate bowl of the soup along with some bread and salad, and serve up the rest of the soup tomorrow among three people.
but the more i think about it, the more i doubt that there will be any trace of garlic soup by tomorrow.
except a lingering odor, of course.
Love, love love Garlic soup. Made this several years ago for my sister and family. To say they were wild for it is an understatement. My brother-in-law ate 4 bowls of it! They could not stop talking about it for hours. That was until the ‘interesting effects on the body’ kicked in. Needless to say- he was miserable having had nearly all 40 cloves of it himself. To this day we speak fondly of that delicous garlic soup as a memory. I have been asked to never make it again. (for them anyway)
Garlic lovers – try Caprial Pense’s Fresh Tomato Tart with Roasted Garlic Crust! The crust another winner!