come on thunder
I don’t know about you but when I arrived at work yesterday I had both the appearance and seething demeanor of a wet cat. I don’t know what exactly the point of carrying my green flowered umbrella was, if to get utterly soaked just the same, making my way through two phone calls irked by a lingering unpleasant zoo-like scent that turned out be emanating my sopping wool pants. Yech! After work drink thing? Cancelled. Pedicure? Cancelled. Tomato soup and grilled cheese sandwiches? Oh, it was so on.
It’s funny, you know, when I talk about these “classic homey foods,” these “best childhood memory meals,” as I must confess that they’re not mine. We ate grilled cheese, but never tomato soup; we loved mac-and-cheese, but all I ever wanted was (of course) Kraft. I believe I had Campbell’s tomato soup a few times at friends’ houses, but never thought it was anything to write home about, as well as more than my share of tomato bisques at restaurants, but too often they reminded me of pasta sauces, excessive at even a cup at a time. But, with times as appropriate as this long, wet winter ahead and sources as good as, yet again, The America’s Test Kitchen Cookbook, this seems as good as a time as any to start making our own, because these recipes are keepers.
This time, Cook’s Illustrated crew was searching for “a perfectly smooth soup with rich color and great tomato flavor” and I enthusiastically applaud their efforts. This soup is fantastically rich in flavor, a whole lot more than you’d expect from your typical puddle of orange. More impressive is how they coaxed that flavor from something as everyday as canned tomatoes. The roasting step brings out their boldest intent, and the caramelizing of the shallots in the butter is reminiscent of the dreamy base of French onion soup. You use nearly every part of those canned tomatoes, which I love, because why dump that liquid carted over here from San Marzano? It’s the least you owe your food miles. I’m sure tomato soups can be made with far fewer steps - and admit to tossing the directions to the wind in step three - but I doubt they’re as layered in complexity as this deceivingly simple-looking one.
Now, the grilled cheese would have been better had I followed the recipe more closely. I cut my bread class rustic white loaf too thick and spread the cheese too thin, but neither of us complained. My classic Deb grilled cheese sandwich is emmanthel or gruyere, a couple leaves of arugula, a slice of tomato, salt and pepper on bread grilled on a panini, but something as humble and unassuming as smooth tomato soup seems no place for such fancy. We had the soup and sandwiches ready just in the nick of time, as the opening scene of Lost was already rolling and OMG, I don’t want to ruin the rest. Warmed, full, dry and rested at last, it was an excellent Wednesday night.
Cream of Tomato Soup
The America’s Test Kitchen Cookbook
2 (28-ounce) cans whole tomatoes packed in juice, drained, 3 cups juice reserved
1 1/2 tablespoons dark brown sugar
4 tablespoons unsalted butter
4 large shallots, minced (about 1/2 cup)
1 tablespoon tomato paste
Pinch ground allspice
2 tablespoon all-purpose flour
1 3/4 cups chicken stock, homemade or canned low-sodium
1/2 cup heavy cream
2 tablespoons brandy or dry sherry
Salt and cayenne pepper
1. Adjust oven rack to upper-middle position and heat oven to 450 degrees. Lines rimmed baking sheet with foil. With fingers, carefully open whole tomatoes over strainer set in bowl and push out seeds, allowing juices to fall through strainer into bowl. Spread seeded tomatoes in single layer on foil. Sprinkle evenly with brown sugar. Bake until all liquid has evaporated and tomatoes begin to color, about 30 minutes. Let tomatoes cool slightly, then peel them off foil; transfer to small bowl and set aside.
2. Heat butter over medium heat in large saucepan until foaming. Add shallots, tomato paste and allspice. Reduce heat to low, cover, and cook, stirring occasionally, until shallots are softened, 7 to 10 minutes. Add flour and cook, stirring constantly, until thoroughly combined, about 30 seconds. Gradually add chicken stock, whisking constantly to combine; stir in reserved tomato juice and roasted tomatoes. Cover, increase heat to medium, and bring to a boil. Reduce heat to low and simmer, stirring occasionally, to blend flavors, about 10 minutes.
3. Pour mixture through strainer* and into medium bowl; rinse out saucepan. Transfer tomatoes and solids in strainer to blender; add 1 cup strained liquid and puree until smooth. Place pureed mixture and remaining strained liquid in saucepan. Add cream and warm over low heat until hot, about 3 minutes. Off heat, stir in brandy and season with salt and cayenne. Serve immediately. (Soup can be refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 2 days. Warm over low heat until hot; do not boil.)
* This is the point where Lost was set to begin in t-minus 5 minutes and I’d had enough with the recipe, plunging in the immersion blender until smooth, adding the cream, reheating for a moment, and splashing in the brandy, measurements be damned -maybe Jack will kill Ben tonight! - so a little light on the cream and heavy on the brandy, and the soup lacked for nothing. Oddly, it didn’t need a lick of salt or cayenne, or perhaps I didn’t notice because Lost was so good.
