brownie-roll-out-cookies Recipes

brownie roll-out cookies

Two weeks ago, Alex and I took advantage of the then-awesome weather and went out for dinner at a place with outdoor seating. One cocktail led to another and then Alex put his hand on my knee! No, just kidding. He actually suggested that we order dessert, and in particular, the homemade ice cream sandwiches on the menu. Who was I to argue?

feeding my cookie cutter addictionchocolate, pronounced

The two tiniest, most precious ice cream sandwiches arrived a few minutes later and, you know, the ice cream, it was pretty good. But the sandwich? The two chocolate cookies? Forgive me for using this over-tired metaphor, but they were an almost Proustian experience.

cookie footprints

You see, we made chocolate cookies exactly like that for Hanukah each year growing up. Why for Hanukah? Honestly, I have no idea. It might be that the only cookie cutters I remember were our Hanukah ones (a dreydel, menorah and Jewish star, the nuisance-y stamp type that it was impossible to get the dough out of) or that it was the only time my mother found the nuisance of rolling out dough worth it, but man, did I love those cookies, and I had to make them again, immediately.

unbaked brownie roll-out cookies

I know what you’re thinking: chocolate roll-out cookies? How dull! But, well, I’m sorry–you’re wrong. What’s notable about these cookies is not what they are–which is, if you must know, intensely awesome–but what they’re not. There’s no sea salt in them, no melted 70 percent chocolate. There’s no brown butter or vanilla bean pulp or pinch of espresso powder. There is not a single thing in them we’d probably jazz them up with today, and instead of fighting this simplicity, I encourage you to revel in it.

brownie roll-out cookies

They will not disappoint. The slight amount of baking powder gives them a softness not usually found in roll-out cookies, which are typically sandier and snappish. These are tender, like a pressed brownie and they particularly excel at a quarter-inch height, slightly thicker than a standard cookie cutter cookie. The cocoa is not an afterthought (like recipes that suggest you swap a couple tablespoons of flour for cocoa to make an chocolate cookie) but has a significant presence that blooms in the oven, leaving you with something that people won’t believe doesn’t have a single bit of melted chocolate in it.

I should also tell you that because of their shatter-free bite, they also make excellent lids and bases for ice cream sandwiches. But I won’t, because that would be dangerous. Okay?

brownie roll-out cookies

One year ago: Chicken Empanadas with Chorizo and Olives

Brownie Roll-Out Cookies*
Recipe from Deb’s mom

3 cups (375 grams) all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon (3 grams) salt
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
1 cup (225 grams) lightly salted butter, softened (Deb note: I don’t really see “lightly salted” much these days, so I used one stick salted, one stick unsalted)
1 1/2 (300 grams) cups sugar
2 large eggs
1 teaspoon (5 ml) vanilla extract
2/3 cup unsweetened cocoa (approximately 60 grams — weights can vary a bit depending on brand. I use the “good” stuff–Droste, Galler or Valrhona –but I can assure you that my mother only used Hershey’s growing up, so your choice)

Preheat oven at 350 degrees. Whisk dry flour, salt and baking powder in bowl and set aside. Mix butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla and cocoa in mixer. Gradually add flour mixture, and mix until smooth. Wrap in plastic and chill for at least one hour.

Roll out cookie dough on floured counter. Cut into desired shapes, brushing extra deposits of flour off the top. (It does disappear once baked, though, so don’t overly fret if they go into the oven looking white.) Bake on a parchment-lined baking sheet for 8 to 11 minutes (the former for 1/8-inch thick cookies, the latter for 1/4-inch cookies) until the edges are firm and the centers are slightly soft and puffed.

Transfer to a wire rack to cool.

* According to my mother’s recipe, they’re called chocolate sugar cookies but I do not feel that it does them justice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New here? You might want to check out the comment guidelines before chiming in.

452 comments on brownie roll-out cookies

  1. Yum! I ce cream Sandwich’s are my favorite! Yum Yum Yum. I notice that one year ago was the empanadas! Yes the very ones that were stolen from me by Amy’s Cool Women Who Rock (uh, suck) club. I have never forgotten them. Guess that is what I get for getting drunk on Cinco de Mayo and leaving them in Amy’s freezer. Grrrrr. Maybe I will try to make them myself….. HA HA HA AH AH AHAHAHAHA AH AHAHAHAH

  2. charlotte s

    mmmm… my husband was just telling me yesterday that his favorite dessert as a kid was ice cream sandwiches- these look like just the perfect cookie!
    i’m always disappointed when sandwiching icecream with regular cookies- they are always unpleasant to bite- and these ” brownie roll-outs ” are just genius! lets see, my husbands out watching a game- i may just surprise him with these now!

  3. RA

    Ooh, my husband would love ice cream sandwiches with these! Of course, he would love ice cream in any form, but that’s a minor detail. I suppose I need to procure a rolling pin…

  4. Rachel

    Hi Deb!
    do you think I can use non-Dutch processed cocoa with this? That’s all I have at the moment. I’m thinking the baking powder might not work in this case – could I use baking soda? How important is the leavening agent?
    thank you!

  5. deb

    I noted in the recipe that although I used Dutch cocoa, I can assure you that growing up, my mother only used Hershey’s–i.e. you can use either. Personally, I think Dutched cocoas have a richer taste, which is why they are my preference.

  6. I’m trying these as soon as I have a moment! I bought cookie cutters at the Sur La Table near me that is going out of business. That store only lasted like 2.5 years…such a shame. I love baking!!!!!!!!!!!!! I love your BLOG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  7. Susan

    “Roll out cookie dough on floured counter until. ” – until what? Also, will these freeze for storage? Thanks so much for your blog – I absolutely love your photos and your recipes!

  8. Wow. I cannot wait to make these. My roommates are going to go nuts.

    Also, now I want to make those empanadas again. I made them for a vaguely Mexican themed party about a month ago and at one point my friend Tom came over to me with two in his hands and one in his mouth and asked me why I didn’t tell him they were so delicious. Thanks for the inspiration, Deb!

  9. deb

    The error is fixed now.

    If you wish to freeze them, I always think it’s best to do so before they are baked. I only baked about a third of my batch. The rest I rolled out, cut into shapes, flash-froze so they would not stick together and then layered them between pieces of wax paper (to be extra cautious) in a freezer bag. Can’t wait to bake them off in the coming months!

  10. I’m in love with Skinny Cow Ice Cream Sandwiches, and I might just have to try my own version with these. Though…I suppose they won’t be quite as skinny then :)

  11. courtney

    you have never steered me wrong in cookie land before (I found my favorite cookie thanks to you, and chocolate chip cookies that finally pleased my husband texture wise) so I suppose I must make these.

    Plus now I might have an excuse to buy the ice cream maker I have wanted for 2 1/2 years now.

  12. These are getting made this week! Wow! they look devine and the idea of making ice cream sandwhiches…. Gotta try it!

    yesterday I made english muffins from your pancakes, english muffins, frisee salad post. They’re tricky because the dough is so sticky. The first four were badly burnt. They set off the smoke alarms. So I lowered the temp on the griddle to about pancake heat and halved the dough for the next batch. When they were browned nicely on both sides I thought they were still uncooked in the middle, but… I was wrong. Split with a fork and toasted, they were heavenly.

  13. Your dessert recipes do it to me every time… I think I should start a new blog, something like… sinful smitten kitchen recipes – done gluten free… because your recipes torment me so :-)

  14. Christina

    Yum! I can’t wait to try these cookies. Can you please tell me where you bought your set of cookie cutters? Thanks

  15. I am so making these on Thursday – France labour’s day! I’ve been quite anxious about not having the time to go grocery shopping for some leisure baking, but since I have everything at home, you’ll certainly find my on Thursday pm, still wearing pajamas, in my kitchen, rolling and cutting these!

    – fanny

  16. deb

    Here’s the link for the cookie cutters. However, if you look closely, you can see even in the picture that they are not sealed well. Because it is only at the top, it doesn’t affect the final shape of the cookie, but it is annoying/a sign of not-wonderful construction. Sur la Table has two sets that look like they may be better.

  17. Jamie

    hey Deb,
    i have a quick question :) how come you dust the tops of the cookies with flour before baking? just curious…
    i am SO making these !
    thanks ! :)

  18. deb

    Just lightly brush them. The concern is if there is too much flour, the cookies will not have that lovely dark chocolate color. A little bit is fine, though.

  19. amy

    Dear Deb’s mom,
    right now I love you and I hate you.
    I love you because I am about to get up from my computer, walk into my kitchen and make these cookies that i have been DROOLING over ever since your dear daughter posted pictures on flickr.
    I hate you because I am about to get up from my computer, walk into my kitchen and make these cookies that i have been DROOLING over ever since your dear daughter posted pictures on flickr. And then I am going to then sit down on the couch and eat 15 of them in one sitting. And that’s not good because swimsuit season is around the corner.
    Thank you do much for making my day and ruining my summer plans.
    With mixed feelings,

  20. Mindy

    About how many cookies does this recipe make? And what is the reason for the flour dusting? Is it necessary? They look fantastic, I think I’m going to conquer them tonight!

  21. Mindy

    Oh! Just saw that you brush excess flour OFF, not adding extra on. Nevermind. But am still curious about the number of cookies this recipe makes. Thanks!

  22. Katie in Berkeley

    I commend your excellent use of “Proustian” as a descriptor here. So often people mean “I like madeleines” by that reference, but you actually used it to indicate the power of food to bring back memories. Yay! Not over-tired at all!

  23. so simple! so delicious looking! my tendency is indeed to embellish with the latest ingredient trend but often I fall back to that original simple goodness too. and the fact that I will have access to an ice cream maker this summer guarantees that I’ll be making these soon!

  24. deb

    Mindy — The number of cookies this recipe makes depends very much on the cookie cutter you use. My small one made “a lot”–about four dozen, probably more.

  25. A propos cookie cutters – beware of the william sonoma ones. I just got mine, gave them a good rinse before use… and… they went all rusty on me. which was very sad, because I’ve been itching to make pretty-shaped cookies for over a month now. I’m going to try the Sur La Table ones – they’ve been so good to me lately. And yes, these look incredible particularly because they are that simple. Can’t wait to make these!

  26. looks really great! I was wondering if you have any suggestions in adding in a coffee flavor to this? It would be delightful to have chocolate-coffee flavored ice cream sandwiches :-D

  27. A

    These look really amazing. I remember going to my aunt’s friend’s house with her for a dinner/birthday party when I was younger and having homemade ice cream sandwiches for the first time. It had never even occured to me that you could make them at home. These look like they’d be delicious even without the ice cream (though I can see them being delicious with vanilla/coffee/cinnamon/butter pecan…)

  28. Ann

    Beautiful. Thanks for the clarification about the cocoa too, bc I don’t have dutch. I was going to make brownies this week, but now I’m considering these. What I’m wondering though is, do you think adding a smidge, a dollop, or a plop of frosting or icing would be too over the top?

  29. Nan

    This does it…I’m going to have to start an entire new cookbook…with just your recipes! Aside from ruining every diet I’ve started every Monday of the last year, your recipes are totally harmless! This one looks particularly harmless also…I’m beginning to wonder why I wasn’t lucky enough to grow up eating Hanukah cookies!

  30. So.. stupid question… but…

    Deb, you said you flash froze them before layering them between wax paper and putting them in for the long haul – How do you flash freeze?


  31. deb

    I flash freeze items until they’re hard, so they won’t stick to their neighbors. Cookies tend to be quick–20-30 minutes usually do.

  32. Hi:

    Hope you didn’t already answer this and I just missed it. Can I use natural cocoa powder or must it be Dutch processed? I prefer to use Scharffen Berger’s natural cocoa powder, but am hesitant to do so since you mentioned Droste and the recipe has baking powder….

    Thanks, Laura

  33. deb

    I’ve answered it twice, but I don’t expect that everyone should read 61 comments before leaving one! …Yes, you can use either. I prefer Dutched, but can assure you that my mother, who’s recipe this is, had never used anything but Hershey’s brand and they were delicious enough to make this impression.

  34. Laura 2

    Ah, the joy of turning on my Mac, opening Mail/RSS program and seeing the beauty of a Smitten Kitchen cookie in all its Dutch processed cocoa goodness :)

  35. Becca


    So I’ve been reading for awhile, and this is the second chocolate cookies recipe of yours I’ve tried – I made the Oreoes a few weeks back and they were a big hit. My dough for these is chilling now, but it seems a bit on the dry side, not as sticky as I’m used to for cookies…but I’m not a super-experiences baker. Is that normal?

  36. Yum. I like making sandwiches out of molasses crinkles and lemon ice cream, or key lime pie filling made with lemon instead of lime, and frozen in between the cookies…

  37. I’m so sad. I tried making these last night, and they never came together…literally. They remained a loose, almost sandy texture. I ended up just having to make little balls, and then smooshing them into flat rounds when they were still hot.

    Any ideas for why them came out so dry? The flavor was still great though! Not that I had one (or 4) for breakfast :)

  38. deb

    Hi Brandy — Not sure what happened. We’ve been using this recipe for dozens of years (god, I’m so old) just as it is. Any ideas?

  39. PmntPattye

    Been a lurker for months now…I use your recipes a lot. Thanks for all your helpful information and great recipes.

    Last night I made these and they turned out very crunchy. I put the ice cream between them, froze them, and they were still crunchy…but they were still great tasting, just a bit messy to eat! Keep up the fantastic work!

  40. Maybe the altitude (I live in Colorado)? Should I have tried to add some liquid (milk?) Another egg? I’d love to make these again, but they were impossible to roll out. But like I said, so good.