Classic Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
The America’s Test Kitchen Cookbook
3 ounces cheese (preferably mild cheddar) or combination of cheese, grated on large holes of box grater (about 3/4 cup)
4 slices (1/2 inch-thick) from white sandwich bread, such as Pepperidge Farm Toasting White
2 tablespoons butter (preferably salted), melted
1. Heat heavy 12-inch skillet over low to medium-low heat. Meanwhile, sprinkle a portion of cheese over two bread slices. Top each with a remaining bread slice, pressing down gently to set.
2. Brush sandwich tops completely with half of melted butter; place each sandwich, buttered-size down, in skillet. Brush remaining side of each sandwich completely with remaining butter. Cook until crisp and deep golden brown, 5 to 10 minutes per side, flipping sandwiches back to first side to reheat and crisp, about 15 seconds. Serve immediately.






Both look amazing! I love that the soup has so little cream. I will definately try this one.
haha we are addicted to Lost as well!! Too bad the next one will be in Feb…what will be my weekly addiction from now until then!?! Also, you guys eat a late dinner!
I realize that I put one too many exclamation marks in that comment above (I just have this compulsive habit of putting those suckers in when I don’t really mean to be so enthusiastic haha)
Mmmm…that sounds amazing. Tomato soup is one of my favorite foods in the whole world. I’ve tried many recipes and have found some I love, but am always open to something new to try.
Does anyone have a subcription to Cooks Illustrated? I wanted to sign up but being in Canada and my city name being longer than 13 letters, it is erroring out on me. The 800# is only in US and I can’t find an email address to try to get to customer service. I was wondering if someone with a subcription could find out for me how Canadians need to fill out the subscription webform OR would it be better to just sign up for yearly access to the website? I tend to like to have the actual magazine to flip thru. Or I can buy the Cooks Illustrated 2005 which I am guessing would have all the recipes from 2004 or 2005 for about the same price as the yearly web subcription… too many choices…my head hurts…
i can’t wait to try out this tomato soup recipe…. it sounds sooo YUMMY!!!
have some mercy! I´m drooling over here. The sight of that crispy sandwich after having had lunch is no good… good thing I´m going to yoga in a little while so I can concentrate in NOT eating a sandwhich right this very second hahaha
I have never had tomato soup before, but this sounds like a good place to start. I should hurry up and make it soon before summer makes me abandon soups altogether.
(PS: when you have the time, check out my blog, it´s hilarious, my first commenter ever accused me of stealing your photos!)
Rock on! I am loving the giant grilled cheese. I never did the tomato soup combo myself (more of a ketchup girl), but this version seems way more appetizing than the one with instructions of “Open can. Dump.” Soup and sandwich is definitely a match made in heaven.
I’ve been totally craving this very meal! I am only just getting my feet wet in the cooking department, so have relied on pre-packaged goods to get by. I am absolutely in love with Pacific Foods, Roasted Red Pepper and Tomato Soup. The peppers add a wonderful sweetness! Think I’ll have to test my growing cooking skills on this recipe.
Once again you have solved the “what’s for dinner tonight” mystery! Thanks!!!!
yum. when are you coming over?
This looks sooooo yummy!!!! The perfect winter food! I can’t wait to try it… although I might be tempted to put my go-to cream of tomato soup garnishes in here - a bit of basil and some grated parm…
Deb… I know this means work, but you should post a listing of all your cookbooks (including specific edition information), and perhaps a brief review of each. I’m always curious what cooks keep on their shelves for inspiration!
Thanks again for the great website and all the wonderful inspiration!
Love, Love, LOVE grilled cheese and tomato soup. Yummmmmmm!
And ‘Lost’ last night? OMG.
February can’t come soon enough!
Oh, I can SO top that recipe. There is a restaurant in Missoula where I live that makes the most incredible tomato soup ever. I order it for breakfast. :-)
4B’s Cream of Tomato Soup
3-14 oz. cans diced tomatoes
12 oz. chicken broth
2 tb butter
2 tb sugar
1 sm. onion, chopped
1 pinch baking soda
2 c. cream
Mix tomatoes, chicken broth, butter, sugar, onion and baking soda in a large pot and simmer for 1 hour. Heat cream slowly in a double boiler - DO NOT BOIL. Add cream to tomato mixture and enjoy!
Goes fantastic with grilled cheese.
Trust me, you’ll never go back.
Lisa - I even went easier on the cream. I find it takes so little to get that smooth flavor. I hope you like it.
S - I know, a three-month hiatus?! What do they think they are, the Sopranos? I wish I could quit them. As for dinner, yes, always too late. I didn’t realize the soup had so many steps, which is my excuse every night. Just the straining/seeding/laying out tomatoes was a good twenty minutes. And then they roast for at least 30! But worth it. Self-aware exclamation marks are acceptable, fear not.
Jessie - I think there are a lot of different types, this being the smooth, butter-flavored one. God, I miss it already. How many hours until I get home?
Lisa - I don’t, but (ALEX: HINT!) I hope to have one soon. Sorry.
Jnet - Let us know what you think. I say us - are we okay with this?