    Any ideas for what I may have done wrong? Or what I can do to remedy it? It all went bad when I was adding the flour mixture :(

  41. Eileen

    I am defnitely turning these into ice cream sandwiches… gives me an excuse to use my new ice cream maker as well. Thank you.

  42. deb

    Hm, I wonder. I have no experience with high-altitude baking, so maybe someone else can chime it but if it was just a rolling out issue, well, rolling out hard, cold doughs can always be difficult and can crack and crumble if done too roughly or quickly. (Remind me to do a tutorial on this soon!)

  43. Sula

    Brandy, the same thing happened with my dough. When I mixed it up, it was not as sticky as I thought it should be for a dough that needed to be frozen, and it turned into sandy lumps in the fridge. I also smooshed it into balls and baked it anyway. The cookies tasted fine but were pretty ugly.

    And I live in Michigan, so it’s definitely not the altitude (for me, at least).

    I’m wondering if I added too much flour? I’ve stopped spooning my flour into my measuring cup for things like cookies because it seemed unnecessary (I just scoop); maybe I should start again? Or start weighing the dry ingredients?

  44. after I saw your post, made these yesterday. terrific flavor. I did the ice cream sandwich thing that you mentioned and the family really liked it. Noticed a commenter said theirs turned out crunchy, just so you know, mine did not – texture much like what your pics look like. Thanks so much for sharing.

  45. I want to make a batch of decorated cookies and send them to a friend, but i would love to go non-traditional with these chocolate cookies (versus plain sugar). Can these brownie cookies be decorated in the same way that roll-out sugar cookies are… with royal icing and the works?? my concern is that they might be too soft or that the flavor with royal icing might be odd…

  46. Yeah, my dough looked NOTHING like that! It didn’t stick to the mixer paddle at all. Maybe next time I’ll just add the flour super slow until it’s the right consistency? Or should I add a liquid? Egg?

    Oops, I already asked that!

  47. Thank you for this! The timing was perfect for me–all day, I was telling co-workers that I was craving “something like a cookie or a cake. Not a brownie, but something in-between…” I couldn’t articulate what it was, and then you posted the recipe! I made them the next day and was completely satisfied with just one or two.

    I will bake the rest of the dough tonight, and am planning to fill them with a cream cheese frosting.

  48. Deb, first I want to say, you’re cooking is exquisite!
    Second, I came to your site yesterday looking for something to take to for a co-worker’s birthday, and I found these lovelies. I made them and got compliments all around! I owe you all the credit! I sent everyone who asked for the recipe to your site. Expect a flood!


    p.s. I’m sorry I can’t stop with the exclamation points!! It’s because I really mean it!!

  49. Sarah

    I’m always looking for a good cocoa-only chocolate cookie recipe. Do you think I could halve the recipe with good results?

  50. Elisa

    Hi there,
    I’m just trying to figure out how much a ‘stick’ of butter weighs. Measuring butter into cups is way too many steps for me – I’m much better at just slicing a section off the block. But I’ve got a feeling that an American ‘stick’ is somewhat smaller than an Australian one.
    Little help?

  51. Maybe I missed something, but the recipe does not indicate whether the butter should be cold, room-temp, or melted. Could this be part of the dough-consistency problem? I can only assume that it should be melted and cooled, in order to be able to mix the dry cocoa powder into it. Why is the cocoa not mixed with all the other dry ingredients? There must be a reason for this. Thanks for answering.

  52. deb

    The butter should be soft–I will edit that now.

    I considered updating the recipe to whisk the cocoa with the other dry ingredients, but as I said, this is my mom’s recipe, we’ve always made it this way and it’s always worked this way, so I wanted to keep it authentic.

  53. Luinecu

    I’ve just finished baking a batch of these moments ago. My dough looked exactly as your refrence picture in the comments above, and I had no problems at all (maybe those who found theirs to be too dry were using smaller eggs? I did use particually large ones..). I ended up rolling out my cookies between plastic wrap, which worked very well for me. And because I’m using an Aga (which aways runs a little hot, even using the cooling plate) decreased the baking time by 2 mins and turned them around after the first 3. Mine didn’t rise as much as yours (hardly at all, actually) but turned out with a lovely texture.

    .. Now to try to pursuade my brother to drive us to the 24hr supermarket for icecream.. it may be gone midnight, but I’m dying to try these babies out with a scoop of vanilla. Thank you!!! I’ll be using this one again!

  54. oh, we’re going to have to try these too! i love making ice cream sandwiches, always a treat when the kids open the freezer to find them (just for the kids – right!) these remind me a bit of peace cookies, have you tried them – they’re our favorite. they would be too crumbly for ice cream sandwiches though. thanks for the recipe! xo heidi

  55. Jules

    Deb, do you know how much your flour usually weighs per cup when you scoop? I’ve been using a scale for baking these past few months, assuming 4.25 oz./cup, but get almost 5 oz. when I scoop into the cup. The dough is currently chilling and seems fine, I was just curious!

  56. After reading different posts that used several recipes from your site I just had to come and see it for myself. I can now see the reason(s) you became such an inspiration to many food bloggers :).
    Your cookies just made it to my must-do list. That last photo: simply stunning!

  57. Deb, I made these cookies yesterday and paired them up with some mint chip ice cream today. Just by themselves they’re amazing, with the ice cream? Heavenly!
    I used Dagoba Cacao. Didn’t have anything but unsalted butter so I added a smidgen more salt to the recipe and everything turned out just fine. I also don’t have an electric mixer. Everything was mixed by hand with excellent results.

    I’m always looking forward to your posts!

  58. Elise

    I made these last weekend and they were an unmitigated success. Everyone loved them – my family, my co-workers. They were so easy. The only change I made to the recipe was to about a tablespoon or so of milk as I was mixing the batter because as the flour went in, the batter got really dry. That did the trick. I’d love to try making these with a ganache icing. Thanks for the recipe! Oh I was also amazed by how many cookies this batter made – I kept re-rolling the scraps and ended up with at least 5 dozen.

  59. Neesha

    oh my i got the same cookie cutter recently! so adorable!!!! this sounds yummy i might give it a try. i still have a super jumbo sized chocolate cupcake waiting for me… ah. who cares? you can never have too much chocolate right?

  60. I’ve never liked cheap ice cream sandwiches. But the concept of ice cream sandwiches is just so good, and this is exactly what I’ve been imagining to be the perfect ice cream sandwich cookie. I just didn’t know a recipe existed for it…thanks!!!

  61. Erin

    Oh, Deb–another winner! I made these cookies today to turn into ice cream sandwiches for my mom’s birthday. (I’m making strawberry ice cream–one of her favorites.) I had to try one of the cookies and they are the most amazing texture. And they’re so EASY! Thanks again for another great recipe. I love this site!

  62. kookie in London

    Hey deb, thanks for this recipe. Great flavour but I totally overbaked my first batch. My niece still loved helping me cut them out and eating them too – she didn’t have a sandwich but immediately worked out that they were good for dipping in icecream! Very astute kid! Anyway plan to make and freeze more, great to have this as a ready to go dessert. Looking forward to your next post as always.

  63. Duessa

    Hi all. I have only been lurking on your blog for about three days but I was recently compelled to post. Today I was sitting by the boy friend while reading your blog and he got curious (for once, lol) and looked over my shoulder. You know how you imagine cave men grunting for food? Well, he saw these cookies and grunted his appreciation. lol So now I HAVE to make them but there are only two of us here and I don’t have ANY cookie cutter. lol That is what you get for being young and in college. : ) Any suggestions? My butter is already out of the fridge and I have a limited amount of time before he calls me from work demanding I bring them for his lunch! lol

    Thanks all. You all seem great and have given me a number of laughs over the past few days. : )

  64. Duessa

    Also, is there a problem with melting the butter a little bit in the microwave first? I do this with my sugar cookie recipee and it always turns out great and cuts prep time way down. Thanks!

  65. Sky in Santa Cruz

    Deb two quick questions:

    1. When you say to “Mix butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla and cocoa in mixer” is it as simple as it sounds – throw it all in there and let it rip?

    2. How thick would you say the dough should be rolled out to?

  66. deb

    Hi Sky — 1. Yes. I know, it sounded odd to me too; like most bakers I am used to mixing my dry ingredients, beating my wet ones and being delicate when combining the two. But this worked. I considered rewriting the recipe so it fit the standard recipe-writing patterns, but like I said, it worked, it’s from mom, I didn’t mess with it. :)

    2. 1/8-inch thick is fairly standard, and that’s the way we made them when I was a kid. But 1/4-inch? Oh my. They get really brownie-like, and so tender in the middle. So, it depends on what you’re going for.

  67. Deb, two questions:

    1) I’m trying to decide between two of your chocolate cookie recipes for ice cream sandwiches (where sandwich = chocolate cookies + peanut butter ice cream). Which would you recommend? This one? Or the one from your previous post about ice cream sandwich cookies?

    2) When making ice cream sandwiches, do you scoop the ice cream in between two cookies and eat it right away? Or do you re-freeze the whole sandwich in some plastic wrap? I don’t want my cookies to get soggy, but one of my favorite memories of my youth is biting into that ever-yielding cookie of a chipwich, where the whole thing stays mostly together until it’s all melty down your arm at the end. Thoughts?

  68. deb

    Hi Lizzi — I actually think I’d use this one. I think there’s something slightly softer about it when it is cold. I also recommend refreezing the cookies after you scoop it–something we didn’t do that first time around almost two years (!) ago. It was messy and they melted too fast.

  69. Sarah

    Made these last night using Green and Black’s Organic cocoa (Green and Blacks is UK based and aaammaaazing. Their 85% chocolate is like a fine or two squares is all it takes to satisfy!!). The cookies are fabulous!! I’ve frozen half the dough to use later, as the recipie (as you said) makes ‘alot’ of cookies. Love them, and so easy! Thanks for this!

  70. Jackie

    Hi, I’m a novice baker and wonder if it’s possible to roll out the dough for this recipe using a large plastic tumbler. I don’t own a rolling pin (just moved flats and there was none in the cutlery drawer), but will obviously run out and buy one if it’s definitely needed.

  71. Sue

    I also have no cookie cutter and find that successive rolling out can make the later batches more tough as more and more flour gets incorporated. I’m just going to cut into squares — not so pretty but should taste as good. I also think I might try making a long roll that I can slice ( like the old-style refrigerator cookies). For (109) Jackie — try an empty wine bottle.

  72. Heather

    The Sur La Table cookie cutters look exactly like the ones you have pictured, except that the seams are sealed better and they have rolled edges on the top so they don’t hurt your hands. I purchased them a long time ago – well before I came across this recipe. I’m so excited to use them for these cookies! :)

  73. SLM

    these were great! even better with icecream.
    i live in a ‘high elevation’ state (UT) and read a prevous comment about from someone in CO. i added an extra egg to the recipe and it came out perfect to me! hth’s someone.

  74. Pegster

    I tried these this week and they were a big hit at work! My old boss (who moved to a different organisation) even made an excuse to stop by and grab some when he heard I had been baking! Five stars from me, and thank you for posting the recipe. :)

  75. Maggie

    These were a HUGE hit with my dinner guests. I used a biscuit cutter, and the size was perfect. We got Haagen Dazs pints in mint chocolate chip and coffee, and my husband just sliced the pints up and peeled off the paper–so easy! The cookies are good on their own, but their lack of sweetness was just ideal for this use. Thanks, Deb!

  76. Jen

    I’m seaching for a good chocolate cookie recipes and I think I found it!!! Its a little too cold to sammich these with ice cream so I’m thinking I might fill it with homemade oreo filling and revel in the delicious-ness! Love your blog! Hope you had fun and ate wayyy too much good stuff in Paris.

  77. Bill

    I made these for a party yesterday, and they were a huge hit. Even though I overbaked them a little (I always have that problem with cookies) the insides stll remained super soft like a brownie.

  78. I made these over the weekend as part of my xmas cookies bake-a-thon (it’s never too early!) and they were a HUGE hit with everyone (including myself). Thanks so much for sharing, they will be made again…soon!

  79. Wendy

    Made these with mint Italian buttercream filling and they were scrumptious! I wonder, have you ever played with the recipe to make a vanilla version? I need a superior sugar cookie for cut outs and thought this would be great!
    Thanks for your recipes!

  80. Donilyn

    I can not wait to make these! For the last couple days the thought of making chocolate cookies will not leave my brain! Some people wake up with thoughts of the day or what happened the day before. Not me, I wake up with the notion that I have to find a chocolate cookie recipe!! ha ha

  81. Karin

    I made these last night and very happily enjoyed a mint chocolate chip ice-cream sandwich at around midnight!

    I screwed up the recipe at every turn and had to work really hard to get the dough to ‘dough up’ – but it all worked out fine by the rollout phase.

  82. JC

    Just made these, they are on the cooling racks now. They’re part of my Christmas cookie selection. I used a star shaped cookie cutter and am going to drizzle them with white chocolate. My husband and I will have them for dessert tonight with some whipped cream and raspberries.

    Great recipe, as always. I’m also thinking of adapting it to a “vanilla” sugar cookie recipe…..the texture was/is great.

  83. Jen

    I saw from your beautiful photographs that the cooked product stays true to the cut of the raw dough, so I selected this recipe for ‘gingerbread houses’ and just added some ground ginger powder to the recipe. They turned out perfectly and came together beautifully because the dough shapes I cut out for walls, roof, etc did not change size/shape during cooking. I’m going to use this recipe again and again… because not all kids are such fans of ginger but everyone loves chocolate. I’m loving your recipes and have bookmarked plenty for future use.

  84. Jackie

    So my husband springs on me that he would like 200 cookies to bring in to thank everyone on his team for a good job this year. I ran a test run of this recipe last night. Fantastic! This is a definite keeper recipe. Thank you!

  85. Ann

    Well, don’t try to bake them without sugar! I was so pleased with how easy they were to mix up and how beautifully they rolled out, but the taste was …”something’s MISSING!” I figured it out and rebaked. They are wonderful — worth the extra round. I’ve sent my husband out for peppermint crunch. I figure I’ve earned it.

    Happy Holidays!

  86. Just did a trial run of these and they are fabulous! We’re doing an ice cream sandwich bar for my son’s first birthday party in two weeks and these will really round out the selection (also doing chocolate chip and snickerdoodles with chocolate, vanilla, and mint ice cream). Thanks for sharing! You have yet to lead me astray.

  87. heidi

    i made these last week using low-fat drinking choc mix (all i had, emergency recipe change after i realised at 8pm on jan 1st i didnt have enough ginger to make gingerbread and needed cookies to take to my boyfriends family)
    they still turned out awesome. we tend to get smallish eggs in japan, but i also suspect i dont measure things properly lol so everything probably works out proportionately. i melted the butter slightly in the microwave first cos room temp here is too cold.
    lessons learnt: dont let boyfriend play with electric mixer.
    dont let boyfriend eat all the cookies. he would seriously eat the whole batch in one go.
    flour the insides of the cookie cutter regularly!

    am making these again tomorrow with cocoa.
    long time lurker from osaka.

  88. Erin

    I looove these cookies, and have made them before to go with strawberry ice cream (and that was divine).

    But this week, I cut them into small heart shapes and sandwiched them with some pink-tinted buttercream for a Valentine’s treat to take into work. They are AWESOME. I toyed with making Deb’s homemade Oreos, but I really wanted a heart shape, so I used these instead.

    They were absolutely not too sweet (something I worried about), but rather perfectly soft and a little salty and a great contrast to the sweet (traditional) buttercream. A major hit at work and beyond.

  89. deb

    I haven’t tried it (but let us know if you do) but I’d be hesitant to. The wafers for an icebox cake need to be able to completely absorb the whipped cream and become cake-like… I haven’t seen many homemade cookies that can pull that off.

  90. Michele

    Hmm. I would call them Cocoa Cookies. My texture came out not brownie-like at all, and while I think most desserts are too sweet, this was on the verge of not sweet enough. I think it needs a) dutch-processed cocoa, which I didn’t use and would help with the bitterness I detected, and b) ice cream. Otherwise, I wouldn’t make them again as a stand-alone. Next, those delicious looking oatmeal cookies you posted!

  91. Ruby

    Someone mentioned re-rolling the scraps. Would you recommend re-rolling the scraps and baking the 2nd-round cookies or does the re-rolling really affect the baked result?

    1. deb

      I always re-roll the scraps, but it does affect the results slightly. Every time you re-roll, it picks up more flour, so the cookie will theoretically toughen — this is the case with all roll-out cookies. I try to do so as little as possible/be as efficient as possible when cutting shapes out.

  92. Deb, I have to say: I love your site, and I use your recipes so often…but this one is my favorite. I think I’ve made these for every major holiday and every birthday for two years, because everyone loves them. I even made them in star shapes for the last meeting of one of my college classes, my Tolkien class–stars for Elbereth, of course.

    Long story short, you don’t know how grateful I am for this recipe and for your site.

  93. Ruby

    Before I go and fool around with your perfect recipe, and I feel okay asking you as I am tapping into your self-declared nit-pickiness, do you think that brown sugar would make these more chewy and moist? Or would the brown sugar drown out part of the chocolate flavour? But please know, I love this recipe and will definitely turn to it again and again!

  94. deb

    I haven’t tired it with brown sugar, but do let us know if you do and how it goes! My only concern would be that sometimes, brown sugar in cookies like this causes them to spread a bit — I would assume it’s the extra moisture due to the molasses in the brown sugar.

  95. Ruby

    Shouldn’t have fooled around with your perfect recipe, but doubt I have learned my lesson. I replaced the white sugar with brown sugar, & added a teaspoon of instant espresso (dissolved in 1 tsp boiling water). The brown sugar made the cookies more dense, but in a heavy, dull way, not fudgy:( And even though you’d think they would be more moist with the extra moisture from the brown sugar, I needed to shorten the baking time from 10 minutes to 8 minutes, which is a lot, and they were still drier than the original! Espresso didn’t really enhance the cocoa flavour either; I think you have a perfect balance between chocolate flavour and sugar. The espresso just added a bitter hint. However, the brown sugar did not cause them to spread. So now I know not to fool with your recipes – thank you for entertaining them, though, Deb.

  96. judy

    Perhaps this has been mentioned & I missed it – but I have heard about rolling cookies on a lightly floured board using powdered sugar in place of the flour to keep them from getting tough – would that work for these brownies?

  97. Melissa

    My husband LOVES ice cream sandwiches and is turning 40 this weekend. He also has an obsession with cookie monster (strange, i know, you would never guess if you met him) so i was going to surprise him with cookie monster ice cream sandwiches at his party. This recipe sounds perfect (and delicious!) but i was wondering if anyone had ever tried icing these? do you think it would work/taste ok (for the cookie monster face)? also if i bake them the day before will they still taste fresh? Just found your blog, it’s wonderful!

  98. Heidi

    Deb, These cookies are incredible!!
    A friend of mine gave me cookie cutters in this exact shape and pointed me to this recipe, knowing full well I would have no choice but to bake them immediately. I did. And fell in love!! They turned out perfectly – crunchy outside, soft inside!
    I overcooked some of them a bit and they still tasted great (especially with sandwiched with some white chocolate ganache!)
    Total Smitten Kitchen convert!!

  99. Delilah

    Just followed a link trail to this post.

    My dough is chilling as I write this. Here’s a hint: instead of rolling out with flour, try a light sprinkling of cocoa powder. This is standard for chocolate doughs.

  100. Briana

    Mmm… these just came out of the oven and boy are they good! I added some andes mint chips and they are just perfect. I can’t wait to try making ice cream sandwiches out of these.

  101. Teresa

    I made these over the weekend and used them for ice cream sandwiches. They were quite good, very chocolatey and rich. And the dough was surprisingly easy to work with, I had no problems rolling it out and cutting it. Here’s my one pet peeve, though – don’t tell me to preheat my oven, then a paragraph later, tell me to chill the dough for an hour. I know, I should read the whole recipe through first, right? I did, but I still turned on my oven as directed and then realized 15 minutes later, that I wasn’t going to need it for at least an hour. I’m sorry if I seem petty, I admit it is a silly thing to complain about!

  102. Tracy

    I made these this week and loved them! The icecream sandwiches were delicious too. I added chopped walnuts for a full brownie effect! Next time I will add more! I worried it would make them hard to roll out or burn, but no problems! Thanks!

  103. Little English girl

    I made these for valentines day as heart-shaped cookie pops! They looked so cute, I dusted some with confectioners’ sugar and dipped some of the others in melted white chocolate.
    I’m making them again tonight, I thought they were so great!
    Thanks for such a wonderful recipe!

  104. Kara

    I just made these and they are currently chilling. I found the dough very hard to work with actually. I felt like there was too much flour and too little liquid. My mixer had a hard time keeping up, so I coated my hands in flour and dove in. It was easier to mix together with my hands. I do look forward to trying them though. And I want to use them for ice cream sandwiches. I won’t be making homemade today, but I’m going to use Sheer Bliss natural vanilla ice cream, (comes in a metal tin!)

  105. Joyce

    Hi Deb,
    I want to make these for a party this Sunday, how long do these cookies last after baking them? id prefer not to bake them on the day in case they don’t turn out.Im a novice!

  106. Annie

    I’d like to bake ginger bread cookies that have the same wonderful texture as these. Any suggestion how to adapt the recipe?
    By the way, I used ordinary Fry’s cocoa and they were delicious!
    I left out almost half a cup of flour because it got too hard to blend (despite using dry-ingredients measuring cups and so-called large eggs). But it worked perfect!

  107. Nessie

    Some one asked before whether you could frost these: I made these this weekend in the shape of Jack ‘o Lanterns and iced them with good old buttercream and they are totally delish!! The cookies are not overly sweet so BC goes really well with it. The buttercream dried overnight but it doesnt totally harden (if you want the icing to go really hard try using royal icing – I just prefer the taste of BC). I used regular cocoa and thought they could be a bit more chocolately so will definitely try these out with dutch cocoa next time. Thanks heaps for the recipe! By the way your photos are gorgeous! :)

  108. Hannah

    Amazing! I wanted to make cut out cookies and was bored with the old sugar cookie and tried this. They are like a legit brownie in a cookie, so good!

  109. To #132 – I re-rolled with no problems!!! Except when I rolled, I didn’t use flour… I used cocoa powder… may I insert an evil chocolate grin now?

    (These were amazing by the way!!!)

  110. amanda

    If anybody else is as stupid as me and pulls these out of the oven at time thinking “those aren’t done” because they look like they did when they went in.. they’re supposed to. They kept their exact shape even through my over cooking, and they are quite good, even with crunchy edges.

  111. roshelle

    I found your website looking up challah, (I am know known as the challah girl) and stumbled upon several of your recipes. I can’t tell you how obsessed I am with these cookies. These are by far the most incredible thing in the world. I made them wrong the first time but not having soft enough butter, so i added some milk which still made them incredible but the second time around. I can’t begin to tell you how obsessed I am with these cookies. Deb, please tell your mother thank you!!

  112. Katie

    My second run of this recipe is still on the cooling racks, so I have to leave a comment (because my finicky internet ate the one last time). These cookies are awesome! Ironically, the first time the dough was super sticky and this time it wasn’t, but this time I also chilled the dough longer which I think helped. I used Hershey’s cocoa powder and after the rave reviews last week I am thrilled to bring them to my big family Thanksgiving!

    Also, I suggest eating them with a smear of peanut butter between two of them; one of the most decadent things ever! :o)

  113. Kim

    I made these last night. It took exactly 11 minutes like you said. Delcious! and I used Hershey’s. it is not too sweet, which is just what I like in my cookies. Thanks to Deb’s Mom for the recipe, and I’m glad you re-named it brownie roll-out because that is exactly how it tastes. Next time I must make mini ice cream sandwiches out of these. Mmmm.

  114. Tonya

    I made these when you first posted the recipe and they were immediately my favourite. Then a few months ago we found out our four year old has a whole host of allergies including wheat, milk, and eggs which makes baking a whole lot trickier, but I’m getting the hang of it. I decided to try these again with a few substitutions, and they turned out beautifully – my most successful converted cookie recipe to date. Yay! I thought I’d post my substitutions in case any of your other readers have similar restrictions – 2 cups Bette Hagman’s gluten free mix, 1 cup sorghum flour and 1 tsp guar gum for the flour, 2 tbs flax mixed into 6 tbs of water for the eggs, and vegan margarine/shortening (I think I used earth balance shortening, either that or unsalted fleischman’s) instead of butter.

  115. E

    BEST. COOKIE. EVER. This is the sort of cookie that I dream about, but hardly ever make because I simply cannot be trusted with them. They are the perfect combination of brownie and cookie texture. Make sure to roll them out thickly so they are slightly crispy/chewy around the edge, and rich and fudgy in the middle.

    Ok, I have to get this off of my chest, the last time I made these I ended up eating the entire batch. And by ‘the last time’ I may mean the last three times. Oh, the shame!

  116. Stephy

    I decided to make these on a whim tonight after finding my old teddybear cookie cutter. They were absolutely PERFECT. I usually try to avoid recipes that require room temperature butter but I will definitely be making these more often. Thanks so much, Deb.

  117. pilar

    Hi Deb, Happy New year!!
    Thanks very much for this recipe, it worked perfectly. I tried with 1/4 and 1/8 inch and we prefer the ones of 1/4 inch. My kids loved them too. Love your post and thanks for sharing all your great recipes!! by the way, lovely pictures of your baby.

  118. Charity

    MMMmmmmm. These were a big hit with the big and the little people in my house. The perfect thing to make and eat while stuck inside for another snow day.

  119. Angela

    Yummy! My dough was very dry. I sprinkled some water over it just so i could get my mixer through it. I think they turned out great. I can’t stop eating…

  120. I used regular unsalted butter and Penzeys natural high-fat cocoa and they were very very good. I made an ice cream sandwich with one and it was also delicious. HOWEVER. For me, what really took this recipe to the next level is making the cookies into a peanut butter sandwich. I used creamy Jif and wouldn’t dare let the natural (grainier, healthier) stuff anywhere near it. But you should decide how many of these you want to eat in advance because you will be in no position to make that decision once you have started. Happy Valentine’s Day indeed!

  121. I baked these for Valentine’s Day using heart shaped cookie cutters. The dough was a little dry so some of the cookies were a little flaky looking on top. I’ll try either using bigger eggs or adding a little milk next time. The heart ice cream sandwiches were a huge hit and made for awesome pictures. My boyfriend double-fisted the cookies. Thanks for the tasty recipe.

  122. Meg

    I’ll definitely have to try these babies out! i’ve always loved how sugar cookies look once decorated. The only problem is, not all sugar cookies taste good. BUT I HAVE A VERY GOOD FEELING THESE DO & WILL. :)

  123. Heather

    I am on my 5th time making these. So yummy. Tonight I used unbleached flour and had to at a little milk to wet the dough. I’m wondering what else I can add to the base of these cookies as opposed to the cocoa powder. I love the soft texture. Was thinking ground almond and almond extract? Maybe oats and some honey?