Marce - Yeah, that’s some crazy commenter, indeed. Being anonymous is always the first sign. Hurry before summer starts? Jealous!
RA - The grilled cheese are actually tiny thus I made three. It’s that narrow loaf of bread and my press-your-nose-in-it crop. You should totally try this soup!
Birdita - All I did was follow the recipe. That’s the beauty of these CI recipes - they always work. Swoon.
Married Girl - I aim to please. It was my exact feeling when I saw the recipe over the weekend.
Jocelyn - For your bday party, of course. I’ll be around, well, Saturday at least.
Jen - No basil! No parm! Actually, though I LOVE those flavors, they were exactly what I didn’t like about “marinara sauce-like” tomato soups. It confuses my simpleton taste buds. I wanted spaghetti with it.
Browneyedgirlie - February better come soon, because I swear, there hasn’t been a season that’s given us LESS info than this one. So frustrating that they don’t get this. As I said above, I wish I could quit it, but frankly, I’ve got not a chance.
Jessica - 2 cups of cream? Are you trying to kill us? I kid, I kid. I’m sure it’s tasty as hell.
I know it has two cups of cream, but trust me, it’s worth it. Give it a whirl one night when you’re really cold and it will redeem itself. Oh, I want a bowl right now…
Lisa - Cook’s Illustrated for Canadian Addresses subscription page is here:
https://w1.buysub.com/pubs/BP/CID/Subscribe_Todayb.jsp?cds_page_id=13375&cds_mag_code=CID&id=1163113285426&lsid=63131701254026215&vid=1&cds_mag_code=CID&cds_misc_1=%3Cscript+language%3D%27JavaScript%27+src%3D%27https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cooksillustrated.com%2Fs_code.js%27%3E%3C%2Fscript%3E
Ok, I am just going to go ahead and tell you this. I think that you have somehow found a part of my brain that remembers my childhood, because you have now given us the ultimate grilled cheese and tomato soup combo. This combo is in my definition, the search for the best two food items ever invented separately, let alone combined.
You frighten and amaze me.
As someone else said, I think I’m drooling. I love this for dinner on a cold, rainy night.
And yay for Lost. :)
oh boy. I recently tried a tomato bisque at our new Market District Giant Eagle and I have spent WAY too much money on that stuff already- it is phenomenally addictive and good. AND I just LOVE tomato soup and grilled cheese. I just can’t stand that one of the ingredients of Campbell’s is high fructose corn syrup!!!!
So, thanks for sharing this recipe. I adore C.I. and tape them every Tuesday on PBS and salivate over the recipes they make w/ such ease (many steps, but looks effortless… ah tv).
May have to try Jessica’s suggested recipe, too!
TGIF, tomorrow- perfect grilled cheese and tomato soup kinda day!
That tomato soup recipe (or a version of it) may be one of the first recipes I ever read in Cook’s Illustrated, and I remember thinking at the time how good it sounded. I need to get around to making it!
My favorite version of the grilled cheese sandwich is pretty much like yours but uses pepper jack cheese. It would be spectacular with tomato soup.
Two colds in the house, Cook’s Illustrated is the best, I think this is on for dinner tonight!
Mm, maybe I should try this. You know I grew up eating grilled cheese (and was AMAZED when I discovered the addition of a tomato slice…)… but I can’t get into eating/drinking tomato soup. I’ll give this a whirl one night but like you said, it reminds me of pasta sauce and, sorry but ew?! You promise it doesn’t, right?! :)
am I having a birthday party? I don’t even know who is in town. Just me you and Jess i guess.
WOW. I just made this soup last night, and it was amazing! I don’t even like tomatoes, but I absolutely loved this soup. I even posted about it my own blog, which is not generally dedicated to recipe making. Nice find.
Hope your arm recovers quickly!!
this was out of this world fabulous. how did i ever survive on campbell’s? I made it for my wee little one for his birthday dinner. thanks for sharing!
It rained here in DC over the weekend and this made the perfect Sunday dinner! Didn’t have any sherry or brandy at home (suprising :)), and forgot to pick up tomato paste. Still delicious and light years better than canned! Thanks, Deb.
I am snowed in today and I made a bastardized version of this. I had no cream so I used cream of chicken soup, plus my food processor is crappy and it didn’t turn out particularly smooth. But even so, it was SO delicious and perfect for a snowy day! I didn’t think I even LIKED tomato soup! Consider me converted.
I made the soup and sandwiches for my husband last week. At first he thought - why is she cooking such a non-gourmet meal (especially since I always make quick dinners), then when he tasted it — I received so much praise! He even took the leftover soup to work and distributed it to some of the girls. A few of them asked for the recipe, so he sent them this link. He was so proud of me :) Thanks!
I been using an old recipes from a NY Times cookbook for tomato soup. Can’t wait to try this one with the grilled cheese sandwich.
Those grilled cheese ‘wiches look delicious! Don’t forget to add plenty of butter and brown both sides.
I made the soup and sandwiches tonight and they turned out fantastic. I actually didn’t have brown sugar or all spice, so, I substituted white sugar and pumpkin spice mix and the soup was still so good. Thanks!