  124. Marci

    It’s disgusting out today in NYC so I felt the need to bake a batch of warm cookies. Limited by my pantry and no desire to run out to the store in the hurricane, I turned to these cookies using unsalted butter (meant to make up for this by adding more salt but then I forgot to do that, whoops) and regular cocoa (for some reason, I have a very hard time finding Droste in midtown though it’s also my preference). Feeling lazy, I couldn’t bring myself to bother rolling out this dough so I patted it into a log and rolled it up in wax paper, stuck it in the freezer for 20 minutes, and then took it out and simply sliced treating them like a refrigerator cookie. Less fuss and nothing lost for sure as these are friggin’ delicious and my husband, who loves, LOVES, simple foods, is in love with these. I made forty (with 1/3 of the log still in the fridge for tomorrow) and we’ve eaten far too many of these already. We did not make them into ice cream sandwiches but I will in the summertime with vanilla ice cream and coffee ice cream. I also plan on trying these with a shmear of nutella for breakfast tomorrow. In the future, I may try swapping out some of the cocoa for finely ground coffee to make a chocolate coffee cookie. Around the holidays, I think these would be great with crushed up candy canes in them or rolled around the edges prior to cutting my log. And since I have a bag of hazelnuts, I may make these next with finely chopped hazelnuts – like a nutella cookie without the nutella. I absolutely love the texture of these and the flavor – just perfect – totally hit the spot on this dreadful day. Thanks Deb – you never fail to please! Also, I can’t stop making the cream scones and I always thought I hated scones… must stop baking now, too close to bathing suit season and still carrying some baby weight… sigh.

  125. Brooke

    These cookies… were soooooooo great. I am not a HUGE choclate fan, I usually enjoy chocoalte in something, rather then the main subject. These were grand. A friend of mine wanted to decorate cookies on valentines day, but she didn’t enjoy sugar cookies…. I wasn’t ready to settle for decorating choclate chip cookies and cupcakes aren’t exactly the same. I made a simple, but always great, frosting of a tbsn butter and milk melted (microwave) and mixed with powdered sugar to desired thickness. My roomie actually ended up smushing some ice cream inbetween some, but i prefered the frosted delights- but it may have had to do with how nice they looked frosted.
    great recipie nice, fluffy and soft… yet somehow carry a nice crisp to them. swell.

  126. Jen S.

    And…they are fantastic! This dough turned out perfectly and was very easy to work with. Since I was rolling it into logs and shaping it, I was particularly thankful. For those who asked, the recipe can be halved easily and with great success.
    I think that you might get 18-24 cookies from a half batch…I got an even dozen of the special cookies I was making and used a golf-ball size of dough per cookie.

  127. OOO!!!!! I can’t wait to try these ones, they look great! :)
    mmmm, this chocolate section of the blog is driving me crazy!! I can’t wait to get into the kitchen this weekend… Your blog makes me hungry/anxious! :)

  128. AmyLynn

    Deb. Deb… these were amazing! I brought them in to work and everyone is asking for the recipe. I can’t wait to try them again, maybe with ice cream, or to make sandwich cookies using your peanut butter icing recipe. Mmmmm.

  129. jen

    these cookies are simple and amazing. I just sprinkled a little raw sugar on the top for added crunch, but the taste and texture really are just perfect.

  130. Sally

    I just made these for the second time and this time added a couple of drops of peppermint oil, fabulous. They’ll be delicious filled with vanilla ice cream later tonight.

  131. Tina

    Can’t wait to try these! They look and sound fantastic! I stumbled across your site while looking for a chocolate cookie recipe to make Darth Vader cookies for my son’s birthday party. I think these will work perfectly.

  132. Meaghan

    I just made these last night and I should have known…. I think they are a rather unsuspecting little cookie but once you get going, wow, they are reeeeally addicting. Brilliant of you for sharing!

  133. Lisa

    Yup, these are crack cookies. Made them twice in the past week, used some for ice cream sandwiches ate the rest like potato chips.

  134. I love the comment above mine from Lisa – yes, crack cookies indeed!!!
    I made them for the first time this past weekend, and have had a hard time not eating every single one of them. I did not have ice cream this time around but will definitely make them again SOON.
    they are delightfully delicious – I used organic dark cocoa powder which made them even more special.
    I have linked this page to the photo of them that I put on my Flickr photo page.
    EVERYONE should have this recipe…
    seriously doubt if I’ll make any other kind of cookies again.
    I’ll be back to Smitten Kitchen for other culinary adventures.
    thank you thank you thank you !!!

  135. Jarrelle Sartwell

    my friend has been dying for me to make him a batch of brownies so instead of cracking open a box of duncan hines i took this recipe and made home-made borwnie cut out cookies! i dropped them off at his desk this morning and he started eating them for breakfast. my phone rang a few minutes after i sat at my desk and he said they were the best things he ever tasted! thanks once again smitten kitchen!!!

  136. Emily

    *cry* it went all wrong!! I had the same problem those couple people had from the start: once i’d added the flour my dough became a dry crumbly mess! I tried to salvage it by adding in some egg white to make it come together, but even though I added 3/8 c. I think I should have put more because the cookies were dry.

    I think I’ve got to assume it was the size of the eggs that made the difference, because even though I bought large I noticed they were a little on the small side, and I think I normally use extra large for baking.

    Maybe I should try rolling them out to 1/4″ instead of 1/8″, though, it might be better. If I make them again, I’ll probably add a little less flour, or at least keep a close eye on the mixer when adding it so I can stop if I have to.

    That’ll teach me not to bake late at night!

  137. kerrie

    On a smitten cookie roll right now – made a half batch of these, silly me, and they disappeared before I had time to get the ice cream in between them and make a little chocolate dipping sauce, so another batch in the making. I also made the brown butter brown sugar shorties for the second time this week – I am not going to pick favorites. Thanks Deb for all the deliciousness.

  138. Lisa

    I’m addicted to these cookies. I have made them twice. The first time I used them for homemade ice cream sandwiches. The second time, I kept the dough in the fridge for a week or so and used the dough to make up a tray here and there. I prefer them thicker so they stay soft though the crisp ones will soften overnight.

  139. katy

    these make amazing peanut butter sandwich cookies! i used my linzer cookie cutters to make the top and bottoms so that the tops would have little star cut outs. i am super excited to try them again with raspberry jam in between, yum!!!
    i accidentally ran out of flour while making these so one third of the flour was whole wheat – not bad, but next time with white flour they will be even better!
    thanks for the recipe!

  140. Rachel

    I made these as roll-out cookies last week, but had doubled the recipe. Tired of all the rolling out (my least favorite baking activity) I took the remaining dough, and made two 2-inch logs out of it. Left them in the fridge. Yesterday, needing cookies for my son’s baseball game, and having no time to mix and bake, I took out the logs of dough, sliced off about 50 1/4-inch cookies, and baked them up, about 8 mins. They kept their perfect circle shapes, and made for a pretty cookie. Once they were cooled, I sprinkled them with powdered sugar. So much easier, and just as tasty as the ones I did with all the rolling. Love the dough; hate the rolling. Just thought I’d share this easier option with others.

  141. Krista

    I regret knowing this recipe but not making them for (literally) years. What a dummy! The dough’s currently in the fridge but I already know they’re going to be wonderful just by how good that batter was. Licking the Kitchenaide paddle with after making this cookie is the best.

  142. Antonella

    Hi! This is my first comment on this wonderful site, and being an Italian girl I apologize in advance for my poor English :)
    I baked these cookies yesterday and all my family adored them. Unfortunately I can’t find any US measuring cup here, so I had to search my house for a milk cup that contained precisely 240 ml of water and used it for this recipe: it was fun, and even though I was worried it would be unprecise, the cookies turned out to be great, with a rich flavor and soft in the center. The dough was a little too soft compared to the usual italian rolling cookies dough, but with some flour I succeeded in taking the rounds out.
    So, thank you for this one! I’m so happy I found The smitten Kitchen, I’m reading a lot of recipe and enjoying your pictures during these days, and I feel like I can trust you blindly :D

  143. Michelle

    I dont know why but these cookies did not work at all for me! Even after putting down flour on the table, the dough got stuck to the counter! I had to put it back into the the fridge and try again but by that time it already had 2 layers of flour. I used a confection oven and they were already overcooked by 8 minutes. I had a few cookies left to cook that were not part of the burnt batch so I cooked those for 6 minutes. They came out much better but didnt end up tasting that great. Any suggestions?

  144. Teri

    Made these cookies today. Twice, at the request of my daughter. Being a somewhat lazy cook, I wasn’t looking forward to rolling the dough out so I made small balls of dough and pressed them to 1/4 inch or so with the bottom of a glass. Dipped the glass in sugar with each press – the same natural sugar I used in the dough in lieu of white sugar. Worked just fine. I cut back the flour about 1/4 cup in the second batch since the first was a little too dry and think it makes for a more tender cookie. Definitely will be making them again. And again!

  145. zoe

    I just tried making these and they haven’t worked.. :( The dough was really sticky and I had to put it in the freezer to get it firm enough to roll out, and now I just looked in the oven and they have totally spread and not help their shape at all..
    I’m assuming I’ve got the measurements wrong as I had to convert to grams (I live in the UK).. I used a conversion chart I found online but anyway, I’ve gone wrong somewhere. :( so disappointed! I was really looking forward to trying them after so many positive comments!

  146. These were a huge hit at a get-together today! People kept thinking they had something like cinnamon or ginger in them…I kept saying “nope, chocolate.” The first thing out of their mouths was “they’re like brownies,” so you did a good job measuring.

    Zoe-it must be the measurements. If it helps, 1 c of butter is a half-pound. I thought the UK also used cups, but I guess the whole EU thing has gotten there! The cups would probably be better measured by converting to ml since the cup is a measure of volume.

  147. Evie

    I have made these cookies a few times now…and they are loved by all!!! They really do taste like a brownie cookie….fabulous. Great texture…I have also decorated them with royal icing…even though they taste great with nothing at all. I do think some cream cheese icing would be a great addition.

  148. Nic

    Yum! My son has been asking to make Christmas cookies. I’m not a fan of sugar cookies and frosting, so I found this and had to try it. So yummy! I got a good cookie and he got to use his cookie cutters. Win/Win. Down side is I can’t seem to stop eating them. Good thing I only made a half batch. Thanks!

  149. Deb:
    Great great great recipe. I made it as gifts for my sons’ teachers. They were very appreciated.I just had one quick Q about the recipe, since the dough sits in the refrigerator for an hour, shouldn’t the preheating step be mentioned at the point when the baker is ready to roll out the dough?

  150. Marisa

    If you freeze them before baking, should you thaw them before baking or can you bake straight out of the freezer? If the latter, how long should you bake them (for 1/4 inch cookies)? Thank you!

  151. Made these tonight with two little girls, and they turned out perfectly! Did a powdered sugar dusting and they look great for the Christmas cookie platter. Used half regular cocoa powder, half fancy cocoa, fyi. Thanks for the great recipe!

  152. Hillary

    Yum. Just made these for my work cookie exchange and they’re great. I know the beauty is supposed to be in the simplicity, but I iced them and sprinkled them with crushed candy canes. Really yummy and great texture, though I do wish I’d splurged for better cocoa powder.

  153. Penny

    Made these today with Christmas cookie cutters. The dough is amazing to work with as it doesn’t stick like a lot of other cookie dough recipe. Can’t wait to make these for every holiday, thanks for the great recipe :)

  154. I baked these today, and they are yummy. I actually made the dough several days ago and kept it in the icebox. It rolled out wonderfully. I chose these to be my toddler twins’ first experience making their own food. They loved it, and they totally understood that *they* cut the cookies and then got to eat them. It was great.

    Also to note, I made these gluten-free. I substituted a gluten-free flour mix and it was fine. I also substituted finely milled raw sugar for the refined sugar, just personal preference. I will make them again, but I will use a better quality cocoa. I couldn’t find the good stuff.

    Thank you for sharing this recipe!

  155. Sue

    Hi Deb- Just wanted to let you know I made these, used 1/3 cup black cocoa and 1/3 cup regular- yum- taste like oreos!! Not sure if this is how they taste anyway, but man, they are great!

  156. elvee

    This recipe is AWESOME… My children don’t like gingerbread, so I used this to make a “Chocolate bread” house for Christmas… worked perfectly and was devoured by adults and kids alike… Thanks, it will be a traditional thing for us now….(I can send a pic if you would like to see the results)

  157. Betsy

    Oh wow. These were DELICIOUS. However, I ran into the same problem several others readers faced – my dough was ridiculously dry. I re-read the recipe several times over, but I knew I had followed it accurately. Although dry, the batter tasted pretty good, so I decided to try something instead of scrapping it: – I took about half of the uber dry batter out (because my KitchenAid was not liking how dry the mixture was)
    – Mixed in about 1-1.5 Tbs softened butter, and a whole beaten egg (all the eggs I used were large) until fully incorporated
    – Added the other half of the batter back and followed the baking instructions as written

    They turned out fabulously; they’re quite possibly my new favorite cookies.

    Other things I did –
    (1) They didn’t need them, but I added some finely chopped 80% chocolate pieces to half the batch – soooo good when they were warm with little bits of melted chocolate!
    (2) Used 1/3 c regular Hershey’s cocoa powder and 1/3 c Hershey’s Special Dark cocoa powder – I’ve been doing this with all of my recipes and like the extra chocolate-y-ness.

  158. hi deb! i was going to bake boring old chocolate chip cookies tonight, but i think i’ll make these instead – thanks :) but maybe i’ll ice them, to make them a bit more decorative.

  159. Jenn SF Bay Area

    These cookies are beyond amazing! I was so excited about finding this recipe last night that I couldn’t sleep. For my son’s school bakesale today, I wanted a cookie that I could use a cookie cutter with but I didn’t want to make regular sugar cookies. This was perfect! This dough was the easiest, most forgiving dough that I’ve ever worked with. I didn’t stray from your instructions other than I have a super hot oven so 7 minutes was perfect for me. To make them a little more interesting for the kids, I made a 1/2 batch of your homemade Oreo cookie filling—-this amount was perfect for the amount of cookies that were made. I sandwiched them together and I’m positive they’ll be a hit at the school!! The only disappointment: This batch isn’t for me!!!! I might have to do it all again tonight and keep them for myself. Such chocolatey dangerousness!!! Thank you a million times over!!!

  160. Phyllis Katzen

    I think i have a helpful hint. Instead of rolling the scraps out over and over on flour and worry about them getting too hard from all the flour, i rolled them out once on a floured board, then took the scraps and put them between a large piece of folded over cellophane, then rolled over the cellophane, nothing sticks, roller is clean. I did roll the scraps together and put back in frig. to harden up before i rolled each batch, but it worked well.

  161. Naomi

    I made these for the first time this weekend, and I too ran into the problem of a slightly crumbly dough (it certainly did NOT look like your picture). I’m not sure what caused the consistency to be this way (maybe my hand mixer?), but I found that working the dough with my hands (in small portions) helped it to hold together. I was then able to roll it and cut the cookies. I also found that underbaking them slightly helped to give them the a chewy texture, although they didn’t seem to be as soft as you described…luckily my 3 year-old nephew loved them anyway!

  162. Lauren

    Made these cookies with a friend last night. Decided spur the moment to make vanilla buttercream frosting and made some cookies sandwiches. Best decision ever. These cookies are delicious on their own, but with the frosting they are over the top! Like a oreo, but a million times better!

  163. Danielle

    My batter is in the fridge as we speak and i cannot WAIT to make them! I was so afraid when i was making it because the batter was kinda sticky and stinking to the mixer, but i came on here and read all the comments and saw the picture and was relieved that it is suppose to do that and i am SOOOO excited!! Will report back after i make them! Has anyone ever decorated them with icing? Any suggestions or ideas? After they are made– how long will they last for? i Plan on doing them tonight but need them for saturday– think they will still be good if i put them in tupperware?

  164. Pam Loeb

    Tried the Brownie Roll-Out Cookies three days ago and a big thank you to you and your Mom for the recipe. So easy and so delicious!

  165. Deanne

    I made groundhog cutout and football shaped cookies, Received so many compliments on how delicious your recipe is. Thank you for posting!!

  166. Heather

    I just wanted to thank you for this recipe. I am a huge foodie and Culinary School grad. I loved them so much I am making my second batch in one night. Perfect for Valentines Day cookies dipped in White and Dark Chocolate. I have searched high and low constantly trying new recipe and these have hit the spot. My Chocolate Sugar Cookie Mission is over. Thanks again!

  167. Heidi

    Delicious! I have tried making chocolate sugar cookies in the past and they were terrible – definately not chocolatey enough. I think your title fits perfectly. I baked a tray last night and ate three for breakfast. I rolled and cut the rest of the dough and froze the cookies. Do I need to let them come to room temp before baking or can they be baked straight from the freezer with an additional few minutes? Any suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks!

  168. carrie

    I was determine to make these cookies even though I discovered that I had (a) not quite enough butter (b) not quite enough flour (c) no rolling pin. And then I accidentally cooked them the entire time on broil instead of bake! The results? Delicious! These cookies turned out to be (thankfully) idiot proof!

  169. Miss Kelli

    I was looking for a recipe just like this one, thank you so much for sharing. i am now heading straight to the kitchen to make me some deliciousness!

  170. Linda

    Love these cookies!!! Made them yesterday as a test and was so pleased I turned around and made a double batch this afternoon. They held their shape, were tender yet firm, and pleasing to taste without any topping but a very nice canvas for those who wish to be creative. Yummy! Thanks for sharing!!

  171. Lynette

    I made these cookies as a base for ice cream sandwiches, as recommended in your original post. I made both vanilla and coffee sandwiches and they were a huge hit! I had extra cookies left over and they were gobbled down rapid-fire at a family reunion. The basic cookie itself is durable (and nicely transportable), yet soft (like the word “brownie” in the name implies). Thank you for the recipe — I’m sure I will be making them again!

  172. amber

    WOW! i made sandwich cookies with an orange creme filling (incl. orange flower water, a bit of juice from an orange and zest!) for a potluck and they were a HUGE success. everyone was especially delighted that they weren’t sickly sweet. thanks for the recipe – it’s definitely a keeper and i made SO MANY i was able to freeze some for me and my husband later!

    deb, i’m so excited to have found your site, and i’m definitely adding it as a fave!

  173. Marisa

    I’ve made these a few times, and because they’re so easy, decided they’d be the perfect addition to my 4th of July spread. I cut them out with star-shaped cookie cutters and made sandwiches with cream cheese frosting. Then. I decorated the sides with red & blue sprinkles for a festive presentation. Tasty & pretty!

  174. Ann

    I was searching for a “chocolate sugar cookie” recipe for my son’s Star Wars themed Birthday Party. I am planning to make Darth Vader cookies using a Darth Vader cookie cuter. This recipe sounds like it might be the one… especially since I am planning on serving the cookie as a topper for an ice cream sundae. With the slightly soft texture, they will go so much better with the ice cream than the a hard sugar cookie. My only question and concern is, do you think this cookie would take well to cookie cutters with detailed imprints? I purchased the William Sonoma Star Wars cookie cutters and they are the type of cutters that have all of the fancy facial details, etc. Thank you for posting the recipe! Can’t wait to try it out.

  175. I baked these cookies today with my kids, but when my son was reading the recipe to me, he skipped the “chill for an hour” part, so we didn’t do that and they turned out great. What does the chilling do? Does it change the texture or moisture level or is it just to make them easier to roll/cut?

    Ours were a tad on the dry/crunchy side, so that’s why I’m asking, but we had no trouble rolling them out and cutting them. We’re decorating them with buttercream and they’re so yummy!

  176. Amanda C.

    My mom and I just made these and they came out so dry. :( They’re not too bad tasting but we wound up having to make little balls because the dough just wouldn’t roll. I followed the recipe to a tee so I’m not sure what happened. :(

  177. Sarah

    These look really delicious. I dont have any unsweetned cocoa but would unsweetened cocoa powder work? If not what could I use to substitute it?

  178. klara

    How long the cookies will be good & should i store it in refrigerator? i was thinking to put some royal icing for decoration too.. i wanna try it :)

    Regards, klara

  179. Teresa

    I had a question! I’ve made these cookies before and they were super wonderful, but I recently I bought a really cute cookie tin sheet with different shapes that you press the cookie dough into, and I was wondering if this recipe would still work as well? I really hope that it does! Any suggestions?

  180. Teresa

    Ok, so I tried baking these cookies in the press-into-different-shapes-sheet I bought and it didn’t go so well. It’s hard to gauge how think the dough should be in the little moulds! Thankfully, I had a backup plan and just used some cookie cutters I bought when I ran out for more flour! I want to try again with a little less dough and flatten it out even more in the little moulds.

    Regardless of the derpy shapes I had, everyone loved the cookies. Super delicious as always!

  181. Eve

    wow – i chose this recipe as my first-time-ever attempt at making cookies and they turned out ah-mazing!

    As i had never baked before i was a little nervous when it came to handling the dough (fear of tough cookies!) and since i don’t have a mixer, i was also a bit nervous regarding doing everything by hand.

    Seriously, I could not be happier with the outcome. These cookies are delicious, soft and thick and the dough is perfect cut-outs. My boyfriend, who had never made cookies before, couldn’t have been more excited. We really spent most of our Sunday afternoon decorating the cookies like 5 year olds.

    Can’t wait to make these again!

  182. Anne

    Love the simplicity! and the taste.. Since I’m allergic to dairy and eggs I replaced the butter for vegetable margarine, used egg replacer instead of eggs and doubled the amount of baking power (I find egg replacer doesn’t quite do the job on its own). They turned out great and are exactly as you descibe them! Since I’m Dutch I did use ofcourse Dutch cocoa!

  183. Arti

    I made this yesterday came together so quickly with what I had in hand. I used Valhrona cocoa and just used the roll and cut technique.The shapes were a little mishappen, but using a serrated knife helped. My husband was craving brownies and he was surprised to see something on a weekday. They tasted heavenly with a glass of cold milk. Its a good thing I just baked up a few. Otherwise I can never get out of the gym.
    Thanks again for a wonderful recipe..P.S: we are planning up another Smitten thanksgiving for this year.

  184. Renee

    I am looking for a good chocolate sugar cookie recipe and this one looks great. A question to those who have made them, are the cookies firm enough to decorate with royale icing and individually bag, like a regular sugar cookie?

  185. Sharon Chak

    Hi Smitten Kitch,
    The cookies were delish…. slightly salter and sweeter than we liked but still chewy and soft.

    One disclaimer with this “recette” is that the batter ends up being quite crumbly and it is hard to roll properly and then make the cookie cut outs. Please advise.

    P.S. We mixed the cocoa into the dry ingred list instead of the wet one, so maybe that made a difference.

    1. deb

      Hi Sharon — I’ve never had trouble rolling these out (I made them again just last week.) though the crumbly-ness of a dough can be affected even by the way flour is placed in a cup — I tend to scoop and sweep, getting cups of flour that weigh 125 grams. Hope that helps.

  186. Amy

    These are amazing … I loved chocolate fudge pop-tarts when I was little and the cookies taste just how I remember those did … Thanks for the recipe!

  187. Lulu

    These are awesome! I made three of your recipes for my holiday gifts (these plus the Nutmeg Maple Cookies & Pecan Sandies), and all three worked out beautifully. I have to say, sometimes roll/cut-out doughs can be a bear to handle, but all three of these were a piece of cake. You made my cookie baking much more pleasant than past years!

  188. Laura

    almost done baking these for an upcoming Hanukkah party. amazing! i generally find myself getting super frustrated rolling out cookies but these were a dream. now trying to decide how to decorate them. so yummy!

  189. Jenny

    I’ve made this cookies twice and they are amazing! This time I used them as “ginger bread man” because I don’t really like ginger cookies. Also this time I added a tsp. of cinnamon. I’m Mexican and chocolate without cinnamon is not the same. They turned out delicious. I might try to add a bit of spice next time ;)
    Thanks for yet another great recipe!

  190. Amy

    I made a batch last week and froze the dough. I took out of the freezer last night planning to bake today but I can’t until Thursday morning. Will the dough stay ok in the fridge until then?

  191. Amy

    Btw, they came out fine. The dough that was thawed and refrozen was maybe a little crumbly when rolling and cutting but they still tasted great in the end.

  192. Ella

    I made these for a Hanukkah celebration tonight and they were a big hit :) This is a great recipe because my boyfriend is always buying me random cookie cutters but its hard to find roll-out cookies soft enough for my taste. This will definitely be going in my brand-new personal recipe book!

  193. Katie M.

    The consistency when I mixed these up seemed just right, but after refrigerating the dough I had the same problem as others. It was rock hard and very crumbly. I ended up rolling it into balls and pressing them with a fork like peanut butter cookies, baked them for 11 minutes and they were delicious. I would be happy to make these again, and if I want to roll them out I’ll just skip the refrigeration.

  194. Diana

    Made these tonight, and, as I am lazy, after refrigerating the dough I rolled it into balls and then flattened them with a floured bottom of a glass.

    Came out wonderful, and now the only problem is resisting eating the whole pan! I like my cookies to be moist and soft, no matter what kind they are, and these did not disappoint! Thank you!

  195. Justine

    Yummmm! These are amazing. I had a short day at school and decided to celebrate the end of finals week and semester 1 with cookies and these fit the bill! Thank you so much for the recipe and for making my finals happier!!

  196. Melissa

    Deb, So I made the recipe just as it said but when I rolled them out they crumble and I can’t do anything with the dough. What do I do?

  197. Cat

    I loved working with this dough – and the cookies are very tasty! I used cocoa with some Dutch processed cocoa in it, as I didn’t want them to be too bitter. And I didn’t need to adjust it for high altitude (much… I added about 1/2 cup extra flour so that it wouldn’t stick to the beater), and the baking time was perfect for this elevation (7220 ft). Only one or two cookies puffed too much for being able to flood with corn syrup icing or royal icing. I’m eager to see how they’ll hold up in shipping, though, as right now they’re kind of soft. If it doesn’t look like they’ll ship well, I know someone in this house who will happily accommodate making them disappear.

  198. Heather

    I just made these for Valentines day. Yum. Your recipes are amazing.
    A few things: First, I partially flatten out the dough before refrigerating. Easier to finish rolling them than from a chilled ball of dough.
    Second, I rolled the dough out between two pieces of parchment, so no need for any flour. I do this trick with pie crust and other rolled cookies too.
    Last, the dough was rock hard after refrigerating. It was a lot of work to roll it out, even from the partially rolled out slab. Next time I will refrigerate for 15-20 minutes and then check to see if it’s firm enough. Otherwise, I guess you have to let it sit out for a bit.

  199. Emily

    these aRE lovely valentines cookies. i wondered, anybody have a recommendation for an icing with which to decorate these? maybe it’s sacreligious, but I’m craving something else with these cookies…makes sense to me these are sort of a with-ice-cream cookie (though I’ve been eating them plenty on their own) — anyway, what icing/frosting would be good do we think? It would also be pretty, right, something white or pastel on the dark dark cookie?

  200. I just made these, and I really love them. The dough is so tender and easy to work with, and the taste and texture are perfect. This would be a great dough to make into a log and stash in the freezer to keep for last-minute company. Thanks for sharing it!

  201. Arti

    Deb’s mom- thank you. I have already made these 4 times so far in the last 2 months. My husband refuses to share these and we eat them as dinner. (6 tiny ones with a glass of cold milk). Oh the joys of adulthood!

  202. Caroline E

    I tried rolling these both thin and thick and the consensus in my house is that thick is much better! They are a little plain on their own for my tastes, but they made excellent ice cream sandwiches. Next time I would dust them with powdered sugar or maybe drizzle them with some type of chocolate or frosting. I could also see these as jam sandwich cookies with raspberry jam and some almond flavoring in the dough!

  203. Marta

    Thick is definitely better, but the name “brownie rollout cookies” set my expectations higher than was met. This is a very basic tasting cookie, sort of like a shortbread though not as buttery as good shortbread… Yes, I agree these would make great ice cream sandwiches, but as a standalone I’m not sure they were worth all the rolling. I used a really expensive organic cocoa, too, so that wasn’t the issue. Hmm. They did seriously create a cold milk craving!

  204. Ray

    Has anyone tried to stamp these cookies? I have cookie cutters that also have a design with which to stamp the cookies. I am wondering if these puff up too much for that kind of detail to stay visible.

    1. deb

      Hi Ray — For stamp cookies, I’d roll them thinner. Growing up, we’d make them with a stamp-style cookie cutter (before they were spring-loaded and easier to use, sigh) and they held the marks pretty well. Not as well as a cookie without baking powder, but clearly enough.

  205. Claudia

    Just wondering if the mixture can be left in the fridge overnight in a big clump or if I should cut out the shapes and put them in the freezer like you recommended in your comments 18 and 59? Thanks :)

  206. So so love these! Returning to reprint because I misplaced my first. One of my go-to cookies. Yes, they hold stamping well (I’ve just used other smaller cookie cutters to make an imprint for birthday party theme…ie: R/R on a circle for train crossing, or the birthday girl’s initials). I like them especially with some fine piped royal icing detailing or sandwiching mint frosting. We definitely like them thick and soft.

  207. Tania

    I made these for a playschool party and they were a hit. I used 170g unsalted butter and added a pinch of salt, and stirred/mixed with a wooden spoon, not a mixer, which was fine. Refrigerated for an hour before rolling, then again before the next batch (got too soft as it’s hot where I live). I used small animal and shape cookie cutters and the recipe made 94 cookies! Then glazed them (3 cups icing sugar, 3-4 Tbsp hot water and 1 1/2 tsp lemon juice) with different colours. They were chewy and tasty! Thank you!

  208. Tania

    Maybe why some people’s dough comes out crumbly: I have 2 measuring cups, and one measures a cup at about 110-113 grams, the other measures a cup at 145-158 grams (a 2-cup measuring cup, so also wider). I use the smaller cup to make recipes.

  209. Dez

    I actually did get frustrated with the dry ingredients in the middle of the recipe because I just couldn’t get the wet and dry ingredients to meld together. So I actually added maybe about two tablespoons of milk and the dough still came out firm enough to rollout cookies, just in case anyone was wondering. But anyways the cookies are delicious! My favorite chocolate cookies by far.

  210. Melissa

    I would like to bake these for my daughter’s birthday party to stake into the centerpiece foam. Can they be baked on a stick or are they too soft to stay on?

  211. Chris

    Fantastic website! You are just the person for my long standing question. Some 30 yrs ago when I was in HS the “lunch Ladies” made their own cookies. I will never forget them and to this day have never had one like it. they were chewy chocolate brownie cookies. They looked like they were baked in a muffin top pan. they were so dense that you could hold the cookie in the palm of your hand, make a fist and the cookie would actually stay formed with ridges that show your finger joints and peaks that divided your fingers. I have not been able to find the right ingredients to make cookies so dense and pliable with such chocolatey goodnes. I hope my description was able to do justice to such goodness. Thank you for your wonderful contributions to comfort food. YUM!

  212. Chris

    The closest consistency to these famous chewy brownie cookies that I have experienced has been the 1/2″ edges of some brownies. any suggestions or references you have would be fantastic. Thank you.

  213. Rania

    I made these cookies an hour ago I didn’t have any problem with them..they looked very nice and soft even when I took a bite from one they looked like the one in your picture.thank you for this very yummy recipe

  214. Karen

    I had always steered away from cut out cookies because of their texture and snappiness, because I much prefer softer brownie type cookies. But the kids want to make cut out cookies for Xmas and my son loves chocolate, so these sound like address all my issues with cut out cookies. Can’t wait to make them now. Thanks!

  215. Karen

    So I made the cookies yesterday. The dough was fine to work with ( I only chilled for 20 mins) . They cooked beautifully ( although mine took 12 mins) and tasted great. I could see how they would be perfect for ice cream sandwiches. Next time I’m going to add some chic chunks.

  216. Anna

    I tried to make these today, followed the recipie as it was.. Not sure what went
    wrong but my cookie dough was very crumbly and was not smooth what so ever!!! Has anyone else experience the same issue??

  217. Laura

    I was wondering if you think there is any problem with freezing the dough in balls, rather than pre-cut the cookies, then roll out and bake when you need them (my freezer is just too crowded for flash freezing…..

    1. deb

      Hi Laura — No problem at all. My freezer is tiny as well. I stack the trays (usually clearing out a shelf long enough to freeze the cookies; not long enough for anything essential to defrost or get ruined) turning each a little so that they don’t nest into each other and it doesn’t usually take long for them to get firm enough that they can be moved to a freezer bag. I do it this way so that they’re ready to bake whenever the craving strikes. Just sharing the tips in case that helps you navigate your freezer, too!

  218. Melanie

    I made this recipe for a party last night and they were a smash hit! I think next time I may add a little bit of chili to make them a Mayan brownie roll out cookie – for a twist. Thanks, Deb!

  219. Paty

    I’m sure this is the dummiest question EVER but I have to do it… When you speak of 350 degrees, are they Fahreneit or Celsius. I don’t expect you to answer (more likely you will laugh at me) but I’m from Spain and once had a really bad experience with a friend’s recipe, temperature and some cupcakes :(

    Really, I can’t wait to try such a great recipe.

  220. Thanks Deb! This recipe was exactly what I was looking for and the cookies turned out delicious. I am not a regular backer, but you make it so easy and fun! I hope it’s OK that I wrote about this recipe in my blog, with a link to yours, of course. I have just started a craft blog and you are truly an inspiration.

  221. aubrey

    Hi! I have a quick question. I didn’t scroll through every single comment so I don’t know if it has been asked or not… I want to make these cookies, but I need to freeze them since I’m not making them until a week from now. Do I just freeze the hunk of dough? Flatten it and then freeze it? Freeze it in sections? Can I bake the cookies and then freeze them?

  222. Simone


    I really want to make these! How long do they last once they are done? I want to make them for a Christmas party but I would also love to have some to bring somewhere a few days later. Do you think they will last a few days?
    Thanks so much!

    1. deb

      Hi Ilona — Normally I’d say a day or two, and longer, you should keep it in the fridge. But last week, I made the dough on Monday and didn’t get to rolling them out until late Friday afternoon and it was fine, fine, fine. Ideally, though, you’d want to do it for less time. I was taking a risk that may not work if your eggs or butter or luck is less fresh. ;)

  223. Ilona

    Okay, good to know! Thanks, Deb. They are the second recipe I’m trying from your cookbook, and I’m sure I won’t be dissapointed. They’re next in line to go into my Christmas cookie tins, joining your coffee toffee.

  224. Lori w

    I made these for the holidays this year and did them as slice and bake instead of rolling them. I also sandwiched two with chocolate ganache and crushed peppermint. Wonderful cookie, thank you. They have become a requested item already

  225. Elle

    I actually read almost all of these comments, before deciding to try these today. I was most concerned about these cookies being too dry or crumbly. I like the idea of something retro-my mom always had hershey cocoa as well. (That moist hershey cocoa cake made with oil and hot water can’t be best for simple, foolproof, chocolate goodness).

    So, I haven’t rolled these out yet, and made a few changes. I halved the recipe. I didn’t want to roll out five dozen cookies. But I made a mistake, and put in the regular amount of cocoa (2/3 cup). I also had fresh orange zest (1-2 tsp) left over from my regular sugar cookie recipe I make every Christmas. I also used closer to one tsp of baking powder. I added about a tablespoon of plain, non fat greek yogurt, to compensate for the extra cocoa. I find that a small amount of yogurt helps with texture in other things I’ve made.

    I used the “creaming” method of mixing, creaming the butter/sugar, then adding egg, vanilla, (yogurt), orange zest, then adding the (combined first) dry ingredients. The batter crumbled up nicely, had the right amount of moisture, molded perfectly into flattened saran wrapped disks, just as well as the sugar and gingerbread cookies I made earlier today. They are very, very chocolatey, and I like the addition of orange flavor. (Lindt dark chocolate with orange bits is my favorite chocolate bar).

    I’m very confident they will work out: even rolling them out with kids, because the texture is like the other butter cutout cookies I make. Will let you know if these alterations don’t do well after rolling out and baking. But they taste incredible!!

  226. Timothy

    Hi Deb,

    This is the third recipe we’ve tried from your Smitten Kitchen cookbook – the chicken with olive & grapes was fantastic, and the brisket is in the slow cooker right now.

    I’m not sure what I did wrong, but the cookies came out sort of chalky tasting. I rolled them out a bit thinner (we’re having them with home made honey vanilla ice cream tomorrow) – probably close to 1/8 inch. I cooked the first batch for 9.5 minutes, and the second batch for 8. The texture isn’t a problem – they’re right at that sweet spot between crunchy and chewy, but the taste is sort of… bland. Any thoughts on what I might have done? I used a new canister of unsweetened cocoa from Whole Foods, and I’m pretty sure I used 2/3 cup (always second guess myself though)…

    Thanks so much!

  227. Peg

    AWESOME cookies! I brought these to a party a couple weeks ago, and they were a huge hit. I used some ultra-dark cocoa I had laying around; that made these, IMHO, even better. A transcendent brownie-cookie experience!

  228. Emily

    In my gas oven, I had to shorten the baking time significantly to prevent drying out the cookies. At 7 minutes for 1/4 inch thick cookies I had nice fudginess. Longer than that and the cookies were dry. The fudgy cookies are SOOO GOOOOOD!!

  229. I made these for christmas, took them to a party and stealthily took the leftovers home as I left early. Is that bad of me? They were just sooo good. I couldn’t bear these cookie-haters (they practically didn’t touch the cut outs) left with the goods. I don’t think I’m a bad person, deep down I hope you’d do the same Deb :)

  230. Ashby

    These are lovely. I made them with two assistants under the age of six and was pleased to find the dough nice and easy to roll out, and very forgiving. We “glued” a little flowershaped cookie onto the top of a bigger flower with a bit of ganache and it was stellar.

  231. Jodi

    I used this recipe to try out my new Batman cookie cutter, they’re absolutely delicious! They remind me of the biscuit on the icecream sandwiches I used to get when I was little (icebergers) ,combined with a bourbon cream biscuit. And they look pretty snazzy might I add ;)

  232. Cher

    I just made these from the recipe in your book (which is AMAZING btw) and my mom and I can’t stop eating them. So, I HATE you for these cookies, but I also love you. We have a difficult relationship dynamic. I bet you didn’t even know you were in a relationship with a terrible baker from Chicago! Seriously enough, THANK YOU for this recipe!

    1. deb

      Juanita — I’ve never tried — I’m not sure they’re the spreading type that would work with that technique but it can’t hurt to try a few that way and see what happens. You could also chill the dough into tube shape and slice off cookies, to avoid rolling.

  233. Amy

    I made these yesterday and cut them into footballs and then piped white icing lines on top. They tasted fantastic and were very easy to put together. I will definitely make them again and try them for homemade ice cream sandwiches. Thanks a bunch for sharing.

  234. RK

    Do you have an estimation of how much salt to use? I only use unsalted butter and would like to avoid buying a whole pack of salted without a use for them.

  235. Pat

    I plan on making these tomorrow- heart shaped and partially dipped in tempered bittersweet chocolate! Love cookies…. I read with interest the comments from some regarding dry dough. It could be due to the type of butter used. Butters have varying moisture contents and can significantly effect the consistency of a cookie dough. I’ve been burned by buying inexpensive butters. They seem to have the highest moisture content and lead to a wet dough requiring more flour. I use an organic butter and hope that my dough will not be dry like some experienced. Certainly the way the flour is measured comes into play and is probably the biggest factor in dough consistency. I really wish that everyone that posts recipes would use weights, along with standard measurements. Baking would be so much more consistent. I made the salted caramel brownies today. I’ll post some comments on that recipe.

  236. Oh my goodness. I just made this from the recipe in your cookbook, and they are so good. Both of my roommates gave a post-first-bite gasp–this is what chocolate lovers are looking for. You’re right, Deb. They look like “Chocolate Sugar Cookies,” but they taste more like “Brownie Knockout Cookies,” or something along those lines.

  237. Charlotte

    Made these today to surprise my kids for Valentines Day! They are SO good — everyone who’s wondering, they DO taste as good as the pictures make them look! I used King Arthur’s white whole wheat flour, as I always do with baked goods. They’re moist, sweet and very chocolatey. My favorite thing was how easy they are , without lots of bowls and extra hassle. Just mix, chill and cut out!

  238. Lena

    This is a cookie-science question – WHY are these so easy to roll and is there a non-chocolate sugar cookie recipe that is similar? I’ll do some experimenting, but I thought I would ask. Is it the cocoa?

  239. Sara

    Just had these at a reception last night and they were DELICIOUS! Had to ask for the recipe and this is where I was sent… can’t wait to try making them myself!!! So, so good. And now you tempt me with ice cream sandwiches, holy moly. Hope we get that ice cream maker I registered for as a wedding gift! :)

  240. I finally made these cookies after wanting to make them for the longest time, and I am so glad I did. These are delicious, and were a dream to roll out and cut. I was worried about the dough being crumbly but they turned out perfect. Thank you (and your mom) for this wonderful recipe!

  241. Audrey

    I am doing a Bridal Shower tea and the bride loves anything Chocolate and peanut butter. Would these work to sandwich together with peanut butter frosting in the middle making tiny sandwich cookies for the shower or are they too thick?

  242. Jeannette

    I only recently ‘found’ your blog and have been avidly reading as many of your recipes as I have time for, and as baking is my passion I clicked on to the ‘cookie’ section. I thought these sounded interesting and seemed to have a huge response so I tried them out on Sunday. I just rolled out half of the dough and made them quite thin, the dough behaved very well and looked just like yours so I was pleased. They baked up very well too, no spreading, keeping their shape well. However, I wasn’t that impressed with the taste, sorry! HOWEVER, today I rolled out the rest of the dough and this time made them thicker, what a difference! Much nicer and well worth making again, and again….

  243. I just made these today, cut into little shamrocks and topped with peppermint icing for St. Patrick’s Day. Quite tasty! They didn’t puff up at all but maybe it’s because they were cut so small. I’d make them again, for sure. Thanks!

  244. Ania

    Great cookies. I used the recipe in your book, so I weighted all my ingredients. They turned out amazing. I froze half the amount and they were great cooked straight from frozen. They are definitely nicer rolled out thicker, more brownieish if that makes sense.

  245. Miranda

    I made these cookies last week. They were super easy to make and delicious! Even my non-cookie loving husband loved these :-) I totally see how they would be great for ice-cream sandwiches since they have such a nice soft texture.

    I baked about a third of the dough the afternoon I made them, then froze the rest (rolled and cut) and baked a second batch a few days later. I found that they froze very well, just as Deb promised. I did notice that the freshly baked, non-frozen batch tasted a little more chocolatey, and the frozen ones spread a little more during cooking (despite same oven, same temp, 2 minutes added to cooking time since baking from frozen). But the frozen ones came out great and were very much enjoyed too. Will definitely be making these again!

  246. Whoooo. These are fantastic. And love that they’re low-fuss, too. Rolling and cutting always seems like such a pain, but this dough is really easy to deal with! I’m planning on dipping the bottom in tempered chocolate!

  247. Sally

    I’m guessing, but I think that NYC has a much more humid climate than a lot of the rest of the country. Anyone having trouble with dry dough should probably keep that in mind. As, don’t add all the flour until you see how the dough is behaving. That said, our 20% humidity and these cookies sliced, not rolled, were exceptionally good!

  248. Sofia

    Made these cookies for Valentine’s Day in a heart shape and iced them with some pretty patterns. They came out great! Both my sweetheart and roommates loved them.

  249. Lauren

    I made these from the cookbook last night, and they are fabulous! I used a cookie press, so they kind of resemble a chocolate spritz cookie–very cute. The dough was a great consistency for the press, and I just baked them for a bit less time (~6min). Everyone at work today loves them!

  250. Tash

    Made these today and they came out great! As others have said, the dough is easier to mix by kneading a bit at the end, and it is very easy and quick to press the cookies with a glass if you don’t have the time or desire to roll out the dough.

  251. Hi there ~ I made these cookies this past weekend and they were SOOOO yummy! Definitely adding this to my most loved recipes. I blogged about them today, and I linked to you.

    Thanks for sharing the yummy recipe!

  252. Peggy

    Attempting these with my three year old today. Pretty sure it’s going to be a messy endeavor but surely worth it if these taste as good as they look!

  253. AK

    What is the maximum amount of time I can chill the dough? I ask because I’d like to make the dough one night and bake them the next night to bring into a meeting the following morning. Is 24hrs chilling too much? Thanks for any info about this!

  254. Martha in KS

    My niece & I used this recipe to make moustache-shaped cookies for the launch of her PhotoBus. I added two packets of instant Sanka and they were delicious! Thank your mom for her recipe.

  255. Kathryn

    I should know by now just to come here first, when I’m looking for a specific type of recipe. I googled “chocolate cut-out cookies” because I need to make some for a Batman theme party…..and what do you know, I happily ended up on Smitten Kitchen again. Brilliant! Thanks as always!

  256. Tasha

    My friends and I are arguing about whether or not you took a bite out of the cookie in the final image or used a cookie cutter to make it look like you had – they claim the bite mark is too clean to be real, I claim you simply cleaned away the crumbs. Could you please clear this up for us?

  257. deb

    I absolutely took a bite! No way I would let a cookie cutter have all the fun. The cookie doesn’t leave a lot of crumbs, either way, I probably picked it up to take a bite so any crumbs would be … on the floor?

  258. Jess

    Made these tonight, and am leaving them to chill overnight. The dough seemed very dry so I added a small bit of water to the mixture to help mix the liquids and dry ingredients together. Will be making your pumpkin pie and crust this weekend. Have you tried to create some Gluten Free recipes? Would love to know some :-)

  259. These are wonderful! I just got some fun cookie cutters from Ikea – moose, bear, hedgehog, etc. This was perfect for them, and lots of little hedgehog brownie cookies are cooling on a rack in the kitchen right now. Or they were a moment ago, I imagine that they are going to disappear rather quickly!

  260. Joanna Banana

    Hi! I is made these and they’re definitely very, very dry. They were crumbling as I rolled out the dough. I noticed in your book you show them being mixed in a stand mixer. I did it with a hand mixer which had the typical whisk beaters. Would this effect the texture or do you think I went wrong somewhere? Any advice would be greatly appreciated as I want to love these! Maybe I should put a smidge more butter or a smidge less flour? I used Hershey’s cocoa. IDK if this makes a difference.

    1. deb

      Joanna — They don’t need to be made with a stand mixer. Often in cookies, dryness can come from either overbaking or using too much flour (i.e. packing cups of flour tightly, rather than fluffing-and-sweeping or spoon-and-sweeping). Did you make them 1/4-inch thick? The hallmark of this cookie is that when thin, it’s just another sugar cookie but when rolled a full 1/4-inch thick and baked just until done, it should be firm on the outside and hold its shape perfectly, but taste tender-soft-brownielike inside. I hope that helps.

  261. Sarah

    These came out perfect!I did use a stand mixer and I chilled overnight, and rolled between wax paper. The dough had a very nice smooth texture and was very easy to work with. I decorated them with a powdeed sugar glaze and some with milk or white chocolate to have a variety. I cut them at 1/4 inch, baked 9 min, cooled on the pan and they are brownie like- I will be making another batch soon!

  262. Ida

    FYI — makes about 3 dozen 3.5″ squirrels (with mini M&M’s for eyes), and the dough can be gathered up, rerolled and cut — doesn’t seem to affect the final texture, which is marvelous! Thanks!

  263. dawn

    These are in the fridge chilling, along with some soft gingerbread cookie batter and some regular sugar cookie batter. My sweet boy, (who is actually a man of 24) requested sugar cookie baking…says it’s his favorite holiday tradition. Can’t wait to try them as cutout cookies and maybe next time as icecream sandwiches. Thanks so much for sharing and special thanks to Deb’s mom for sharing as well.

  264. Stephanie

    I have made these twice now, Halloween & Christmas, and LOVE them. Most recently, I made them with small (2in) Christmas shaped cookie cutters. They are so cute! I cut the baking time to 5 minutes and they are perfect. I refrigerated the dough over night to use in the morning. It is easiest to separate it into 2 balls and flatten before refrigerating. Then, you just have to let it sit out a bit before rolling. The dough becomes more pliable as you go. Also, if you are flouring the surface, the cookies rolled out at the end will be on the drier side. Just sprinkle with a bit of water. I also have glazed them with a simple mix of powdered sugar, milk, and vanilla. Thanks so much! I was once anti-rolled cookie, but no more! :)

  265. Margaret

    I just made these! After chilling, I decided I wasn’t up to rolling out the dough so I scooped it, rolled it into balls, and used my cookie stamps to flatten. They turned out wonderfully after baking for 10 minutes. (Except the Santa face cookie stamp is very, very creepy.)

  266. Carrie

    Wow, I made these last night after chilling in the fridge from Saturday. I had to let them sit a bit because the outdoor fridge must be really cold. I couldn’t roll these out. lol! But once they warmed up the dough is beautiful to work with. I love the flavor of them, you think hmmmm, then once the flavor of the chocolate hits your taste buds the magic happens. I’m going to make a few ice cream sandwiches tonight and a few with cool whip and freeze.

    I have a family recipe for Bavarian Cream Pie, it calls for the Nabisco Choc. Wafers. I wonder if I bake these a bit longer to get them crispy, I could use them in the crust?

    Thank you for sharing another great recipe!

  267. dawn

    I’ve made a couple of batches of these. Made one batch as directed, 1/4 inch thick. Perfect cookie! Re-rolled the re-rollers thinner 1/8 inch and used a linzer cutter. Baked at 8 minutes. OMG Words can’t describe how cute and yummy. Raspberry filling… and the little center shapes (trees, candy canes and snowmen) make perfect elf sized mini cookies! You NEED to try the mini cookies… seriously.

  268. April

    These are fantastic. I’m not a huge fan of butter or sugar cookies, but I wanted to do roll out cookies with my kids. Since November we have made at least four batches of them. I am about to do #5 to cut and decorate as Despicable Me Minion Cookies for my daughter’s birthday at school. (Santa got Minion cookies too) I agree with Dawn above as well, we made 4 dozen mini cookies out of these as well for class parties over the holidays and they were a hit. They keep their shape PERFECTLY.

  269. Another fantastic recipe from your cookbook/blog! Loved the simplicity (as I had all the ingredients right in my kitchen) and how they turned out. I added a dusting of powdered sugar on top as I just needed an extra hint of sweetness, but overall loved the recipe. Your mom knows what makes a good cookie! I wrote about my attempt at this recipe on my blog – Thanks again for a great recipe, another one from your cookbook with a big star next to the title (means I need to make it again)!

  270. Erin

    Hi!!! Love your blog! And love these cookies I made them yesterday.. Unreal!!! Perfect!! Have you ever tried altering the recipe for the classic white vanilla cookie I love the texture of this cookie, the right amount of “chew” something I have been looking for in a roll out cookie. I know I could leave out the coco.. But what in place? Extra flour? Any suggestions would be awesome… Making another batch tomorrow, not sure where they all went ;-)

  271. Molly

    I have been wanting to try this recipe for some time, and today was the perfect occasion – made little groundhogs with this dough for Groundhog Day, and they turned out both cute and delicious! Will be making these again for Valentine’s day with students at work!

  272. sara

    Just made these. Not sure what I did wrong! The dough was very dry and extremely messy and hard to work with. It was very crumbly. Any tips or advice for next time? They smell amazing, the dough tasted wonderful and the baked cookie still is pretty good but a bit dry. Please help!

  273. deb

    Hi Sara — I wonder if you may have packed your cups of flour on the heavy side, which leads to extra flour in the dough, and dry, crumbliness. Bake them on the scant side; it’s okay if they look a touch underbaked coming out of the oven; they’ll firm up as they cool and taking them out on the early side will ensure some tenderness remains in the center. And make sure they’re a full 1/4-inch tall. You’ll need that full height to get the brownie effect. Hope that helps.

  274. Debbie

    Thanks to you and your mom for a wonderful recipie. I love how the cookies stay true to the cut shape. To make a non chocolate sugar cookie do you think substituting flour in the amount equal to the cocoa would work or could you please suggest an alternative?

  275. Debbie

    Just wanted to share that swapping 2/3 cup of flour for the 2/3 cup cocoa yielded the most beautiful non chocolate sugar cookies I have ever made. Again, the cut shapes stayed true and the taste was great. As wonderful as this recipie is for the chocolate cookies, the same is so for using this recipie to make tradional sugar cookies.

  276. Tasha

    Your photos have done it. I saved this recipe in my Pinterest for later, and the later finally came earlier today! Gorgeous cookies, precise recipe, had fun baking them. Will definitely repeat :) Thank you!

  277. Masha

    I always make these cookies when I want to have something a little “fancier” than brownies (fanciness is directly correlated to production time, obviously) and also at every Christmas. Everyone gobbles them up like crazy, even more than the gingerbread! Thank you so much for such a successful recipe.

  278. Danielle

    I baked over 300 of these yesterday for teacher gifts, and they turned out lovely. Thanks as always for the beautiful recipes!

  279. Sarah

    These are SO good! When I made them the first time, they tasted mysteriously kind of nutty. I meant to make them with almond extract when I made them again, but didn’t have that when I decided to make them today, so I chopped up almonds until they were powdery and put them in some of the batter.

  280. Sal

    I am half way through making these amazing biscuits for the second time this week. The first batch I iced with icing sugar/cocoa powder/water. This batch is going to be ice-cream sandwiches with cookies and cream ice-cream. Can’t wait!

  281. Nettie Baker

    Hey Deb!
    There was a pdf that someone put together of chocolate cookie recipes. Since I had made your Ice Box Cookies, and was the toast of the town with those, I decided to give this a try. No disappointment at all! My son is waiting for them to bake! He can’t wait to dig into these. LOL! I loved the cookie dough all by itself. It is remarkable and fantastic. This is the best that I have run across. Love you!

  282. evl

    O.M.G! I was craving a chocolate cookie and didn’t have time today for World Peace cookies (my husband’s favorite). So I made these up and stuck them in the fridge while preparing dinner ingredients.
    Now that we’ve baked and taste-tested them, the trick will be having any left by dinnertime! Like Sara, I found the dough too crumbly to roll out straight out of the fridge, but after I let it sit at room temperature for 15 minutes it was very easy to work with. I made them ¼” thick and got about 3½ dozen. These would make dynamite ice cream sandwiches, but being lazy I think I’ll just eat them with a bowl of ice cream :-). Thanks for another GREAT recipe!

  283. VL

    Made these last night and the dough was easy to work with and the chocolate flavour was just great! (I used good old Hershey’s only). Thanks for a great recipe, Deb!

  284. Jenny

    Hmm….I had a “dry cookie” experience here, too. I used a balance to measure all my ingredients, so it’s quite unlikely that there was to much flour. The cookies came out with a sort of tang to them, and not very sweet, either. I had natural cocoa in the pantry, and demerara sugar (not granulated white); could these switches have caused texture or flavor changes?

    Otherwise, @321 from Deb, I did make them as refrigerator slice & bakes, and it was a very tidy way to get consistent 1/4″ cookies (rolled the dough log in chopped hazelnuts, too, BTW — going for that nutella effect).

  285. Jenny

    Take 2, with the other half of the dough: I turned down the oven 20 degrees, and baked them for a shorter time; until the tops only just started to look dry. Much better. I still think regular sugar would perform better (that’s the recipe, after all!) because it might hydrate better?
    Thanks, Deb!

  286. deb

    Hi Jenny — I’m glad it all worked out. Slight underbaking is definitely the way to go so that this is less of a shortbread or sugar cookie and more brownie-like. That, and the full 1/4-inch. (We made them shorter, more of a standard height growing up, but they were mostly crisp. I prefer them this way.) Hard to say whether the coarse sugar would affect it — did it seem gritty in the end? 1 cup of coarse/turbinado sugar weighs barely 10 grams less than 1 cup granulated, and sugar adds moisture, so it could throw it off, but barely.

  287. Allie

    Could I sub in flour for the cocoa powder to make a plain sugar cookie? I am making some cookies for a cookie decorating party and I want to also have a plain option.

  288. Amy

    Hello! Do you think these would work well as a cookie dipped in candy melts? (at least part of it). Thinking of making some mickey mouse shaped cut outs, and dipping the bottom 1/2 in red candy melts for the pants. Would they hold up? Thanks!

  289. Lauren

    Hey Deb!

    Love your blog and always trust the recipes on here! Last night I had an unfortunate failed attempt at making these cookies — they came out tasting very much like flour. Any idea what went wrong here? I used three cups of flour and added slightly extra baking powder, but not sure why the flour taste was so overpowering… Also, I must confess that our bodega (nyc resident) did not have any cocoa, so I substituted with chocolate chips instead — didn’t think that would change much though. Thanks for your time, would love to make these (successfully) again!

    1. deb

      Lauren — It’s hard to say, but it definitely helps to have the cocoa here. In a recipe like this, cocoa doesn’t equal chips in terms of substitutions; they won’t work the same here. WAs there a reason for the extra baking powder? The most key thing, I’d say, is to use a good cocoa that you love the taste of here. They’re what makes the cookies brownies.

  290. Michelle

    Was looking for a replcement recipe for my Christmas chocolate peppermint cookies so I added 1/2 tsp peppermint extract and chocolate chips to this recipe, and they turned out crazy delicious. So good.

    Also, I don’t own a rolling pin, so if anyone else (who is lazy and sans rolling pin) is wondering, I rolled them into little balls and baked them for 11 min and they turned out just fine. They don’t spread though, so if you don’t want ball cookies, you’ll need to flatten them down before.

    Thanks for the recipe!

  291. Julie

    These were yummy! Seriously….moist and not crunchy. I left them a bit thick so they would be more brownie-like. Would definitely make these again! Oh, I used Dutch cocoa…and it was great.

  292. Laura

    Hi Deb,
    I am not familiar with the cocoas you mentioned (Droste, Galler or Valrhona). Do you purchase those on Amazon? Additionally, I was wondering if the cocoa from King Arthur Flour would be considered “good stuff?” Thank you!

  293. Laura

    I live in NW Arkansas – so I usually have to buy online. I happen to have some King Arthur Flour cocoa on hand, so I was wondering if it would be “good cocoa” or if I should order on Amazon? Thanks for your help! :)

  294. Laura

    Thanks for your help! I think I will try it. It’s described on their website as, “A rich, dark blend of Dutch-process and black cocoas with complex superior flavor and color.” In appearance in my pantry, it’s very dark…much darker than the Hershey’s that is also in my pantry. :)

  295. Jennifer

    I am trying to find a way to make a twist on hamentaschen. My kids love brownies above all other baked goods. Do you think these will fold up if cut in circles? Thinking almond and raspberry filling…

    1. deb

      I can’t be sure, but I’m not sure if they’d bend and stay folded well enough to work as hamantaschen. That said, you could replace 1/4 to 1/3 the flour in most hamantaschen recipes with a good dark cocoa for a similar chocolate effect.

  296. Sarah

    Deb, I am tasked with making “something chocolate” (usually brownies) for a tea fundraiser at my church. I don’t usually go in for cute, but I found a really cute tea pot cookie cutter…do you think these cookies would hold their edges well in a small cut-out? And taste VERY chocolate-y? Or would you recommend one of your other chocolate wafer cookies more? Or do you think this whole idea is half-baked and I should just make brownies and keep everyone happy? Thanks for your thoughts!

    1. deb

      Sarah — What will make or break how chocolaty these are is the cocoa you use. If you’ve got a beloved dark cocoa around, use it here. Otherwise, you might get more oomph from the chocolate sables (again, the cocoa you use counts, but maybe a touch less since there’s also grated chocolate in it), chocolate wafers (which again hinge on cocoa, but use so much, the quality can be somewhat forgiven) or the Dorie Greenspan/Pierre Herme classic, World Peace Cookies.

  297. Taylor

    Made these cookies today and they are fantastic. :) They hold their shape very well. And are rich but still fluffy and light. Thank you!

  298. Mikaela

    These were very easy to make and they turned out great!! Will definitely be keeping the recipe for more parties they were a hit!! Thanks for sharing this recipe!!

  299. Lauren

    I made roll out shortbread at Xmas time with terrible results. But this was a winning recipe. I’m inspired to try others now!!

  300. Heidi

    I’ve been looking for ways to use up the mint in my backyard and tried making these with half mint sugar (2/3 c. sugar, 1 c. fresh mint in the food processor). It worked! But next time I’ll use more mint sugar – the mint flavor could stand to be a little stronger. It was fun to try, although most recipes use mint extract. Anything to put a dent in the mint crop! (And not end up with something tasting like Girl Scout Thin Mints, lovely as those are.)

  301. sara

    Well, i’ve been looking for a recipe that i could use my cookie cutters with. I came across this one, and I have to say… these are amazing! I decided not to use the vanilla (i usually don’t use it with cookies) and started eating these as soon as they were cold enough, and i just can’t stop!
    Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!

  302. Julia

    I made these using Penzey’s natural cocoa powder and an equal amount of Star Kay White chocolate extract instead of vanilla extract for extra chocolate-y punch. I liked them the first day, but actually thought that the flavor was better developed the day after I baked them. They don’t really harden up much more in the freezer, so I can see how they would make great ice cream sandwiches.

  303. Stephanie

    I am sad to say that I just made these and they seem REALLY dry :( They are soft, but DRY. I think it is a little too much cocoa for me too because it was almost like a bitter chocolate taste and not sweet. Any suggestions for what I can do to make them less dry if I try this again? Like I said they are super soft but the taste was just not there for us. The only thought I had was to maybe try less cocoa next time but I was not sure that would help. Thanks for the help.

  304. Gerilyn

    Hey Deb! Just wanted to point out a typo in the paragraph above the last photo; you wrote “dangeous” instead of “dangerous”.
    My cookies from this recipe are currently chilling in the fridge. Love you and all you bake!

  305. Allison

    These were awesome! I had a disaster trying to use my cookie stamp letter set. My search for recipe that would work led me to your recipe. Thank you!! We used it for halloween cookies and the other half for my cookie letter stamps and my ice cream pan tonight. I’ve had this pan for years and never had anything come out that works for ice cream sandwiches. Til tonight! I enjoyed that sandwich so much! Your right it is brownie like. It holds the stamp and is tender for ice cream! I’m in love and thinking what else to make with this recipe! Hooray for yummy cookies!

    1. deb

      Em — You can bump it up by 1/4 teaspoon, but it may not be necessary. (I’m realizing I’ve been making these cookies for years totally ignoring the adorable lightly salted direction and do not bump up the salt.)

  306. Sarah

    Laura, I found these froze beautifully! I put them on a sheet pan for about 20 minutes first, then into freezer bags, so they wouldn’t stick together. I baked mine quite a bit less time than indicated–they were best when they stayed brownie-like in the center. A great recipe for a cookie exchange!

  307. Ivana

    I made these (from the book) last night and had a major disaster – the dough was way too soft. I had chilled it as recommended and all my measurements were correct.
    I ended up scooping the dough with spoons (even that was a challenge) and letting it melt down into a flatter shape during baking (like chocolate chip cookies). The taste is fine, but I’m wondering what I did wrong. Could it be that I overbeat the butter? I notice a lot of your cookie recipes say “beat butter and sugar until fluffy” – but I’m never sure what to consider fluffy in this case…

  308. Jannette

    Ooh these look delish! I scrolled through all the posts trying to see if you mentioned how long you mix the butter mixture for. Is it until just mixed or until it is fluffy ( like creaming butter and sugar)

  309. Jeannette

    I didn’t bother reading through 400+ comments to see if this has been mentioned yet, but this dough makes a great slice and bake cookie too (because have you ever tried rolling and cutting out cute cookies with a baby? Let me tell you, it just doesn’t happen.) And, my “I don’t like dessert” husband loves them! Hurray for wife/mommy brownie (ha!) points. Thanks for a great recipe Deb!

  310. Daisy

    These are excellent! I’m doing late minute Christmas baking and didn’t want to bake regular sugar cookies. I’ve going to pipe a bit of royal icing tomorrow to add a bit of sweetness but it’s amazing by itself. I used Droste (Tip for NYCers they sell it in the food section of bigger Bed Bath and Beyonds) and added 2 1/2 tsp of espresso powder to the dough. It gave it a bit of bitterness that worked well with the chocolate. Not crumbly at all. Rolled to 1/4 inch and used 2 inch decorative cookies cutters. Baked for 8 minutes for a fudgey middle. Thanks Deb for the great recipe!

  311. Hel

    I LOVE these cookies. I’ve made them twice already this rollout cookie cutout season for the purpose of decorating them… and I ended up eating so many plain instead because they’re just sooo good. They’re perfect, they keep their shape, they don’t fall all over the place, they’re soft, they’re just ugh delicious. I never thought I’d find a rollout with-icing-on-top cookie I could make cute AND delicious. Thank you!!!!!

  312. Joan

    I just found this recipe, and I made a batch. The dough was so easy to handle, and the cookies are DELICIOUS! I’m going to try the toasted coconut shortbread next.

  313. Shana

    These cookies are delicious! They are the BEST chocolate cookie I’ve ever tasted and I’ve tasted a lot of chocolate cookies! I just made them for my twin daughters’ birthday party and many people asked for the recipe. I highly recommend this recipe. I used Hershey’s cocoa. I’m going to make them again for my daughters’ Valentine’s party exchange.

    1. deb

      Amy — They should be fine with those, but you’ll want to make them thinner. We used cookie cutters like that (well, with Hanukah designs!) growing up and they definitely can take texture, but we didn’t make them as thick as I do today (the full 1/4-inch). They also didn’t get as brownie-like though when thin.

  314. Skye

    Just wanted to thank you for sharing this recipe!
    I’ve used this recipe over and over, and every time these chocolate-flavored cookies are a big hit!They don’t spread and taste great – I’ve found THE chocolate roll-out cookie recipe here.

  315. Lynn

    Made these over the weekend…so yummy!! Definitely like them thicker to add to the brownie-like texture. I only baked them 5 minutes and sprinkled added sea salt on the tops before baking.

  316. Sue

    I made these cookies tonight and they were a disaster. Way too much flour, I believe, even though I followed the recipe exactly as written. They turned out hard and the dough was brittle. I don’t know if there is any way to salvage the other half of the dough or not. Luckily, my husband will eat anything, so the first half won’t go to waste. Is there any chance that 3 cups of flour is a misprint? My dough just got drier and stiffer as I added the flour, but I followed the recipe. After refrigerating the cookie dough for over an hour, I let the first half sit out for a little while to see if it would become more pliable. Anyway, they have a good flavor, but just turned out very hard. Maybe I did something wrong, but I took my time and followed the recipe exactly as written.

    1. deb

      Sue — There is absolutely no misprint here; we’ve been making this recipe as written my whole life. The tricks are two-part, roll them thick (a full, even generous, 1/4-inch tall, these will not be tender if standard thin) and to slightly underbake them (so that they’ll set up with a brownie-ish center). It sounds like yours baked too long (baking times often need to be adjusted to each oven).

  317. Sue

    Well, Deb, I made a discovery and now I know it’s not the recipe. I had recently purchased new measuring cups at a local grocery store. I used the new measuring set when I made those cookies. Tonight, I started to make some pie dough, I took a good look at the one cup measuring cup. It appeared to be bigger than my older one cup measure. So I did a comparison, and the new measuring cups are not accurate! They hold at least two tablespoons more flour than the older one cup measure did. I never knew it was possible for measuring cups to be inaccurate. Looks like I will have to stick with my old Tupperware cups. I will test the others in the set, as well, but I’m sure they all have the same issue. I also bought a matching set of measuring spoons. I apologize for doubting your recipe!